5 ms·
F2P-with-purchases games should (a) require disclaimers, (b) be illegal and stiffly penalized for allowing minors to play, & (c) have their algorithms open to a
by ethbr0 6y ago
F2P-with-purchases games should (a) require disclaimers, (b) be illegal and stiffly penalized for allowing minors to play, & (c) have their algorithms open to a gaming regulator (in the same way Las Vegas does).
- Kaze404 6y agoI play a lot of Apex Legends and recently I found out that when you go purchase a loot box it explicitly tells you the chance of each item's rarity. My initial thought was that it's a step in the right direction (of banning loot boxes entirely), but it also made me wonder how anyone can be sure those numbers are actually true in their backend.
- PhillyG 6y agoIn some countries, games are legally required to do state rarity of items in lootboxes, so it may just be so that they are compliant with all countries. I forget which countries, but I think they're in central europe
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIt is also pretty useless. Normal people can't parse probabilities - otherwise nobody would play in the lottery. If you have a list of 20 items with non-uniform chances, can you tell how long you need to play before it's likely you'll get an item you want? You and me can, by doing little math in head; most people can't (and it's another question whether one has the willpower to do such math and follow it through while tired, unwindng in front of a casual game). What would be more useful if they listed the expected number of loot boxes you need to buy to get an item. "2% chance" reads differently than "you'll need to buy about 50 loot boxes, on average, to get that item".
- wizzwizz4 6y agoI'd prefer “you'll need to buy about 50 more loot boxes, on average, to get that item” as wording. Bonus if there's a question mark next to it that explains probability (specifically, why the gambler's fallacy is wrong – though not necessarily mentioning the fallacy).
- TeMPOraL 6y agoGood catch, I agree yours is better.
- tesseract 6y ago"Most <evil grin> players will get the item after buying 26 more boxes"
- pixelbro 6y agoWhile we're all patting ourselves on the back for understanding probability, the correct calculation is actually log.98(.5) = 34.3 = number of attempts required for a 50% chance of getting a 2% item.
- michaelmrose 6y agoWouldn't it be easier to just ban gambling apps including ones disguised as games from app stores? You could probably get virtually everyone by simply defining it as a game with in app purchases that provide probabilistic or in game performance improvements. If they can sell levels but not swords nothing of value will be lost.
- mod 6y ago> Normal people can't parse probabilities - otherwise nobody would play in the lottery. Yes, they would. The lottery is about giving up something of little value ($1 or $2) for some entertainment and the chance at a truly life-changing situation. I doubt anyone is unaware there's almost no chance they win, and that they're losing on every dollar they spend. Interestingly, the lottery is occasionally +EV to play. I otherwise agree, people are bad at gambling, probabilities, and understanding the long term. I play poker, and poker players are constantly furious that their 80% favorite hand doesn't win 100% of the time. 80% feels like a lock. Some people don't care. They want to gamble, and they have no regard for what they lose in the process. I think many humans are just wired this way, or perhaps it's cultural.
- mym1990 6y agoI agree, playing the lottery is a little like buying insurance for something. Everyone knows that insurance is a losing proposition, but no one buys it to save 500$ on that fender bender, people buy it so that they can get through a catastrophic event like 500,000$ in medical bills.
- telchar 6y agoI would hazard a guess that people who buy lottery tickets are much less likely to buy insurance than those who don't. I think some similar psychological mechanisms may be at play, but not in the way you are suggesting where they overestimate small probabilities across the board. I suspect it has more to do with discounting odds that are against them. But I wouldn't bet on it.
- wincy 6y agoWell because evolutionarily, gambling must pay off sometimes, and the people who are averse to gambling might become rarer if it pays off in a big way. Ten thousand years ago doing something risky might result in you going from being a male with no prospects to having a harem with 50 wives. It makes sense that when your ancestors could have made a risky gambled (say raiding the village next door), they’d go for it, much like someone will put everything on 21 Black because the payoff could be so big.
- svachalek 6y agoI don't think you realistically can trust these as there will never be serious audits, and they exploit all kinds of psychological weaknesses. They really just need to be illegal. Sell content piecemeal, sure. But not loot boxes.
- Kaze404 6y agoI agree completely. I would've spent ridiculous amounts of money on that game at this point if it weren't for loot boxes, but alas it wasn't meant to be.
- PoignardAzur 6y agoI don't have any more information than you do, but my gut feeling is "80% of companies won't bother to lie on the numbers, 20% will lie, and will occasionally provoke a scandal when they get caught in the rare audit or get the whistle blown on them by a spiteful employee".
- zigzag312 6y agoThey should also disclose a spending ceiling. How much do you need to / can you spend to gain access to all the content. Do I need to spend $60, $600, $6000, $60,000 or is there no limit?
- Darmody 6y agoMost of them don't have limits as you don't buy a DLC to unlock content. Games are almost infinite and money helps you advance. Mobile gaming is disgusting. And the few good developers that make good "traditional" games don't make enough money to keep developing.
- Tyr42 6y agoInterestingly enough, the Pokemon Picross game on the 3DS had a fixed spend limit of $50, after which you could just top up your in game currency for free. So either you did f2p, or you paid $50 and got a full game, or some linear combination of both. I liked that game and paid $50 for it.
- Shared404 6y agoHello fellow person who liked that game! I didn't know there were more of us. I never did spend any money on it though.
- kryogen1c 6y ago> F2P-with-purchases this misses the core issue. a game like path of exile is completely playable for free - and they release new content quarterly and yearly (again, for free). a game like Raid Shadow Legends is not - you very rapidly hit a paywall and it would take years of free play to acquire power equivalent to spending $100. the exploitative nature is pay to win, where youre simply playing a different game unless you spend money.
- lmm 6y agoThere's nothing wrong with an honest pay-to-win game. The dangerous part is the randomness.
- hakfoo 6y agoWhile I agree with your sentiment, I have to wonder if it would be possible to make a non-random pay-to-win game be compelling both from a financial and gameplay standpoint. Say you can buy max-level weapons/characters/whatever for a defined price. The meta rapidly breaks down to "this is the highest yield of power per dollar" and "the optimal build costs exactly USD 1143.76." It's not compelling for new players to say "I know that I'm going to eventually spend eleven hundred bucks if I love this game." You can't dangle the chance of getting a super-powered item on that first 99 cent lootbox to get someone on the IAP treadmill. I'd expect the game design itself would have to feature hard breakpoints to trigger a purchase/hundred hour grind moment. And then, how do you convince the whales to pony up 5 and 6 figures once they possess an optimal build? Fashion and equivalent power churn only goes so far.
- Spivak 6y agoEh I don't really think "think of the children" is the right narrative here. These games, while especially bad for children, aren't much better for adults. Absolutely require 18+ to play and require them be labeled as gambling but I don't think that's enough. If we're counting on adults "knowing better" which makes it okay to play these games while the industry profits on precisely those adults that don't then there's a problem.
- luplex 6y agoIn fact, we never marketed to children. Adults are much more profitable, because they can actually pay up.
- Sohcahtoa82 6y agoI don't have a problem with "F2P-with-purchases" as long as the "purchases" aren't random lootboxes and aren't gating progression or buying power. For example, I always felt that League of Legends had a good F2P-with-purchases model. There are a lot of characters you can play as, but you have to either unlock them by playing or pay a couple dollars to unlock one. But the more expensive characters aren't necessarily more powerful, they're typically just newer, and it doesn't take much play to unlock a character. Once a character is unlocked, there are skins you can purchases with money, but they're purely cosmetic.