5 ms·
So here's what I'd love if other people here could help me understand. Sensitivity to VOC's is extremely dependent on the person. My father, for example, had t
by crazygringo 6y ago
So here's what I'd love if other people here could help me understand.
Sensitivity to VOC's is extremely dependent on the person. My father, for example, had the carpet redone cheaply in his office, and worked there happily 8 hrs/day without smelling anything and without any ill effects.
For me, on the other hand, the smell was noxious but bearable, but I'd start to feel lightheaded after about 15 minutes in there. My brother would get a terrible headache after just 5 minutes. (And this is us as adults, same size as him.)
Memory foam (e.g. in a pillow) also affects me, even after it's offgassed for weeks. I don't smell a thing, but it gives me a burning sore throat after I'm close to it for a couple of hours. But again, zero effect on my dad.
And so my big question is: I'm well aware that people have drastically different responses to VOC's. But does that mean VOC's harm people differently too, or are we all harmed the same?
In other words, does my dad have some kind of "protective" genes where the VOC's don't bother him because they harm him less, so he doesn't avoid them? Or are my brother and I better off because we're super-sensitive to them, so we escape the harm he might be suffering?
It seems like such an urgent public health problem, especially given how many people use memory foam mattresses and pillows. It just boggles my mind that I get a sore throat after just a couple of hours with one, while other people sleep peacefully all night.
- abarringer 6y agoIt seems the older generation is so much more tolerant of toxins than us younger ones. For instance, at company lunches it seems at least 50%+ of the 25-45yrs have allergies/glucose issues while the older generation pounds down whatever they want. I have so many friends that have crazy allergies and sensitivities to toxins and almost no boomers that do. Maybe all the weak boomers were weeded out in their youth with lawn darts and no bike helmets or something? Or more likely not exposed to so many toxins when younger?
- echelon 6y ago> Or more likely not exposed to so many toxins when younger? Or perhaps inversely, the older generation was exposed to more industrialized chemicals and their immune system developed a tolerance. Something akin to the hygiene hypothesis [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hygiene_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hygiene_hypothesis
- crazygringo 6y agoThere's a big difference between common traditional natural substances and industrialized chemicals though. My understanding is that our immune system learns through exposure that things like peanuts, pollen, gluten, etc. aren't bad, so lots of exposure to these things and playing in the dirt is healthy for kids. On the other hand, from my understanding, we don't build up protection to industrial chemicals. They're just poison, plain and simple. The more you accumulate, the more you're likely to die.
- echelon 6y agoHere's a good counter, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6454566/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6454566/ > Hundreds of chemicals (e.g. metals, epoxy and acrylic resins, rubber additives, and chemical intermediates) and proteins (e.g. natural rubber latex, plant proteins, mould, animal dander) present in virtually every industry have been identified as causes of allergic disease. In general, allergens can be classified as low molecular weight (chemical) allergens and high molecular weight (protein) allergens. These agents are capable of inducing immunological responses that are both immunoglobulin E and non-immunoglobulin E-mediated. --- IgE receptors can match against almost any shape. And they're not the only immune receptors or signalling pathways by a long shot. The problem is we often sample our environments when we're experiencing unrelated inflammation. Inflammation is a signal to our immune system that something's up. Unfortunately, a match during this time can and often does teach the body the wrong thing. If they find signal, they'll self-amplify against it, and you could be stuck with a new allergy for life.
- crazygringo 6y agoHuh, thanks. So now I'm incredibly curious -- the sore throat I get from memory foam. Is there any way to know whether that's simply a result of the VOC's damaging the cells in my throat directly? Or if it's an allergic reaction happening in that spot? I have definitely been curious why memory foam would give me a sore throat specifically, when the offgassing is making equal contact with my skin, sinuses, etc.
- abledon 6y agothe women who 'birthed' the boomers, were also a lot more 'hardy', cleaner air, very little electronics, more manual labour, outdoor activity etc... i bet that generation of mothers gave their infants good gut bacteria that set them up for success.... nowadays our best bet is probably to target a poop transfer surgery.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoPop a pill of PowerPoop! It's prophylactic! Persistingly pushing performance to perfection!
- Spooky23 6y agoLess plastics in everything is the big difference, IMO. Even a can of beans is lined with some sort of plastic film. My father-in-law was a fireman and was in anything from 10-15 fires/month from 1965-1975, most of that time in a rescue company where he would pull people out, without an oxygen mask because they didn't fit. He did it enough that his knees were shot. He smoked as well, and in now in his 80s, along with a big cohort of his buds. My brother-in-laws on both sides of the family are in fire service, and I've been to several funerals for guys in their 30s and 40s, who probably see 3-5 fires a year, are mostly fitness buffs and don't smoke. All for stuff like bladder cancer, esophageal cancer, etc. I know one of the theories is around fire protection gear causing carcinogens to be absorbed through sweat, and another issue is the toxic stew that is found in car or house fire smoke. Another factor to consider, newer houses are sealed up with poor ventilation and build quality. Your typical >1985 home is largely assembled with glue and don't ventilate well and tend to have alot of mold. My house is a circa 1920 average quality single family. It ventilates well in the summer, has few materials hazards other than some lead risk, etc.
- harperlee 6y agoWhen I was a kid I knew exactly one child with celiac disease; nowadays I know about several people, so I thought in that line. But this very year a childhood friend of mine became aware he has it. Nowadays I tend to think we are more attentive to these kinds of things, and older people rationalize symptoms or grow unaware of them, so they are no longer conscious of them.
- nineplay 6y agoI had a friend who threw up when she ate cheese. Today we would call her lactose intolerant. At the time she was told she was 'spoiled' and she would eat her mac-and-cheese or go hungry.
- solraph 6y agoHonestly, I suspect they have the same plethora of issues, they just ignore them. I've had fifteen years of gut & digestive tract issues, which I eventually narrowed down to fructans (garlic & onion being the worst offenders), and some fruits. This discovery lead to a train of people in my family removing them during shared meals, and various other people in my family (including a couple of boomers) also discovering they had the same issue!
- estaseuropano 6y agoOur olfactory system has no magic ability to detect what is or isn't dangerous. That an unpleasant smell causes headache/nausea is one thing, the long-term health impact should be expected to be independent of this.
- nwienert 6y agoIt absolutely does have a pretty magic ability to detect danger, that's sort of its purpose. As an example, last I checked, the human nose is the most sensitive device we have to detect spoilt milk. Taste, smell, touch, all our senses are pretty damn good at parsing danger when functioning normally. Though I would bet with really un-natural substances the reliability goes down.
- jack_h 6y agoThis is kind of true, but our senses have massive blind spots when it comes to dangerous things we encounter in nature.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mleonhard 6y agoYes, the human nose has evolved sensitivity to sulfide substances produced by bacteria that spoil food. For example, the humans can barely smell 0.001ppm of dimethyl sulfide (from decomposing vegetables) and 1ppm of formaldehyde [0]. Human noses are three orders of magnitude more sensitive to the relatively safe dimethyl sulfide than to the dangerous formaldehyde. Formaldehyde can harm you even when you can't smell it (at 0.1ppm [1]). [0] https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/00022470.1969.10466465 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/00022470.1969.10... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formaldehyde#Safety https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formaldehyde#Safety
- nwienert 6y agoMakes sense, though covered in my “natural” clause as formaldehyde practically doesn’t accumulate in nature as we find it.
- bromuro 6y agoVOC?
- tkzed49 6y agovolatile organic compound
- sojournerc 6y agoVolatile Organic Compound(s) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volatile_organic_compound https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volatile_organic_compound
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- narag 6y agoDifferent people has different sensitivity to different substances. Take musk. Musk is an organic substances coming from the glands of a few animals. It's one of the most common base notes in perfumery. Since perfumes became a mass market product, there aren't enough musk deers in the planet by some orders of magnitude to fullfill the demand. So they created "white" (synthetic) musks. Problem is most persons are anosmic to this one or that one white musk. Also white musks are not exactly biodegradable. Perfumists make cocktails of them to make sure you will feel some of them. A few people (sigh!) are anosmic to every polycyclic and macrocyclic musk. And this is for substances that their explicit mission is to be smelled. There are newer alycyclic musks much more biodegradable and most people can feel them. See Romandolide, Helvetolide, Rosamusk, if you're curious.
- briefcomment 6y agoWould love to know the answer to this. Epigenetics is a thing, so I could easily see later generations becoming more and more sensitive based on previous generations' exposure.
- linuxftw 6y agoThe reasons vary person to person, but methylation is one reason. There are metabolic pathways that remove these chemicals from your body. Some people have pathways that don't work as well as others. MTHFR is one mutation I know of that can cause this. This is kind of an emerging field, so there's no shortage of quackery, but the underlying metabolic pathway seems clear to me.
- galoisscobi 6y agoA few years ago, I had bad burning sore throat and two swollen lymph nodes but couldn't figure out what was causing it. Went to the doctor, but that didn't really help. Finally figured out that it was a new purple pillow (https://purple.com/pillows https://purple.com/pillows) I had bought. I put it in the closet for a few days and my symptoms went away. I then ended up throwing the pillow away.