3 ms·
>> Colorectal is also one of most treatable, and curable cancers there are . While I agree that the interesting statistic is "the individual chance of getting
by YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago
>> Colorectal is also one of most treatable, and curable cancers there are .
While I agree that the interesting statistic is "the individual chance of getting colorectal cancer given that one eats meats cured with nitrites and nitrates", I don't think I'd accept the risk to give up a piece of my colon for the joy of eating ham. Especially if this joy can be enjoyed without having to run the risk (see the bit about Parma ham in the article).
Btw, 5% risk is a gigantic chance. 5%! One in twenty! Where does that number come from? Can you link to its source please?
Edit: let me stress this again; it's not cured meats that increase the chance of colorectal cancer. It's meats cured with nitrates. You don't need to make a choice between a healthy colon and an enjoyable diet.
- drannex 6y agoI over-rounded on the 5% number (since fixed), real stats are 4.3% for men and 4% for women and with an 18% increase that brings it to <5.07%, not 5.9%. I've included the source in the comment as well.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoThank you.
- lostcolony 6y agoWell, there are some natural nitrates/nitrites in celery powder, which is generally what is used in more 'natural' processed meats.
- tomxor 6y ago> 5% risk is a gigantic chance. 5%! One in twenty! I can't tell whether or not you understand that 5% is supposed to be the base chance of getting colorectal cancer. Cancer in general is very common, we basically all get it eventually in some form or other. The difference nitrate processed meats are supposed to make is an 18% increase of that base 5%, moving 5% to 5.9% (this is why the article feels a little deceptive, because the correct interpretation of the statistic completely relies on the word "by" and a preexisting knowledge of the baseline statistic). > I don't think I'd accept the risk to give up a piece of my colon for the joy of eating ham. I'm not saying it's nothing, but to be clear the OP is suggesting the _absolute_ difference is 0.9%. So that is the additional risk you would be accepting over your lifetime for regularly eating it.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago>> I can't tell whether or not you understand that 5% is supposed to be the base chance of getting colorectal cancer. I suggest the following as an easy to make, strong interpretation of my comment: "5% chance is already pretty high and I would prefer to do nothing that increases it any further". To clarify, that was the intepretation I had in mind when writing the comment (and still now). Edit: >> Cancer in general is very common, we basically all get it eventually in some form or other. That sounds counterintuitive and from a cursory look at incidence statistics, it seems to be an exaggeration. e.g. Wikipedia says: About 20% of males and 17% of females will get cancer at some point in time while 13% of males and 9% of females will die from it.[196] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cancer#Epidemiology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cancer#Epidemiology
- pvaldes 6y agoThe biggest problem is that some people [typically on rural areas that have a traditional disdain for science], only have access to drinking water contaminated with nitrites from farms. For many people there is a chronic daily dose, even if they are vegans.