3 ms·

Lori Gardi, widely believed to be a crackpot, in my opinion has made a breakthrough in our interpretation od quantum mechanics. If I understand her correctly,

Lori Gardi, widely believed to be a crackpot, in my opinion has made a breakthrough in our interpretation od quantum mechanics. If I understand her correctly, she proposes that the reason waves behave like particles is because they transfer energy essentially every zero-crossing : for example a photon is just one half of a wavelength of light. She has a much more interesting explanation of what i am very poorly tryingto spit out here on youtube. Bear with, because honestly she is a whackadoo but she is a smart whackadoo. Lemme know if you want a link to the video

jamiek88 6y ago
Why is it always YouTube videos with these (let’s generously say)esoteric ideas and never a link to a paper or essay?
- millstone 6y ago
  Not GP but since you asked, here it is: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/325462944_Planck%27s_Constant_and_the_Nature_of_Light https://www.researchgate.net/publication/325462944_Planck%27... The argument is: Planck's relation says that a photon's energy is in proportion to its frequency. But a higher-frequency photon oscillates more times per second. If you look at the energy of a single oscillation, you get a constant, regardless of frequency. This is remarkable and so we should reframe Planck's constant as the fundamental "energy per cycle." The problem is that "energy of a single cycle" cannot be related to other measures of energy, e.g. the binding energy of an electron in the photoelectric effect. Basically it seems like unit sophistry.
  - rpz 6y ago
    Sophistry is a bit strong of a term in my opinion. Physicists have received Nobels for inventing particles to balance equations. Why isn't that sophistry? Maybe we just need to spend a few more billion dollars on a brand new particle accelerator to figure that out.
rpz 6y ago
Yes I watch her stuff as well I appreciate her work although its not always consistent video to video. I recommend people check out https://forgottenphysics.com/ https://forgottenphysics.com/ Just a guess but I think this is probably where Lori got most of her inspiration at first

jamiek88 6y ago

Why is it always YouTube videos with these (let’s generously say)esoteric ideas and never a link to a paper or essay?

millstone 6y ago
Not GP but since you asked, here it is: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/325462944_Planck%27s_Constant_and_the_Nature_of_Light https://www.researchgate.net/publication/325462944_Planck%27... The argument is: Planck's relation says that a photon's energy is in proportion to its frequency. But a higher-frequency photon oscillates more times per second. If you look at the energy of a single oscillation, you get a constant, regardless of frequency. This is remarkable and so we should reframe Planck's constant as the fundamental "energy per cycle." The problem is that "energy of a single cycle" cannot be related to other measures of energy, e.g. the binding energy of an electron in the photoelectric effect. Basically it seems like unit sophistry.
- rpz 6y ago
  Sophistry is a bit strong of a term in my opinion. Physicists have received Nobels for inventing particles to balance equations. Why isn't that sophistry? Maybe we just need to spend a few more billion dollars on a brand new particle accelerator to figure that out.

rpz 6y ago

Yes I watch her stuff as well I appreciate her work although its not always consistent video to video. I recommend people check out https://forgottenphysics.com/ https://forgottenphysics.com/ Just a guess but I think this is probably where Lori got most of her inspiration at first