3 ms·
So are we going to ban biometric stuff on passports too? because they became mandatory since a few years ago in the EU.
by ekianjo 6y ago
So are we going to ban biometric stuff on passports too? because they became mandatory since a few years ago in the EU.
- notimetorelax 6y agoThe petition is to regulate not to outright ban it, it’s in the first 2 paragraphs of the petition. Biometrics in a passport may be one of the cases allowed under that law.
- Freak_NL 6y agoPassports are not used to track me without me knowing about it. I can restrict the places where I present my actual physical passport to borders and interactions with my government. Interactive ad billboards with a camera in them? Not much I can do about those except deface them with a sticker. CCTV? Can't do anything about that. I'm not against security cameras per se, but I want them watched and judged by human beings, not algorithms (and ad billboards should not record me at all).
- ekianjo 6y ago> Passports are not used to track me without me knowing about it. except every hotel, every flight, ever trip outside your borders... you make it sound like it's OK for your movements to be identified as long as it's outside the borders of your original country?
- g_p 6y agoI think this might come down to individual countries. I've stayed in hundreds of hotels throughout the UK, and never been asked for ID. I've flown hundreds of domestic flight legs, and on the non-budget airlines (budget ones use name change fees and paid changes to tickets as a major revenue stream) I've never had to show ID, and nor is it required. Going overseas, it's only needed for entering the country (and a cursory glance from the airline to assure themselves you actually have it, due to the high penalties they're charged for a returned passenger). I imagine therefore a lot of this is down to individual countries - in much of Europe they seem very keen to scan passports and ID documents at hotel check-in (often required by local legislation). I always felt this ironic given the (populist) view the UK is a surveillance heavy country, yet it was much of Europe that was being far more invasive in this regard in my experience.
- labawi 6y agoI think UK is more capable and doing more surveillance than most EU counties, but people in UK don't have ID cards, so they can't be required for most services.
- Freak_NL 6y agoWithin Europe standing advice from national governments is to have a copy of your ID prepared in advance for hotels to hang on to, with certain details blacked out (like the social security number if this is still present on the front of the passport) and the name of the hotel/camping/hostel/b&b written over it. The Dutch government even has an app that does this for you. Handing over your actual passport is not required, and the last I've heard the only places where these are actually demanded are pretty shady or just downright ignorant. I haven't had a problem handing over copies anywhere in Europe though. The hotels do need your ID's document number, and a copy suffices for this. Most only jot down the actual number and immediately hand back the copy. Rarely someone might ask to see the actual passport as proof that you have it, but I have never been requested to hand it over (and you shouldn't).
- g_p 6y agoSeems sensible. Interestingly, there's no persistent unique identifier on a UK passport (short of the personal details, which will be unique). But there's no SSN or equivalent on them, and no address. Passport number is a relatively infrequently used thing, on account of the fact it changes on any renewal or replacement. If you have two passports, they have two different numbers. Having a "non-ID" culture is a nice thing though - in the US, people need to show ID to board even a domestic flight. Having an app to help redact ID is a nice idea, but in my view is a fairly poor solution to a non-technical problem. If you didn't insist on having these places collect ID info, you wouldn't need the app. For proof of age, that's a good scenario where you likely do need ID (today), but in future should be able to use attribute-based authentication to pove this without disclosing anything.
- furyg3 6y agoI don't know the details of the proposed law, but there is a difference between collecting biometric data for the purposes of identification and for the purposes of mass-surveillance. It's about how and when the data is used. Biometric passports store a literal JPEG of your face, fingerprint, or iris on the chip, and it's up to the software on the entry gate/computer/phone to make the comparison between what's on your passport and your challenge. Even if both the original info on the passport and challenge data are sent to a central server for processing (or even if they are compared against the info in a centralized database), it's still being used to identify an individual. Besides that, the moment and circumstances of this identification are clear and regulated: a border crossing, a police stop, etc. This is quite different then using a network of CCTV cameras to look for particular individuals... or keeping track of how all individuals move through an area with CCTV footage, so that you can analyze behavior (or look for individuals after at a later date).