3 ms·
Removing them all is a simple matter of blocking DNS lookups for Google DNS addresses. There are only ~10 hostnames to block. Sure, some features will break,
by londons_explore 6y ago
Removing them all is a simple matter of blocking DNS lookups for Google DNS addresses. There are only ~10 hostnames to block.
Sure, some features will break, but it won't be any worse than being disconnected from the internet.
- hobofan 6y agoAh yes, the smartphone, the invention that isn't basically entirely based around the concept of being connected to the internet.
- Erlich_Bachman 6y agoI don't see what is so hard to understand. One thing is internet connections that are initiated by user, or in the background from the apps that user voluntarily installed and wants to provide them a specific services. Another thing is when a phone has a bunch of add-on adware (in some cases spyware) ,built-in into the phone, without user's knowledge, without user's consent and most of the time even ability to choose. Adware chosen by the manufacturer or provider, that is serving their purposes. That is a clear existing distinction. It has nothing to do with being a smartphone or having an internet connection in general, or using a smartphone for internet-related tasks.
- hobofan 6y agoThe parent comment makes it seem like blocking those Google services will brick all online functionality of the phone (I don't know if that's the case but it wouldn't surprise me), and proposing that as a viable solution. I'm all for de-googling (and de-OEMing) our devices, but giving up all online functionality is not a viable alternative.
- ThenAsNow 6y agoThis would take out a certain number of them, but there are hardcoded IP references (e.g., to their DNS servers), use of Google systems for things like NTP, and so on. These are findable and patchable, but you will still be building your own image to maintain as most of these are not exposed as knobs in the Android UI. And of course still no answer for SUPL. Going transiently without an internet connection is common, but going semi-permanently without one is not what these systems are designed to do well. Also, is this list of ~10 hostnames readily available somewhere?
- FDSGSG 6y ago>use of Google systems for things like NTP GrapheneOS doesn't use NTP at all, where are you getting your information?
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoGoogle has a solution for this. By using DNS-over-HTTPS, Google can start deploying software that communicates solely with it's own DNS servers over encrypted connections.
- teekert 6y agoI don't know why you are down voted but this is exactly why pihole and adguard have no effect on many devices.
- teddyh 6y agoDNS blocking will very soon, if not already, cease to work, with the arrival of DoH.