4 ms·
> The ARM Macbook primarily benefits from a better manufacturing process, SoC integration and a better instruction decoder It sounds like that just boils down
by dangus 6y ago
> The ARM Macbook primarily benefits from a better manufacturing process, SoC integration and a better instruction decoder
It sounds like that just boils down to “it’s a better chip.” You’re even saying that the instruction decoder is better - that means it’s a better chip. What else does a processor do besides decode instructions?
How many aspects of the chip do we have to make excuses for before we can just conclude that the M1 is the overall best processor money can buy for a laptop?
Consumers don’t care that Apple is using a great TSMC process and Intel isn’t, they care about performance and battery life.
The M1 multi-core benchmarks are nothing to scoff at, either. They absolutely keep up with the more expensive, heavier, hotter, worse battery life 16” MacBook Pro Intel models - at least, they keep up close enough to not justify the $1,000+ price premium.
When Apple replaces the 16” model, the AS version is probably going to have 16+ cores and make the Intel version look absolutely silly. Just like the Intel MacBook Air, we’ll be asking ourselves how we lived with this x86 trash for so long?
- hctaw 6y agoI think OP is taking issue with the claim that the M1 can compete with desktop class CPUs, which isn't true for multicore benchmarks. The M1 is about on par with current Intel/AMD offerings in single core benchmarks but can't keep up in multicore. Compare: https://browser.geekbench.com/processor-benchmarks/ https://browser.geekbench.com/processor-benchmarks/ to https://browser.geekbench.com/mac-benchmarks/ https://browser.geekbench.com/mac-benchmarks/
- dangus 6y agoBut those benchmarks show that it does keep up until you literally throw more cores at the benchmark. Without going up to 10 cores, only 4 models on that list are faster than a Mac mini that costs $600, and those models are negligibly faster. And they can’t run on a battery for 15 hours like the M1 laptops. So it’s really just a nitpick surrounding the fact that Apple doesn’t sell an M1 with more than 8 cores yet, which Apple definitely will, probably within the next 6 months.
- hctaw 6y agoThat's not a nitpick, it's a legitimate issue with the chip. 8 cores is not consistent with the state of the art, it's consistent with low tier consumer CPUs. The other major issue is lack of memory (just by way of example, I allocate 16GB of memory on my local machine for VMs regularly - I can't buy an M1 Mac to do my work right now). And a Mac Mini only costs $600 if you're ok with 256GB of disk space (not enough) and 8 GB of memory (not enough) and no EGPU support yet (not sufficient). It's a cool toy right now.
- eyesee 6y agoThe M1 is a low tier consumer CPU, and the design choices are consistent with that positioning. In all likelihood this is the slowest M-series processor Apple will ever make. That it is competitive with some high-end processors is compelling, but what this might mean for the future is exciting to many.