30 ms·
>> A person has no idea that they are violating the copyright of copyright >> holder X when they download the file." > > And this is my whole point. No,
by pyre 15y ago
>> A person has no idea that they are violating the copyright of copyright
>> holder X when they download the file."
>
> And this is my whole point.
No, it is not your whole point. They are being sued based on the contents of
the file when the file with masquerading as something completely different.
The fact that they intended to violate copyright in the first place is
irrelevant. In this case, the files were masquerading as copyrighted works that
this plaintiff does not hold the copyright for. It would be up to the
copyright holder to attempt to sue these people, not someone completely
different just because it will 'teach people a lesson.' This kind of 'teach
people a lesson' bullshit is no different than when the DoJ was trying to say
that violating MySpace's Term of Service was tantamount to Computer
Hacking/Fraud because there were no other laws to punish that lady that caused
the student to commit suicide.
The idea that someone should be punished for something they didn't intend to
do, even though their original intent was bad in the first place is an abuse of
the legal system, IMO.
It's probably easier to boil it down to this:
The user is being sued for 'violating the copyright of copyright holder X' not
for some nebulous 'violating copyright but it doesn't matter what copyright'
infraction or else I could sue you for violating someone else's copyright.
Therefore the question should really be, "is it reasonable to have expected the
user to know that they would have violated the copyright of copyright holder X
when they downloaded/uploaded that file?" You're trying to phrase the question
as, "is it reasonable to have expected the user to know that they were
violating any copyright when they downloaded/uploaded the file?"
- ChuckMcM 15y agoAsk your lawyer about intent [1] some time. It could be educational. You are claiming that because the copyrighted work they attempted to download contained a different copyrighted work that the owner of the actual work that got downloaded lacks standing [2]. And it may be that the argument supports a summary dismissal, however it can be reasonably argued that the person intended to download a copyrighted work in the first place. My point (#3 go at this, then I give up) is that educating people who are naive (which is to say don't know any better) that downloading copyrighted material from the web without the express permission of the copyright holder is illegal, and thus if they wanted access to that work they should seek out a legal source for it, is a positive outcome for what is otherwise a pointless and wasteful exercise. [1] http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/intent http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/intent [2] http://encyclopedia.thefreedictionary.com/legal+standing http://encyclopedia.thefreedictionary.com/legal+standing
- pyre 15y agoFrom your link: > In tort an individual is considered to intend the consequences of an > act—whether or not she or he actually intends those consequences—if the > individual is substantially certain that those consequences will result. IANAL, but in this case I would assume that 'those consequences' would be that copyright holder X was harmed. If that's the case, then there was no way that the user intended to harm copyright holder X by downloading something they thought was by copyright holder Y.
- ChuckMcM 15y ago"IANAL, but in this case I would assume that 'those consequences' would be that copyright holder X was harmed. If that's the case, then there was no way that the user intended to harm copyright holder X by downloading something they thought was by copyright holder Y." You're comment is what a lawyer would use in an argument that the plaintiff lacks standing. And it certainly might prevail in this case (I've not seen a copy of the pleading). But if you look at this thread (or at least my contributions to it) you'll notice that I've never expressed any opinion one way or another about whether or not Titan Media will prevail in its efforts. I make only three claims; 1) People sued by Titan Media will feel inconvienienced by it and they will associate the suit with their action of downloading "something" from the internet. 2) Those people will associate 'downloading stuff from the internet' with this inconvience. 3) They (and their friends who had to listen to their tale) will stop doing this because the 'risk' has risen above the 'reward.' I used the short hand of relating this process as 'educating the naive.' I stand by that analysis.