3 ms·
> Is it really that odd that "innovation" is slowing when the most lucrative professions for those with technical acumen do not further scientific knowledge, or
by gumby 6y ago
> Is it really that odd that "innovation" is slowing when the most lucrative professions for those with technical acumen do not further scientific knowledge, or technical capability?
I think the hubris that "innovation" requires technology is, while common, unwarranted. Although Christiansen use technological examples in his book, his thesis works without it.
Thomas Cook produced a major, world-changing innovation with no technology of his own. Sears was an innovation. MacDonalds was an innovation. The key idea of YouTube (aggregate by content type rather than topic) was not innovative (and wasn't even Youtube's idea); likewise Amazon's original idea did not involve developing technology (use pre existing technology to jump on a curve early, which is not having to manage retail inventory in small amounts).
Personally I have a technocentric approach and am uninterested in companies or models that don't involve developing new technology but I recognize that technology is rarely innovative in and of itself.
- judge2020 6y agoI agree with your last point the most - while most things are not innovative on their own, sometimes the implementation in itself is innovative. For example, YouTube might not be innovative for simply allowing only video uploads, but is is arguably an innovation in that it can handle 500 hours of video uploaded every minute[0] and does so profitably (well, maybe [1]). Amazon also definitely didn’t innovate on any concept with Amazon.com, but they did build AWS which started with the on-demand hardware/software space and opened the doors to thousands of startups that might actually be using AWS to push innovative products. 0: https://blog.youtube/press/ https://blog.youtube/press/ 1: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/02/03/google-still-isnt-telling-us-about-youtube-and-cloud-profits.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/02/03/google-still-isnt-telling-us...
- gumby 6y agoI attempted to be clear ("amazon's original idea") that the original innovation was not a technical innovation -- not only AWS but various warehouse, fulfillment and other developments have been technology-based. I also agree that subsequent development at Youtube has been technological. My point is that technology is neither sufficient nor even necessary for innovation and to assume so is to wear blinders. Sorry my brevity resulted in a lack of clarity. And we even have a term for pre-baconian work: "pure science" which is the stuff frequently and foolishly pointed at by the usual gradgrinds as being a waste of money.
- musicale 6y agoIt's tempting to confuse innovation with invention, but as you note they are not the same thing. For example, Apple didn't invent the MP3 player, or the smartphone, or tablet PCs. But they certainly innovated with the iPod, the iPhone, and the iPad, which became category-defining products.