I think it does not hurt to repost my comment again: I think what Brochet study clearly displayed is that novice oenology students are too biased by the framew

I think it does not hurt to repost my comment again: I think what Brochet study clearly displayed is that novice oenology students are too biased by the framework what they have been taught - they see red colored wine and they try to fit it into the framework they know. What this study did not show was that a general public would not distinguish between red wine and colored white wine. It also did not show that seasoned wine experts would not distinguish between red wine and colored white wine. This is a really interesting study but it has its clear limitations and these should be acknowledged.