7 ms·
Nowhere is building enough housing for growth. In low cost of living places, chances are if you look at population data, the metro region has been stagnant for
by asdff 6y ago
Nowhere is building enough housing for growth. In low cost of living places, chances are if you look at population data, the metro region has been stagnant for decades which has alleviated pressure on supply. In any area with growth at all, prices rise because we don't build actual dense housing like we did before WWII (when row houses and mixed use development in walking distance to frequent public transit were the norm everywhere from Manhattan to Los Angeles to downtown Boise, Idaho). We build either tracts of single family homes by clearcutting wildlands adjacent to freeways, or far too little apartments in a single 4-5 story building spanning an entire city block.
In comparison to a block of 4-5 story row homes, these apartment builds are a compromise and will come back to bite planners in the coming decades as construction costs continue to rise. Since it's a single building, you can't redevelop this structure without leveling the entire block. That makes it impossible to do unless you are a deep pocketed development corporation, versus a row house that could be owned outright by an individual and redeveloped by that individual to meet the market demand of the growing city.
- jeffbee 6y agoIt's handy to say "nowhere is building" but it's not really supported by the data. Look at Dallas and Houston compared to San Francisco. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=B6Tc https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=B6Tc
- kwk1 6y agoYour quote chopped off an important qualifier present in the original comment.
- jeffbee 6y agoExplain? The fact that the population of greater Houston has more than doubled in 30 years tends to support the idea that they are building enough for growth. They've got a city the size of Berkeley that didn't even exist 50 years ago.
- fossuser 6y ago> The fact that the population of greater Houston has more than doubled in 30 years tends to support the idea that they are building enough for growth. This isn't enough to support the idea unless prices have also not climbed. The Bay Area population has dramatically increased and prices have too because building to support this growth has been fought by NIMBYs via bad policy.[0] As a result houses on the peninsula have reached insane prices and there is little available for new people, see: https://www.redfin.com/CA/Palo-Alto/3785-Park-Blvd-94306/home/1149731 https://www.redfin.com/CA/Palo-Alto/3785-Park-Blvd-94306/hom... Myself and many of my friends (~30yrs old) rent with multiple roommates. The only people that can buy experienced some sort of exit event or have a lot of FAANG equity with two FAANG incomes. Even then they have to pay property tax on that insane value that the NIMBYs don't pay. Maybe Houston has done a better job, but population increase itself isn't much evidence. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco_housing_shortage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco_housing_shortage Bad incentives for existing owners to restrict growth exist everywhere, but they're particularly bad in California because of Prop 13. The most frustrating bit to me, is that the NIMBYs that won the housing lottery and leverage their political power to screw everyone else also play victim. I hope one day we can pass something that corrects a lot of these bad incentives. The new RHNA housing policy and things like Sacramento's elimination of single family zoning are the way. SB50 and related policy would help too.
- jeffbee 6y agoI mean, population _is_ pretty good evidence of growth. 20 years ago Houston MSA was 15% larger than SF MSA and today it's 50% larger. What other evidence of "building for growth" can you demand?
- fossuser 6y agoA ratio of new housing vs. new population. You can expand sprawl via single family homes and still not build nearly enough housing to meet population growth requirements. You can have a lot more population and still build little. It just forces people to live in shared housing with roommates at very expensive rents. I'm not arguing that you're wrong about Houston - maybe they did build enough. I'm just saying that population growth itself doesn't tell you too much.
- desert_boi 6y agoIs there a similar source that would let you compare MSAs for building of housing units? I'd be interested to see how Boise's MSA lines up with the Bay Area. Most Californian transplants I'd met growing up in the area were from Sacremento/SoCal though.
- jeffbee 6y agoDoes this get you started? Population-adjusted new housing starts for both Boise and San Francisco MSAs since 2000. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=B6Uf https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=B6Uf
- desert_boi 6y agoIt does indeed. Thanks!
- davidw 6y agoBTW, for people looking for other examples of how to grow, who might not like the idea of Houston's sprawl, I've always liked this article: https://www.sightline.org/2017/09/21/yes-you-can-build-your-way-to-affordable-housing/ https://www.sightline.org/2017/09/21/yes-you-can-build-your-...
- wonder_er 6y agoThat is a lovely article! Thanks for sharing. I feel like the US would be better off looking at cities around the world that are pleasent, and pattern-matching off of that. Vienna is beautiful. We should do more of what Vienna does. Clearly tweaking the US's "process" is just moving deck chairs on the titanic.
- davidw 6y agoYeah, Vienna is very nice! It doesn't feel like a "Big City" at all. I'm partial to the Montreal example in the article - it feels the most 'human scale' to me - but everyone has different tastes.
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoI've never been to Vienna so I can't speak to it but my experience in traveling around the world is that many cities have incredible central cities but also have sprawling medium to high density suburbs that everyone turns a blind eye to. The low density automobile focused suburbs of North America might not exist around those cities but the denser suburbs still have poor livability, especially compared to the central cities they surround.
- davidw 6y agoI lived in a suburb of Padova, Italy, for many years. Still quite walkable and nice, even if it didn't have the old, historic buildings.
- rayiner 6y agoYes, housing isn’t a problem in a city whose population is the same today as it was in 1935, in a country that’s projected to slowly shrink over the next century.
- mpg33 6y agoTexas is also a good example of that density only matters if there is a land scarcity problem. There are areas in Canada where building massive towers has been premature and also led to increase in costs.
- jandrese 6y agoDensity also matters if you're trying to avoid sprawl. A city like Houston basically requires you to own a car and drive everywhere, because public transit will never be able to keep up with the construction nor will the density be high enough to make it economically viable.
- xvedejas 6y agoI sincerely doubt that building towers lead to an increase in costs in the existing housing stock, unless something very strange is afoot.
- mpg33 6y agoCost of building a tower is much more than something like rowhouses, multiplexes. Cities like Toronto and Vancouver bypass the "missing middle". So it's mostly single family homes with various "tower node districts".
- xvedejas 6y agoYes, towers are expensive, but building them doesn't make the existing SFHs more expensive. Maybe tower building and rising home prices both coincide with certain economic trends, post hoc ergo propter hoc.
- xenadu02 6y agoNot really. Dallas is an example of a metro area that has extended sprawl as far as it can go. A ton of new highways have been built out but growth in car usage and population have eaten back all the gains. There will never be enough land to make the sprawl work. As a result home prices there are jumping just like everywhere else. No one wants a 2 hour commute.
- altano 6y agoThose cities are much larger, both in size and population. DFW is 8x the population of SF. According to Google, at least. Meanwhile those new building numbers are NOT 8x.
- nostrademons 6y agoIt's comparing DFW metro area vs. Houston/Sugarlands metro area vs. SF/Oakland/Berkeley metro area. As of 1990 (the point where the graphs diverged), DFW had 3.8M people, Greater Houston had 3.3M, and SF/Oakland had 3.7M. They were pretty comparable then; subsequent growth has been simply because the Texas metro areas have added more housing.
- rustybelt 6y agoAs you say some places are growing and others are stagnating or shrinking. If every place has a certain capacity to grow given the necessary pressure to do so, wouldn't more evenly distributed growth reduce the problems caused by the current uneven distribution of growth/stagnation/shrinkage? In other words, how can you say we're not growing fast enough when so many places aren't growing at all?
- asdff 6y agoBecause growth isn't even nor can it be, it depends on connectivity of an area to relevant features that spur further growth, such as industry, jobs, education. There are highly specific reasons for growth to happen where it happens, and 9/10 it's due to some piece of immovable necessary infrastructure that supports a wider region. For example, Chicago is the size it is because it is a confluence point of freight, first from the Mississippi and the Great Lakes, now freight rail. Los Angeles is the size it is because the Port of Los Angeles/Port of Long Beach is the mouth of all east Asian trade coming into the continent, which started a century of industrialization and job growth in the area. San Francisco and Boston are innovation centers due to the number of high quality universities in these areas that continually feed the local talent pool by the year. There are plenty of places that are zoned for growth but it hasn't happened yet, either. For instance, just across the Angeles National Forest north of Los Angeles, you have the Antelope Valley, which remains relatively depopulated in comparison to Los Angeles due to a lack of connectivity to very many job centers or much industry, even with roads having long been laid for eventual development (1). 1. https://www.google.com/maps/@34.5617689,-117.9209187,5165m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/@34.5617689,-117.9209187,5165m/d...
- MrMan 6y agoSo you are saying if we tax advertising housing prices will ease? I agree with you
- throwawayboise 6y ago> we don't build actual dense housing like we did before WWII Because that's not what is profitable for new construction. Builders will build what they can make the most money on. It's not a bad thing -- it's still an increase in housing and every new home sold or rented opens up an older home somewhere for a (probably) less wealthy person, and so on down the line.
- asdff 6y agoBuilders will build what they are allowed to build, and often what is zoned are variances for these massive structures with expensive parking structures and requirements like a mandatory 100sqft balcony for every single unit, and not piecemeal small lot apartments like what was built decades ago. Los Angeles in 1920 had a higher zoning capacity than it does today. I mean, it was a celebration when the city recently let you convert your garage into a tiny studio apartment (after a byzantine permitting process), in neighborhoods where 50 years ago homeowners were tearing down their single family home to be a landlord of a 6 unit dingbat apartment spanning the entire 90ft parcel, which is probably illegal today according to the zoning code. If we loosen zoning code, builders would be able to turn a profit on a lot more types of housing and would be able to meet a lot more market demand. Instead, what they are able to make a profit on with the current review and permitting process is that bog standard 4 floor apartment above a subterranean parking lot with a balcony for each and every unit.
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoBanks are part of the problem too. In Atlanta the city has loosened up many of the density restrictions and parking requirements only to find developers unable to build dense pedestrian focused housing because the banks won't make construction loans for those types of properties.
- pessimizer 6y agoPrices climb because real estate is a vehicle for financial speculation, tax tricks, and the exfiltration of pilfered wealth by world oligarchs.
- jseliger 6y agoNowhere is building enough housing for growth Factually untrue: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16704501 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16704501