3 ms·
>>> But I want to ask all of you: what replaces it as arbiter of truth? A strongman. An idea that I attribute to Imre Lakatos, is that if you strip people of
by analog31 6y ago
>>> But I want to ask all of you: what replaces it as arbiter of truth?
A strongman.
An idea that I attribute to Imre Lakatos, is that if you strip people of the ability to debate and discern facts, you create a power vacuum that can only be filled by those who can act in the absence of debate and facts, notably thugs and tyrants.
I believe this is the actual motivation behind the "war on truth" and the flood of misinformation.
- nexthash 6y agoThis is my biggest fear about the media. If they don't come clean and reclaim their integrity (this goes for both left and right outlets), the public will reject them. Discourse will move to blogs, podcasts, private networks, etc. In the process, the laws and protections for journalism will be weathered and may be abolished altogether (who needs those pompous journalists, right?). Then we'll be no better than a propaganda state, where you can be jailed or sued for publishing a perspective that offends or exposes someone. This is obviously a worst-case scenario, but I think that to prevent anything similar from happening Americans need to step up and pressure their news outlets to do better, and for social media platforms to be choked with regulation until they start preventing manipulative shit from spreading.
- rorykoehler 6y agoIt's already too late.
- rubicon33 6y agoThis has already happened.
- jtvjan 6y agoIn the first paragraph, you argue for freedom of expression. Then, at the end of the second paragraph, you call for regulation against it. Huh?!
- coldtea 6y agoMany want "freedom of expression" only for arbiters of correct expression (the one they agree with)...
- Pyramus 6y agoHow is that a contradiction? Unless some right is absolute it will always be relative to the rights of others. The questions is where to set the limits exactly and misinformation is indeed a grey area. Hence the discussion.
- loveistheanswer 6y ago>social media platforms to be choked with regulation until they start preventing manipulative shit from spreading. Manipulation is an unsolved human problem as old as humanity. The core business model of social media is fundamentally based on manipulation. Asking social media corporations to protect us from manipulation is salmon asking grizzly bears to protect them from getting eaten. It's contrary to their fundamental nature.
- im3w1l 6y agoI don't think there is a war on truth. What we are seeing is fundamentally economic. If you can't make money reporting, only activists pushing an agenda will remain. This leads to a justified decline in trust.
- coldtea 6y agoAlso if you can make money or build a career being an activist... Many "smart" activists found that with a little faux rage (and in the end, believing their own BS too), all these pundit, policy advisor, and advocacy jobs are there for the taking...
- rimiform 6y agoI think you are absolutely right. I can see the fallibility of 'Old World' media as well, but I think those who (actively) try to discredit them are playing with fire.
- MikeUt 6y ago> if you strip people of the ability to debate and discern facts If you dare to debate and discern the wrong facts, you get a hit piece published on you like Slate Star Codex. Or you get fired like the NY Times reporter Donald McNeil Jr. It seems some of the media play an enthusiastic part in stripping people of that ability, not in protecting it.