3 ms·
This article goes a bit off the rails a bit in the middle where the writer discusses their long journey through ideological shifts as a way to justify a critici
by legitster 6y ago
This article goes a bit off the rails a bit in the middle where the writer discusses their long journey through ideological shifts as a way to justify a criticism of rationalists. In this regard, it seems Scott Alexander is just a proxy for an internet punching bag. Rationalism is a vague, fluid concept. He has a prolific body of work. Therefor, he must represent the rationalist community. Very little of this addresses the actual questions of journalism.
> There’s a specific kind of misunderstanding that’s pervasive in tech, and it falls in this taxonomy of fallacies somewhere between the commentary/reporting confusion, and Uncle Chico.
This obviously cuts both ways - isn't it just as easy for journalists to misunderstand other industries? Why is it the responsibility of the ~victim~ subject to know how they are being reported on?
> The malicious journalist thesis is the one that was the hardest on my ocular muscles yesterday. Scott Alexander—the figure at the center of the piece—believes this, and has advanced this theory that the journalist who wrote the piece, and perhaps The New York Times institutionally, were out to smear him.
If you read his writing, Scott Alexander was actually incredibly gracious about the journalist in question, even going so far to say it was probably not their fault. Ironically enough, if the writer was familiar with SSC, she would know that she is looking for a lot of words to describe "Mistake Theory": https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/01/24/conflict-vs-mistake/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/01/24/conflict-vs-mistake/
But again, it seems like nobody actually cares that the argument isn't that whether the coverage was good or bad. It's a bad characterization of the content! The reporting was inaccurate, and the subject didn't want to be interviewed!
> And another structural reality is that organizations--companies, say, startups--are terrible at policing themselves. What journalism seeks to do is illuminate the areas where destructive means are being utilized to achieve ends that might actually be virtuous or worthy in some other way.
What if the journalists are the ones doing something destructive??!!!! You don't get to magically absolve yourself of your sins because your pursuit is noble! How do you get off criticizing the tech industry when you engage in the same crime of thinking you are on the side of righteousness?
> It makes a lot of people uncomfortable when they can’t control their self-presentation, and this extends to journalistic portrayals.
With good right! If anything I learned from this article it's that journalists are too busy to care about making sure they characterize the content correctly.
- runsWphotons 6y agoTo be fair to her: he was gracious to the writer but at the expense of proposing it was really his editors who wanted him to write the story. I.e. he removes some responsibility from the writer. I think it is probably too charitable and the author knew what he was writing and knew his editors would sign off. The editors probably didn't think very hard about it, knowing it looks like the other stuff they publish.