6 ms·
Cryptocurrency is still something that legacy financial systems could easily out-compete given an appropriate regulatory environment. There are things Bitcoin
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
Cryptocurrency is still something that legacy financial systems could easily out-compete given an appropriate regulatory environment.
There are things Bitcoin is better at than e.g. credit cards. If you're a trusted merchant with shady customers, once the transaction posts you don't have to worry about scammers fraudulently disputing the charge or your bank cutting you off because that happened too often. You can get Bitcoin under a pseudonym and use it to buy something (e.g. banned or controversial books, VPN for dissidents) that you don't want tied to your meatspace identity. Things like that.
None of this would be impossible to do with ordinary financial systems except that existing regulations prohibit it. But if anybody can do it with Bitcoin regardless then there is no point in that and you might as well allow it in general. At which point, why are we burning all this energy on Bitcoin?
- kace91 6y agoPresumably, forcing illegal actions to happen through bitcoin adds friction to the process. But more importantly, as far as I know bitcoin is not designed to guarantee anonymity in money transfers, and the fact that every transaction is set in stone publicly in the blockchain makes it relatively easily traceable. Am I wrong in that area?
- kevingadd 6y agoWhile it's not trivial, it's been shown that you can de-anonymize bitcoin transactions. In some cases it's very easy. So in practice you can't rely on your transactions being anonymous even if in practice some of them may end up that way. And of course even if transactions themselves were fully anonymous, many people end up needing to rely on exchanges, and the idea of those being truly anonymous is borderline absurd.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Presumably, forcing illegal actions to happen through bitcoin adds friction to it. Adding friction to non-illegal actions is harm, not benefit. Adding friction to illegal actions is the opposite of what happens, because it's enabling something that wasn't previously possible. Also, criminals can survive higher friction than dissidents and vulnerable populations because the illegality creates a moat that raises margins. It's why drug cartels make billions of dollars and can finance submarines and stuff but marginal changes that nobody thinks through the implications of get dissidents killed. > But more importantly, as far as I know bitcoin is not designed to guarantee anonymity in money transfers, and the fact that every transaction is set in stone publicly in the blockchain makes it relatively easily traceable. Am I wrong in that area? Every transaction is public but it's only the transaction and there is no requirement to reuse the same wallet for multiple transactions. You go to some cryptocurrency hangout, pay some stranger a hundred bucks in cash and they transfer a hundred bucks in Bitcoin to your wallet. You go pay for a VPN with it. Then everybody can see that A transferred money to B and B transferred money to C, but nobody knows that you're B and those are the only transactions for that wallet. Also, there are cryptocurrencies where this isn't the case and you don't even get that.
- ivanche 6y ago> You go to some cryptocurrency hangout, pay some stranger a hundred bucks in cash and they transfer a hundred bucks in Bitcoin to your wallet. You go pay for a VPN with it. Then everybody can see that A transferred money to B and B transferred money to C, but nobody knows that you're B Nobody? Some stranger from above knows that you're B!
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoBut they're a stranger. They don't know that you're you.
- lottin 6y ago> You go to some cryptocurrency hangout, pay some stranger a hundred bucks in cash and they transfer a hundred bucks in Bitcoin to your wallet. You go pay for a VPN with it. Then everybody can see that A transferred money to B and B transferred money to C, but nobody knows that you're B and those are the only transactions for that wallet. Essentially you have to create a brand-new, single-use wallet for every transaction, am I wrong?
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoSo what?
- lottin 6y agoNothing.
- sneak 6y agoI don't think we will get existing planet-scale financial regulatory authorities to give up their dream of ubiquitous financial surveillance and point-and-click, shoot first and ask questions later financial censorship/DoS abilities simply by there being an alternative. Already they have practically banned p2p bitcoin transactions in the US. They're closer to their goal than we are to ours. In 2011 I gave a halfway tongue-in-cheek talk called "Financing the Revolution" about digital payment systems, with a focus on bitcoin and the new possibilities it enabled. It is still, all these years later, not really possible to finance a revolution with bitcoin. I don't think that's in any way an accident.
- novok 6y agoI didn't think bitcoin wasn't going to be special in that regard either, because states have shown ability to tax and regulate the finance of citizens before anything electronic ever existed, with cash, gold, cows, farmland, personal goods and more, and they would just go back to those old methods with something like bitcoin or monero. Also they're willing to add a lot of inefficiency to their economies to retain financial control of their countries.
- AlexandrB 6y ago> If you're a trusted merchant with shady customers, once the transaction posts you don't have to worry about scammers fraudulently disputing the charge or your bank cutting you off because that happened too often. If you're a scammer merchant, ripping off good-faith customers you also don't have to worry about chargebacks. Bitcoin moves power from the consumer to the merchant. I don't see that as a net positive.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThen don't pay scammer merchants with payment methods that don't have chargebacks. That's no reason not to do it when you're confident that you can trust the merchant and the merchant has legitimate reasons to expect that some of their customers are unreliable. It's a common problem for adult products that the buyer's spouse sees the charge on the credit card statement, the buyer claims not to know anything about it and the spouse disputes the charge even though the merchant did nothing wrong.
- Nursie 6y agoEven legit vbendors screw up, or go bankrupt, or any number of other things. Chargeback and other consumer credit-card protections are very useful. Regulations don't prohibit irreversible transaction mechanisms, basically nobody wants them.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Regulations don't prohibit irreversible transaction mechanisms, basically nobody wants them. Please don't just make stuff up. Point me to the credit card I can get which doesn't allow for chargebacks. I want to use it to buy things from people I trust who don't trust me, because that is an actually useful thing that some people have a legitimate reason to do.
- Nursie 6y ago> I want to use it to buy things from people I trust who don't trust me 1. That makes you sound actually crazy. 2. I didn't say you could get a credit card that doesn't allow chargebacks, I said the regulations don't prohibit payment mechanisms without chargebacks. See for example cashiers cheques and bank transfers. There's a reason people avoid them, and a reason popular payment methods support them. The fact is that reversibility is a feature.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> That makes you sound actually crazy. I don't see why this is so difficult to understand. You have a merchant with a sterling reputation. I'm a customer. They don't know me from Adam, but they know that a lot of their customers are unreliable. Suppose the product is bespoke or controversial, so they have a lot of problems with people placing an order and then backing out and refusing to pay after the work is already done or the product is already delivered. In a system with chargebacks, they have to eat the cost of that and pass it on to the honest customers. In a system without it, the people violating their agreement and backing out can't get their money back, and then honest customers like me don't have to pay more to cover them. So I'm willing to commit to trusting the merchant in exchange for not having to pay more. In this case forced reversibility is a cost to me, the customer. > See for example cashiers cheques and bank transfers. In other words, things that are de facto prohibited through inconvenience or risk. Like a website is going to get any customers if they have to drive to the bank and then mail a cashier's check. And disclosing your bank routing number would allow the merchant to withdraw more than agreed -- you then have to trust them with not the $20 purchase you're making (an acceptable risk) but the full balance of your account (not so much). Notice that the convenient equivalent to this that might actually be usable, i.e. debit cards, is back to having chargebacks.