3 ms·
That doesn't really follow though: the US is very good at restricting rights when it wants to without any need for tracking. You just make whatever it is illega
by XorNot 6y ago
That doesn't really follow though: the US is very good at restricting rights when it wants to without any need for tracking. You just make whatever it is illegal, make compliance a responsibility of the individual (think taxes), and heavily punish anyone found in breach.
The US could eliminate whole classes of guns today by this simple measure. After the first 100 people are charged with felony possession after open carry demonstrating with their AR-15's, how many do you think you'd really see in public? From people with jobs and mortgages who can't afford a criminal record? When the police departments get given bonus pay per weapon destroyed?
It won't be many.
Making things illegal is easy, and stomping most of them out is easy. The database problem is more to do with positive policies where you're trying to give something to citizens, whether it's money or passage onto an airline.
- x3n0ph3n3 6y agoMost gun violence is gang violence, and the incentive model you are describing doesn't apply to those committing gang violence.
- XorNot 6y agoI'm not talking about whether gun control should be carried out. Or if gun ownership is the source of America's societal ills. I'm talking about the reality that getting rid of a large proportion of anything by the government has never been an issue of having accurate records. Again: make it illegal, make compliance an individual responsibility, punish breaches heavily, (optional) incentivise law enforcement to find breaches
- xirbeosbwo1234 6y ago>Most gun violence is gang violence I'm pretty sure this isn't true. The total number of people killed with guns in the US in 2011 was about 9900. See page 6 here: https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/hus11.pdf https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/hus11.pdf That year there were somewhere around 1800 gang homicides. See the bottom of this page: https://www.nationalgangcenter.gov/Survey-Analysis/Measuring-the-Extent-of-Gang-Problems https://www.nationalgangcenter.gov/Survey-Analysis/Measuring... Note that not all of those gang-related homicides involved guns. Note also that the methodology to describe a homicide as "gang-related" will tend to overestimate the rate of gang crime, since the most common methodology is to check whether anyone involved is a gang member even if the motive was not gang-related. See FAQ #5 here: https://www.nationalgangcenter.gov/About/FAQ#q5 https://www.nationalgangcenter.gov/About/FAQ#q5 I haven't done more than five minutes of reading, but the numbers I listed would have to be way off to make the majority of gun violence gang-related.
- inglor_cz 6y agoTax evasion would be much easier in all-cash economy, regardless of punishments. Banks and their databases are an important resource in fighting tax evasion.
- XorNot 6y agoThat's not comparable though - the better example I was thinking of is simply "would you transport a large quantity of cash across state lines?". And in the US, the answer is: heck no. Thanks to civil forfeiture, it doesn't matter how much evidence you have that the money is yours and obtained from legal activities, first and foremost it'll be seized the the money charged with a crime. So people just plain don't transport large sums of money around unless they absolutely have to, and get completely screwed over for it regularly. The common refrain when people get done for this is "well you shouldn't do that". It's completely unethical and a miscarriage of justice, but it's effective.
- inglor_cz 6y agoYour example is sort-of a chicken and egg problem. Authorities can only get away with civil forfeiture precisely because transporting of cash across state lines has become unusual enough. If millionaires had to haul their cash stashs across the USA when going on vacation, the police would polish their boots instead of trying to seize the money. It is always much more efficient to prosecute things that are rare. In contrast, recreational MJ use was never stamped out, regardless of the heavy punishments and resources thrown into the War on Drugs; it was widespread enough that it could not be eradicated by brute force alone.