13 ms·
>> They felt that way because papers like the Post could offer the carrot of great exposure to those who needed it, but also, always, the stick of negative cove
by phkahler 6y ago
>> They felt that way because papers like the Post could offer the carrot of great exposure to those who needed it, but also, always, the stick of negative coverage to those who spurned them. There is nothing devious or ignoble about this; a powerful press, for all its flaws, is good for democracy
No, doing hit pieces on anyone is a flagrant exercise of power that deserves no respect and destroys the credibility of the press. Stick to reporting facts and not exercising power and you'll fare much better.
A recent example that was fascinating to me: during an emerging global crisis (covid19) the president of the USA held a press briefing to discuss the situation. A reporter was called on to ask a question by the president himself. That reporter decided to insinuate that the president was racist in addition to asking a question. The president's response included "you're a terrible reporter" in addition to answering the question. I'm sure that guy and his organisation were not welcome back, and rightly so. Keep your editorial shit on the page it belongs, or in another story. There is a place for that, but it's not during a press conference with "the leader of the free world" during a global crisis. And yet the MSM went wild over how bad the president was for calling out a reporter's bullshit.
Stick to the facts and the story or you will be rightly identified as something other than a source of information.
- redelbee 6y agoFact: You are conflating two separate instances where Trump bullied reporters to make your point. Instance from 2018 (with what you termed “racist” insinuations): https://youtu.be/OXp5GJjuOvQ https://youtu.be/OXp5GJjuOvQ Instance from 2020 actually relating to COVID-19: https://youtu.be/N5NQdmHzBTY https://youtu.be/N5NQdmHzBTY I’m going to take this as a reminder that we should all carefully consider sources of information, even when those sources are our own recollections and experiences.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chrisco255 6y agohttps://www.ndtv.com/world-news/covid-19-pandemic-us-president-donald-trump-abruptly-ends-coronavirus-press-conference-after-spat-with-reporter-2227194 https://www.ndtv.com/world-news/covid-19-pandemic-us-preside... No, this was the "racist" incident when Weijia Jiang asked Trump why he was insisting on bringing up the fact that the U.S. was doing better than (several European countries, including UK, Italy, Spain, and France at the time) other countries. And he said, "They're losing their lives everywhere in the world. And maybe that's a question you should ask China. Don't ask me, ask China that question, OK?" because at the time, China was claiming they had basically solved Covid-19 with lockdowns and that the virus was no longer spreading in their country. And she said, "Sir, why are you saying that to me specifically?" implying it was due to her race (she being of Chinese heritage). And Trump, in standard form, said "I'm saying it to anybody who would ask a nasty question like that." Every time Trump would be his ordinary self, you know, he always punches back at underhanded questions. The questions are a set up in the first place, to create a negative connotation. The coronavirus was a situation where nobody won, by the way, but the press certainly was going to do everything to make as much if it be Trump's fault as possible. Weirdly, some, who feared Trump being a true Hitler-like fascist 2-3 years ago, were upset that Trump wasn't being fascist enough and shutting the whole country down and overruling state governors on local policies. None of it was productive. None of it was healthy: on either side. None of it enlightened the population. None of it did any favors for democracy. It just inflamed already tense relations between conservatives and liberals. And note, there's no way in hell the media will ever be as hard on a democrat in office. They are 95% democrats themselves, and they have a bias. They soft balled Biden as it is, when he wasn't hiding in his basement.
- tessierashpool 6y agoShe said: "Why does that matter? Why is this a global competition when, every day, Americans are still losing their lives?" Did he answer the question? Or did he look at an Asian woman and immediately start attacking China? And this is just ridiculous: "Weirdly, some, who feared Trump being a true Hitler-like fascist 2-3 years ago, were upset that Trump wasn't being fascist enough and shutting the whole country down and overruling state governors on local policies." There's nothing fascist about instituting a national healthcare policy during a national healthcare crisis. That's not what the word means. Fascism is far-right authoritarianism. Marshalling private militias to attack people is fascism, however, and it's a practice Trump shares with both Hitler and Mussolini.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> There's nothing fascist about instituting a national healthcare policy during a national healthcare crisis. That's not what the word means. Fascism is far-right authoritarianism. When the “national healthcare policy” you wanted him to institute is an authoritarian policy that overrules local governments and implements central economic planning, then yes, its fascism. Using different words to describe the same thing might work for the soundbite but people know the truth.
- xirbeosbwo1234 6y ago>Or did he look at an Asian woman and immediately start attacking China? I don't think that's entirely fair. I suspect his answer would be pretty much the same no matter who asked it. He was pre >Marshalling private militias to attack people is fascism, however, and it's a practice Trump shares with both Hitler and Mussolini. "LIBERATE MICHIGAN", anyone? Though, in fairness, the plot to kidnap Michigan's governor didn't start until two whole two months after he sent that Tweet. The Blackshirts carrying rifles through the capitol building were largely peaceful.
- xirbeosbwo1234 6y agoI suppose the guy calling Covid-19 "Kung Flu" was in no way trying to deflect blame to China? Was his treatment of that reporter in particular bad? No, not really. I don't believe he brought up China because she was Chinese. But I don't think "he always throws temper tantrums" or "he always finds a scapegoat" or "he's always badmouthing China even when he knows there's been a spike in hate crimes against Chinese people" are terribly good excuses. Premeditation and a pattern of behavior make his actions worse, not better. > because at the time, China was claiming they had basically solved Covid-19 with lockdowns and that the virus was no longer spreading in their country. You are putting words in his mouth. We don't know what he meant because he refused to answer the question. Immediately after that exchange, he cut the briefing short and left the room.
- Barrin92 6y agoI'd suggest to read Hunter S. Thompson's obituary on Nixon https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1994/07/he-was-a-crook/308699/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1994/07/he-was-... "It was all gibberish, of course. Nixon was no more a Saint than he was a Great President. He was more like Sammy Glick than Winston Churchill. He was a cheap crook and a merciless war criminal who bombed more people to death in Laos and Cambodia than the U.S. Army lost in all of World War II, and he denied it to the day of his death. When students at Kent State University, in Ohio, protested the bombing, he connived to have them attacked and slain by troops from the National Guard. Some people will say that words like scum and rotten are wrong for Objective Journalism -- which is true, but they miss the point. It was the built-in blind spots of the Objective rules and dogma that allowed Nixon to slither into the White House in the first place. He looked so good on paper that you could almost vote for him sight unseen. He seemed so all-American, so much like Horatio Alger, that he was able to slip through the cracks of Objective Journalism. You had to get Subjective to see Nixon clearly, and the shock of recognition was often painful." Journalism should not just stick 'to facts'. Journalism's objective is to speak truth to power by whatever means necessary and to bring truth to light. This often requires to get into the dirt. Facts you can find on Wikipedia or in the phone book, that's not what journalism is about. Good journalism is adversarial. The tech sector dislikes this in particular because they rely on the fact that they are not perceived as centres of power.
- imgabe 6y agoNixon bombed more people to death in Laos and Cambodia than the U.S. Army lost in all of World War II. Nixon connived to have Kent State students attacked and slain by the National Guard. These are both facts that can easily be reported and are more than damning enough on their own without editorializing. The editorializing actually makes the case weaker. It does a good job of riling up people who already agree with you, but to everyone else it just looks like you're biased and attacking someone because of a personal grudge.
- jariel 6y agoYou've contradicted yourself in your own comment though. First - Nixon inherited a war that others started, and put in place a strategy to end it, which he did. Second - Your statement "killed more people in Laos and Cambodia than the US Army lost in WW2" is technical factual, but also kind of nonsense. It's pointless to compare civilian casualties in one war, with Army casualties in another. Eisenhower definitely killed more civilians that Nixon - does that make him worse? See how your selective facts are actually a form of editorializing? Journalism is actually kind of hard, but yes, there is too much partisan news. Again this is our fault - if we clicked on straight news, and that's where the eyeballs went, that's where the money would go.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoNope, sorry. The extent to which Trump has been openly racist and inflammatory, providing motivation and boldness for various white supremacy hate groups, is severe and greatly damaging to US society - the damage and racism divide lasting far beyond the end of his term as president. It is absolutely appropriate for a reporter to question Trump’s overt racist behavior. That’s not editorializing, that’s just basic due diligence and engagement with the open fact of Trump’s behavior. Trump put it on the agenda by behaving in racist ways. It’s unacceptable for you to make a false equivalence with someone “editorializing” - it further entrenches racism if you act like calling out racism is inappropriate because it is “editorializing.” That’s just making excuses for categorically overt racists like Trump to go unchecked.