7 ms·
Yes, I completely agree. The reason this is very disheartening to me is because I believe the thing that is really special and awesome about science as a discip
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
Yes, I completely agree. The reason this is very disheartening to me is because I believe the thing that is really special and awesome about science as a discipline is that it teaches people how to critically evaluate and weigh evidence in support of a hypothesis. So instead of teaching people how to be good critical thinkers (and, especially in this day and age, ascertain whether a particular source of evidence should be trusted and what the potential biases that source may have), "trust the science" has been turned into a pretty empty appeal to authority.
This has been pretty evident in the past year when the experts have often been wrong, or at least pushed their opinions in a way that wasn't really supported by the underlying evidence ("the public doesn't need to wear masks" back in March is a good example). It actually wasn't really that hard to dig in to the underlying evidence, assess the validity of that evidence, and make up your mind for yourself.
- AstralStorm 6y agoWhile it wasn't that hard, general public does not know where to even look for primary or even preliminary evidence. Much less how to evaluate the densely written papers. So in the end it is reliant on science communicators, and there is enough people who are either bad at it, fake it or altogether evil and misrepresenting scientific evidence for it to fail. You always will have some authority needed as you have to be able to read really well and a lot of practice with the specific field to handle the outputs of science.
- konjin 6y agoIn the middle ages multiplication was a skill that was taught at universities. Somehow we now teach it to 7 year olds. The reason why we haven't done the same for critical thinking is that the people in charge won't be if we had a citizenry which could think logically. Case in point: NYC and SF have the worst homelessness problem of any city despite being in the hands of the party that keeps saying they are for the poor. That you now have dozens of reasons lined up in your head why it's not their fault despite having the power to solve it for decades and should be let off the hook is the lack of critical thinking in American education at work.
- AstralStorm 6y agoThe bigger problem is that in many fields, even if you can read and understand the paper, it is not actionable, much less verifiable by you. It may be incomplete, hide an asterisk as some other branch may mention, or be altogether written as to be unverifiable. The last bit is especially common in the most important but soft sciences like psychology, sociology, economy, history or anthropology... Or worse, it may be in principle verifiable but only at high expense, or the results of the analysis are incomplete or buried.
- ntsplnkv2 6y agoReading cutting edge papers is not something the layman can do, it's a waste of time. This is why we have things like the CDC offer guidelines, taking into account the changes and growth in our knowledge base. Knowledge is collected and verified over time and eventually becomes distilled in easy to understand ways to the public.
- XorNot 6y agoRemember to vote Republican! This is a rich take coming from anyone living in the US. It's a two party system - the failure of the party partially aligned with your views does not and has never made voting for the party expressly against your views the correct outcome. This is you telling people to think critically while failing to think critically (because it suits the politics you want to advocate for).
- konjin 6y ago> Remember to vote Republican! In NYC and SF? Sure. Or Greens, Independents, Socialists, anyone but Democrats. I'd be giving the same advice to anyone from Alabama about voting not Republican. Politics isn't about good and evil, it's about who gets what. If people who keep failing to give you what you want keep getting your vote they will keep doing what they were doing.
- runsWphotons 6y ago
- passivate 6y ago>While it wasn't that hard, general public does not know where to even look for primary or even preliminary evidence. Much less how to evaluate the densely written papers. I feel like its much worse than that. All of current research is very specialized. I am not a scientist but I do work in vaccines. After having worked for the past eight years in this field, I feel I can generally get the gist of scientific articles/papers, and understand if its something useful or junk - but only in my niche areas. Outside of that, I'm pretty much your average Joe.
- xiphias2 6y agoVaccines (especially mRNA vaccines) are not a bad field to be an expert in. As an example I have chronic sinusitis without polyps which totally destroys my quality of life, while I can probably live with it for a long time. I’m looking at the successful cystic fibrosis inhaled vaccine trials that looks like a great way to help the cells produce missing proteins. I’m hoping for similar treatments to be available in the near future, and I have some money that I would happily use to invest / donate in a chronic sinusitis vaccine development, but so far I see only biologics trials that are probably much slower to go through because of the greater toxicity. Actually your knowledge is enough for you to have an edge over other people in investing in biotech companies.
- passivate 6y agoWell vaccines as a field is super-mega broad, there are so many pure research sub-disciplines one can choose to be an expert on due to the intersection of medicine/immunology/chemistry/biology. And even those are super broad themselves. From an applied sciences standpoint again there are various disciplines depending on the particular vaccine technology - fermentation, protein purification, conjugation chemistry, formulation, drug delivery, etc, etc, etc. From an analytical chemistry/biology standpoint there are dozens more fields that come into the picture when testing. You can spend years and decades in any of these niche fields and still not probe the depths of our accumulated knowledge. And once you have a product, you get into the regulatory domain - finding the quickest and shortest path to the market - which is its own nightmare. I don't know much about the particulars of the vaccine you are referring to, but when it comes to investing, I think it is always safe to assume that all major investing firms have ready access to SMEs that can give them the scoop on any company they're interested in.
- Ambolia 6y agoThe general public could choose to inform themselves through alternative institutions that got it correctly in the first place. But this is disincentiviced and labeled as conspiracy theories.
- czzr 6y agoWhat alternative institutions?
- vagrantJin 6y ago> You always will have some authority needed as you have to be able to read really well and a lot of practice with the specific field to handle the outputs of science. In other words, prophets, pastors and priests. The conflation of academia and science is starting to grate.
- clairity 6y agoyah, who knew how limited the utility of masks were until we tried it en masse? or the unreasonable effectiveness of distancing indoors around familiars, even without a mask? crazy, isn't it? science is hard; human behavior is even harder.
- blub 6y agoMasks of the FFP2/N95 variety have great utility at protecting the wearer, even when not worn perfectly. This should be the main concern of every individual. Governments can worry about whether they work en masse.
- clairity 6y agono, the type of mask doesn’t matter. the situations where masks help are minimal and fleeting, and distancing (or natural dynamics) does the work in most common situations. moreover masks aren’t typically worn in situations where they’d actually be useful (around familiars, because less distance). those are (some of) the human dynamics involved, which nullify the potential utility of masks. masks are primarily palliative, political, tribal, and cargo-culted.
- blub 6y agoIn Germany (and other countries) masks must be worn whenever distance can't be kept, so they are widely worn. Doctor's offices, public transport, work (typically not at one's desk), religious gatherings, retirement homes, etc. Many people are nowadays wearing FFP2 masks, which are available everywhere.
- clairity 6y agomasks don't absolve individuals of situational awareness (and worrying about the type of mask is a non sequitur in this regard), as we each still need to understand the actual risks of various common situations, ignorance of which is what is driving infection rates, not flouting arbitrary masking rules. mask messaging makes that worse by masking (ha) the real, actionable information and issues. people have been relentlessly messaged to think that wearing a mask in public is all they need to do, but that's diametrically opposed to the real infection threats we typically face (e.g., people we know gathering privately). we shouldn't accept mindless rules from our "superiors", especially incorrect and politically motivated ones, but rather demand timely and correct information devoid of political intent, so that we can internalize the risks appropriately and act accordingly.