3 ms·
It's understandable that people want control over property they don't own. Doesn't make it right though. And it doesn't make sense for the law to give them that
by triceratops 6y ago
It's understandable that people want control over property they don't own. Doesn't make it right though. And it doesn't make sense for the law to give them that control.
- pgsimp 6y agoI think it makes sense to give people some rights. For example if you build a highway right in front of their house, it devalues their investment, and they could deserve compensation. Or make it a garbage dump. Are you really of the opinion the the government should be allowed to simply create a garbage dump in front of your house? What about a garbage dump in a poor black neighborhood, would you consider that OK? It's possible there was a promise of "quiet surroundings and lovely views" when they bought the land from the government. So the government should stick to those promises.
- triceratops 6y agoYou're debating a strawman. The argument is that NIMBYs oppose more housing in a place already zoned for housing. No one's talking about building a nuclear power plant next to a kindergarten.
- pgsimp 6y agoIf the places are already zoned for housing, NIMBYs are unlikely to be able to prevent it.