3 ms·
> This is a convenient excuse to justify the expropriation of rents and property by bad actors who seek to use the color of government to impose their own valu
by Apocryphon 6y ago
> This is a convenient excuse to justify the
expropriation of rents and property by bad actors who seek to use the color of government to impose their own values on the rest of us.
Exactly, which is why rents and property should be abolished alongside taxes.
> Foraging populations lack the material surplus to pay taxes and the resources to fund a coercive apparatus tasked with extracting them.
https://www.jstor.org/stable/4500088?seq=1 https://www.jstor.org/stable/4500088?seq=1
> You’re arguing that they had no choice but to suppress the whiskey tax protestors?
It demonstrates that taxes are inescapable even in a society that ostensibly was founded on not paying taxes, to the point that the same society crushes those who are in arrears.
> [citation needed]
Yes, for the definition of coercion!
> How is property rights inherent violence?
See upthread.
> This is an incredibly ignorant statement and I’m uninterested in attempting to educate someone who appears to have such a closed mind. You’re wrong and if you care that you’re wrong, you’ll reconsider.
So you continue to insist on labeling me, but the point is that the ideas exist independently of labels and must be dealt with on their own merits.
> I’ve been assuming good faith, was that incorrect? Is this some attempt to troll me?
Just as philosophy begins with doubt, so also a life that may be called human begins with irony.
> The plains indians are a revisionist attempt at characterizing distinct, unfriendly, and warring populations as a homogenous body.
And there were more of them than homesteaders.
> The point is they either had property rights in the land, which were violated; or they did not, and there’s no basis upon which to look askance at their expropriation.
Ah, and here is a potential tangent into different cultures' conceptions of land rights, particular those of nomadic or animist backgrounds.
> That is to say, “not the least bit necessary.”
Very well, then describe a society that can operate without taxation or public decency laws, so far you have been promising a plan without explaining it.
> established that coercion is unnecessary
No, we haven't. We haven't even defined what coercion is.
> Not really, as taxation is coercive appropriation of economic value. We could easily express public decency and jaywalking as components of the terms of service that one agrees to in order to access another person’s property.
But not all forms of taxation are based on income or wealth. There are consumptive taxes. There are taxes that are more akin to fees. And all taxes can also be expressed as membership fees for citizenship, irrespective of economic value.
> Taxation is a claim on the product of another person’s labor or body.
Sales taxes and VAT surely aren't. Land value taxes are not. You are conflating all forms of taxation with income or wealth taxes.
> Why would they need to coerce people, if they agreed to it?
Why would anyone need to be coerced to pay taxes, if they agreed to pay them? How many tank divisions does the IRS have?
Civil courts can levy penalties. Are those penalties coercive, or are they agreed by those who agree to be bound by the court? Then, are taxes coercive, or agreed by those who agree to accept citizenship?
> When will people learn that it is necessary that someone else threaten you with violence and take your things?
Actually, the Lakota are a revisionist attempt at characterizing distinct, unfriendly, and warring populations as a homogenous body.
https://www.nebraskastudies.org/en/1850-1874/native-american-settlers/conflict-among-the-tribes/ https://www.nebraskastudies.org/en/1850-1874/native-american...
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> It demonstrates that taxes are inescapable It demonstrates the hypocrisy of Washington et al. It doesn’t demonstrate inescapability of anything. > Yes, for the definition of coercion! Feel free to include the definition when you substantiate your assertion. > See upthread. I responded to your assertion upthread, you have yet to substantiate your opinion that property necessarily implies violence. Are you able to do so? > But not all forms of taxation are based on income or wealth. There are consumptive taxes. There are taxes that are more akin to fees. And all taxes can also be expressed as membership fees for citizenship, irrespective of economic value. The common thread being the fact that a person extracts a payment through threat of violence. > Sales taxes and VAT surely aren't. Land value taxes are not. You are conflating all forms of taxation with income or wealth taxes. Those are also unilateral coercive claims on a nonconsenti g person’s labor. > Civil courts can levy penalties. Are those penalties coercive, or are they agreed by those who agree to be bound by the court? Then, are taxes coercive, or agreed to those who agree to accept citizenship? Both are coercive in the current system. Neither are necessarily coercive except insofar as calling them taxes implies that they are coerced. Its possible to have voluntary citizenship and voluntary dispute resolution. > Harvest sharing in hunter-gatherer societies takes the form of implicit taxes Use of the word taxation implies that they’re coerced but the anthropological literature suggests that this is voluntary. Foragers lack the ability to coerce payments from each other to any significant degree.
- Apocryphon 6y ago> It demonstrates the hypocrisy of Washington et al. It doesn’t demonstrate inescapability of anything. P’raps. But at least it's a case study from history. > Feel free to include the definition when you substantiate your assertion. It is difficult to agree on a definition, because once you suggest that any law with punitive measures is invalid, no matter how light the punishment is or how innocuous the law is, you can denounce anything from taxation to property rights to jaywalking as built on coercion. > Are you able to do so? It's not my opinion, it's Proudhon's, and we've already discussed it. If you wish to continue to engage this point then I will go dredge up his writing in more detail. > The common thread being the fact that a person extracts a payment through threat of violence. > Those are also unilateral coercive claims on a nonconsenti g person’s labor. Why is payment any more a concern- or an outrage- than punitive laws that force people to conform to public morality? Or prevent business owners from treating their labor as they see fit? Is it any more robbery to force a factory owner to pay a tax, than it is to forbid them from conducting business free of government regulations? Or any other law? Why are coercive claims on labor less valid than coercive claims on capital? > Neither are necessarily coercive except insofar as calling them taxes implies that they are coerced. Okay, then rebrand taxes as citizenship fees or community funding and this entire discussion is rendered moot. > Its possible to have voluntary citizenship and voluntary dispute resolution. Again, you seem to have a singleminded conception of taxes as something that is inherently coercive, possibly because of real-world oppressive and opaque tax regimes, rather than considering that people might actually voluntarily pay taxes, because they do want the public services and functions of government that their tax money is funding. And if you argue that there's a lot that you never agreed to funding, then I agree with you, but that's an implementation issue, not an argument from first principles conjured from pure logic in Plato's world of forms. > Use of the word taxation implies that they’re coerced but the anthropological literature suggests that this is voluntary. So really that's what it all boils down to. Taxation is oppressive language. We should call them public donations instead.