3 ms·
I feel like I got served an appetizer and a small dessert, with no main course in between. California has a housing crisis in some cities. Californians are mov
by sokoloff 6y ago
I feel like I got served an appetizer and a small dessert, with no main course in between.
California has a housing crisis in some cities. Californians are moving out of those cities. The cities that they're moving into are experiencing an increase in demand (directly restating the previous). That's pushing up prices (not shocking), which is preventing some people with less money from outbidding people with more money (also not shocking).
Conclusion: Single Family Zoning is bad, but only a few places have been enlightened enough to limit or ban it.
OK, maybe, but strikes me as an argument from declaration of opinion rather than a logical conclusion from the priors.
The only thing new I learned from this article is a rough estimate of how much higher an ex-Californian's budget is on average, which was novel but hardly surprising.
- kodah 6y ago> The only thing new I learned from this article is a rough estimate of how much higher an ex-Californian's budget is on average, which was novel but hardly surprising. My story related to this: Californians (and other comparatively rich people) moved to Dallas, TX in droves and outpriced an already saturated housing market. This was happening far before COVID but I think it was really mostly talked about in the circles of state to state income inequality which is largely ignored. When you have loans like the FHA or VA loan this means while you may be qualified for a loan, you'll never actually get a house near where you work in big cities. Instead, you're forced to buy in towns that are increasingly far away from these cities. As someone who has been through this nightmare I don't think "Single Family Zoning is bad, but only a few places have been enlightened enough to limit or ban it" is the right conclusion or even near it. Generally speaking, remote work can help alleviate this problem because then you remove the problem that I experienced which is that I was driving 2.5 hours to and from work every day. Some other things that I've read is that these people also destabilize the cost of goods in enough quantity. The outcome is that communities that have seen decades of development will soon price out the resident who paid for its development in taxes only to reward people who are taking advantage of inequality.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> The outcome is that communities that have seen decades of development will soon price out the resident who paid for its development in taxes only to reward people who are taking advantage of inequality. Sounds like the plight of poor people from developing/poor nations who have to contend with people from developed/rich nations.
- kodah 6y ago> Sounds like the plight of poor people from developing/poor nations who have to contend with people from developed/rich nations. Could be. What's your suggestion?
- lotsofpulp 6y agoNothing. Might makes right is the way nature works. People that harvest cocoa in Africa can't afford to eat chocolate. It's the same situation between rich/poor in the US.
- shuckles 6y agoCalifornia has a statewide housing crisis. Most cities in the country also have their own housing crises.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Most cities in the country also have their own housing crises. No they don't. The ones that do are the ones who's housing market is all jacked up by California money that wants off the sinking ship.
- shuckles 6y ago"If you ignore all the cities people want to live in, the remaining don't have a housing crisis."
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThere's half a dozen or so big east coast cities that are expensive. Nevertheless you can find $200-400k houses 1-1.5hr out (half that if you're willing to sacrifice having a big yard) and rents are blue collar levels of affordable despite those cities being some of the most expensive (basically second to CA). The "housing crisis" is unique to California and markets that are jacked up by California money that wants off the sinking ship. I know a lot of those people want to believe that everyone is doing it just as wrong as they are but if you fire up zillow and start looking at the suburbs of Cleveland, Buffalo, Montgomery, and all the other places that wealthy people leaving places like CA like to deride as dead or dying it becomes immediately apparent that they're affordable. Edit: I was a moron to even reply to you. Based on everything else you've said on this topic we will not see eye to eye and nothing productive will come of this.
- shuckles 6y agoHaving people drive til they qualify is a sign you have a housing crisis. Give me the name of some cities where home prices have tracked inflation in the last decade. Even better, tell me how Cleveland's suburbs have a land use regime that's any better than California?
- majormajor 6y agoDemonizing single family houses seems rather dated in 2021. Single family home prices are surging in much of California too (while apartment prices and condo prices... not so much!), it's not just "everyone is fleeing!" California was short on both types of housing - what has changed is that it is in even higher demand now! And if remote work continues after COVID, that will continue. Add to that more efficient electric cars + more self-driving capabilities, and I think the demand pendulum will continue to swing back towards sprawl. You also have a bunch of millennials still in child-bearing age ranges who are getting around to that. You won't fix a single family home demand surge by replacing single family homes with other things. "How will we make sprawl work better than it has in the past" seems a more useful question.
- jeffbee 6y agoPeople don't buy houses because they have children, they gather both children and houses because they are prosperous. Millenials (some of whom are now past their child-bearing years) and younger generations won't just get houses because of the inexorable march of time. First they'll need money.
- subpixel 6y agoActually, there is an inverse relationship between prosperity and child-bearing.
- jeffbee 6y agoOnly if you make improper global comparisons. Within comparable American populations, wealth is positively associated with fertility. "Examining data from 1985 to 2007, Lovenheim and Mumford use short-run home price variation over time within cities as their shock to family wealth. They find that a $100,000 increase in the value of one’s home results in a 16% increase in the probability of having a child." https://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/abs/10.1162/REST_a_00266 https://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/abs/10.1162/REST_a_0026...
- 6y ago
- KingMachiavelli 6y ago> Single Family Zoning It is bad and yet is one of the only housing types that satisfies a lot of needs. Multi-unit housing has the following list of annoyances: 1. Far more available to rent than to own. Some states such as CO have some weird insurance related laws that makes selling condos more of a liability than leasing apartments. 2. Often not cheaper on a sqft basis so you are paying more for less. 3. If it is for sale, there is often a hefty monthly HOA or Condo fee that increases with inflation/time. 4. Small parking lots* 5. Often up a few stories which make even moving groceries a hassle and moving furniture a real pain. 6. Noise from neighbors and rules/limitations when you can do noise generating things. 7. No garage/workshop area means repairing bikes and cars is a real hassle or you are paying someone else a lot of money to do it for you. 8. Dramatically less privacy and legal rights as far as what you are allowed to do to your property. 9. Almost always closer to roads and other noise producing things. 10. Neighbors are a far greater presence/annoyance in your life than even just living in the suburb. This has the added effect of reinforcing affluence/poor areas; buying a house in a poor/bad area is not nearly as risky as living in an apartment in a poor/bad area. Really the only advantage of living in higher density housing is the access to public transport, city centers, and the lack of maintenance you have to do to maintain the property. The good news is that a lot of people don't mind the above annoyances so building more high density housing has the benefit of making every type of housing cheaper. Its also possible that in large enough cities, apartments can be found larger & more noise insulated than in suburb/low density areas (at least I sure hope so). Essentially, does a single family home replacement exist? Town-homes are pretty close to satisfying the above list and are a lot more dense than SFH but are they dense enough to solve the scarcity problem? * Convincing those who can afford vehicles to get rid of them seems really difficult. e.g Anyone know how people travel for ski trips in Europe? I really can't imagine using American public transport when I need to transport luggage. Sure flying and trains are OK for traveling large distances but buses and local rail systems are difficult to use with luggage. It would be a comical attempt for a family of 4 to transport themselves & their stuff on a local bus yet an SUV makes this an (bi)weekly occurrence for people near ski resorts.
- genocidicbunny 6y agoI don't know that townhomes really satisfy that -- not any of the ones I've seen built recently. The ones I'm thinking of are those 10-to-a-lot townhomes that get squeezed into previously unused spaces or a handful of parcels that the developer managed to buy up next to each other. They usually have little to no land (no front yard and a meager backyard), restricted parking (I have seen two-car garages where you would need to go out through the sunroof if you actually parked two small cars in there.) and are often built as cheaply as possible at the lowest cost. Basically, a lot of the townhomes that I see being built here are effectively apartments and share many of the same annoyances you mentioned. With that said, it could very well be due to the same single family zoning issues -- it's very possible that getting permits for an apartment building in a predominantly SFH zone would be difficult. Getting permits for townhomes (which end up functionally apartments) is likely far more doable. To the question you pose about the SFH replacement -- I don't think that there is one. Even if homes weren't an investment vehicle, I think to a lot of people the appeal of a SFH is the whole package; By the time you satisfy all the desires with something else, you've arrived back to a SFH.