3 ms·
If you believe that fertility is negatively associated with prosperity, then the idea that people will buy these houses because they have children is especially
by jeffbee 6y ago
If you believe that fertility is negatively associated with prosperity, then the idea that people will buy these houses because they have children is especially wrong.
- majormajor 6y agoBut will they want those houses, though... The crisis described here is that more people want them than can get them. So if the trend is that more people will want standalone houses specifically, versus just any sort of housing unit, proposed solutions that reduce the supply of them are bound to backfire for areas that implement them. Basically: is this the start of a different era in terms of demand profiles, driven by remote work, or is this just a short-term bubble?
- jeffbee 6y agoBut why are we treating fertility as exogenous, rather than as a choice? Fertility is not exogenous. Demographers are predicting a 15% decline in live births in 2021 in the US, because women are choosing against pregnancy. It is long-studied and well-known that unemployment also depresses fertility. The idea that people will have children and buy houses just because they turn 30 is silly. They will not have children and they will not buy houses unless the environment in which those appear to be rational choices is established.
- sokoloff 6y agoI do believe that (see my other response to you). I don't believe that people buy houses because of children. I do believe they want to buy them because of children. I believe they actually buy them because/when they can afford them and prefer to live in a house they own over a rental. (Plenty of people have kids in rental housing, of course.)
- JKCalhoun 6y agoAnecdotal: rented until out first child was school-age. The school near where we were renting was not good so we decided to move. The thought of school and a child nurtures in you a kind of "long term" view. I believe that lead to our buying our first home rather than continuing renting. If we are planning on staying in the same place (school district) for 13 years it suddenly made sense to put down roots of a housing nature as well.