2 ms·
> Their are several ways to can synchronize the latitudes and longitudes such that you get a repeating pattern. This lets you cover the continental US without h
by mlyle 6y ago
> Their are several ways to can synchronize the latitudes and longitudes such that you get a repeating pattern. This lets you cover the continental US without having global coverage.
This is seriously confused. The Earth turns under that repeating pattern, and the turning of the Earth is asynchronous unless the period of rotation is an integer multiple of the orbital period (which it isn't).
We're in the peak hour right now. This is Starlink. There's no magical favoring of North America (well, except we have a non-operational "train" of new launches overhead). https://imgur.com/a/h94WRsQ https://imgur.com/a/h94WRsQ
The only thing you can really do is pick your inclination wisely.
- Retric 6y agoUsing integer multiples are the obvious, but not only choice. If you look at this visualization you see a higher density coverage over Europe and parts of North America. That’s what let’s them roll out early as the gaps at the equator eventually get filled in. http://www.circleid.com/images/uploads/12233d.jpg http://www.circleid.com/images/uploads/12233d.jpg It’s also a significant cost saving measure, though a lot of time is wasted in the band over the Southern Hemisphere it’s still a net win due to global population density from Europe, North America, and Asia. Note, the actual effect is more pronounced as lines of longitude vary their width. But I couldn’t find a better projection.
- mlyle 6y ago> If you look at this visualization you see a higher density coverage over Europe and parts of North America. That’s what let’s them roll out early as the gaps at the equator eventually get filled in. So, you've chosen to just show me an illustration of the sole effect in play, that I've been mentionng to you all day long? 9 hours ago "satellites in highly inclined orbits spend more time around the poles." 5 hours ago "A given high inclination short-orbit-period satellite serves all longitudes equally, and the distribution of latitudes it serves is purely a function of its inclination." 1 hour ago "The only thing you can really do is pick your inclination wisely." This is not favoring the US. It is favoring things a bit less than 53 degrees North and South (the inclination is 53 degrees). Each satellite spends time up there (down there?) apparently reversing its motion from slightly northwards to slightly southwards, painting a big 'U' in the sky. And you think this somehow invalidates the data in the study? The study assumed SpaceX's actual constellation dynamics. There's no way to favor North America "more" than the study does.
- Retric 6y agoEdit: Whatever it’s 2:30 am here I am just beating a dead horse. Not quite I am saying the effect demonstrated is more significant than that was suggesting. The distance between lines of latitude deceases as you move north. That’s what allows for 24/7/365 coverage in the continental US before the Equator. Anyway it’s also not just about time spent near though not reaching the poles. The effect is also significant at 30 degrees North vs the Equator and thus the entire continual US benefits. PS: As to 52 degrees North, much like over the ocean satellites can reach further south than just the area beneath them. Which is why the constitution reaches further north than seems optimal at first glance.
- mlyle 6y agoYou said "North America" vs. global coverage. I've been mentioning inclination all day long and that yes, inclined orbits spend less time near the equator than at the northern and southern extrema of their orbits. You've insisted that something else in play. Stop trying to save face-- it's OK to not fully understand something. > PS: As to 52 degrees North, much like over the ocean satellites can reach further south than just the area beneath them. Which is why the constitution reaches further north than seems optimal at first glance. FFS, broski. Do you read? "It is favoring things a bit less than 53 degrees North and South (the inclination is 53 degrees)" > The distance between lines of latitude deceases as you move north. That’s what allows for 24/7/365 coverage in the continental US before the Equator. How does that work? Do you mean longitude? You seemingly use latitude and longitude interchangeably in our conversation. Satellites spend more time at their northern/southern extrema, because ... sine and cosine spend more time near 1 than near 0. And, of course, yes, there's less total land area far north than near the equator. Your diagram has the actual footprints drawn and they're appropriately elongated when the satellite is north or south. There's no further magical effect based on map projection. The study I cited appropriately adjusts for satellite coverage density but you somehow suggested SpaceX could further concentrate satellites over CONUS beyond the study's analysis, which is how we got onto this entire track. They can't, can they?
- Retric 6y ago