3 ms·
Certain kinds of novels can perhaps be written well by computers - but I believe the classical conception of a novel - one which has both internal narrator stat
by bryanrasmussen 6y ago
Certain kinds of novels can perhaps be written well by computers - but I believe the classical conception of a novel - one which has both internal narrator state and external state cannot be conceived of being written well with current methods.
Note I used well written as an indicator of goodness, obviously internal and external states can be represented but will they make anything approaching sense and aesthetic pleasure, ever, given current strategies for computerized writing of a novels? I don't believe so.
The current strategies for any content creation via computer are, as I understand them, always based on having a large enough corpus to be able to determine what should be done.
The corpus for good novels is of course smaller than the corpus for novels.
The corpus for internal state of narrators is smaller than the internal state of good novels, the corpus for internal state of narrators who represent characters of the current generation will not really be very big until that current generation is no longer current.
Things that are probably achievable - a unified style - but only in the way of a pastiche, so rewriting HuckelBerry Finn in the style of Jane Austen seems like it might end up a doable thing in less than a decade? A unified style that is unique seems unlikely within a decade, a unified style that represents whatever are the young, happening writers of the moment seems like it would require a different way for the computer to generate that content. Although 2 decades from now, maybe?
on edit: I seem to go from thinking it will never happen to thinking it might happen in 2 decades, I believe it won't happen, but lots of people have believed stuff will never happen and been proven wrong, so, accepting the requirement that we use the methods for computer generation of content currently available - if those methods have not generated good novels in two decades (by throwing more computing power at bigger corpuses) then I feel confident in concluding my belief that they never will is correct.