4 ms·
Seriously, go read the analysis I linked. I was pleased to see it aligned well with my back of the envelope numbers, and it seems to say that Starlink has a bi
by mlyle 6y ago
Seriously, go read the analysis I linked. I was pleased to see it aligned well with my back of the envelope numbers, and it seems to say that Starlink has a bit of a potential challenge in reaching the underserved populations that it's receiving FCC subsidy to address... They've got a fairly decent model of number of satellites overhead vs. number of subscribers in that area (and assume no one outside of the subsidy customers will buy, which is pessimistic).
- Retric 6y agoI did, but I will more directly address where they are being overly pessimistic. For example, they are likely to prioritizing US coverage which could reach desired goals before completing the global network. Allocate 12,000 satellites equally spaced across 72 planes to approximate the Starlink fleet That’s a reasonable criticism for 2028, but not their actual goal. Assuming a 70% broadband uptake rate of assigned locations Clearly not the goal at 12k total satellites otherwise they would not be aiming for a larger network. 500-km coverage radius Doesn’t seem to be accurate based on other sources, but I would accept an actual source such as a current user. For RDOF locations, we have uplifted these estimates of peak usage to establish a minimum capacity required of 3.6 Mbps per subscriber That’s not how users behave, normally people use zero, ~maximum, or stream a specific amount of bandwidth. Which responds to the maximum available bandwidth. Anyway, they control the rate and geographic location of new users and can therefore maintain minimum bandwidth standards by slowing adoption based both their current network and user behavior.
- mlyle 6y ago> For example, they are likely to prioritizing US coverage This is difficult, because the earth spins under the orbital planes. > Assuming a 70% broadband uptake rate of assigned locations Clearly not the goal at 12k total satellites otherwise they would not be aiming for a larger network. This is the locations that Starlink has bid and received FCC subsidy for to provide connectivity for / receive subsidy for that are completely unserved by broadband. > 500-km coverage radius Doesn’t seem to be accurate based on other sources, but I would accept an actual source such as a current user. It's somewhat pessimistic, going all the way down to the elevation limit. tangent(55 degrees) * 550 kilometers = 785.481404 kilometers At the same time, it's not likely you'll often want to be talking to a satellite at the elevation limit, as it'll be 6-7 dB+ further down even before taking into account the phased array will offer less gain. > For RDOF locations, we have uplifted these estimates of peak usage to establish a minimum capacity required of 3.6 Mbps per subscriber That’s not how users behave, normally people use zero, ~maximum, or stream a specific amount of bandwidth. Which responds to the maximum available bandwidth. Forecast average peak hour demand was what was used to size these numbers, which is reasonable. Assuming stochastic demand with the same average makes this worse rather than better. > Anyway, they control the rate and geographic location of new users and can therefore maintain minimum bandwidth standards by slowing adoption based both their current network and user behavior. Starlink has committed to provide service to these users as a term for receiving these FCC subsidies.
- Retric 6y ago> Starlink has committed to provide service to these users as a term for receiving these FCC subsidies. And they can prioritize them over other US customers. But making the service available doesn’t mean 70% adoption in 6 years. Nor does it mean they need the same satellite density globally to cover their US customers. They can very much prioritize deployment of a larger network before finishing their 12,000 customer network just as some North American customers receive service before global coverage was available.
- mlyle 6y agoThe numbers assume 70% uptake among these customers -- which may or may not be pessimistic. The numbers also assume 0% uptake among anyone near these people that are not one of these customers. This is probably a little optimistic from a capacity planning perspective. > just as some North American customers receive service before global coverage was available. This was a feature of where initial ground stations were located, not of orbital dynamics. A given high inclination short-orbit-period satellite serves all longitudes equally, and the distribution of latitudes it serves is purely a function of its inclination.
- Retric 6y agoTheir are several ways to can synchronize the latitudes and longitudes such that you get a repeating pattern. This lets you cover the continental US without having global coverage. a commercially viable "initial" version of Starlink's service for the US would be possible with 400 satellites, while 800 would be enough for "significant" global coverage. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/elon-musk-says-starlink-now-has-enough-satellites-in-orbit-to-launch-a-public-beta-of-its-high-speed-internet-service/ar-BB19OQAJ https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/elon-musk-says-sta... Meanwhile 1200 was required for “full” global coverage. Polar orbits of course are another option for targeted coverage of high value markets.
- mlyle 6y ago> Their are several ways to can synchronize the latitudes and longitudes such that you get a repeating pattern. This lets you cover the continental US without having global coverage. This is seriously confused. The Earth turns under that repeating pattern, and the turning of the Earth is asynchronous unless the period of rotation is an integer multiple of the orbital period (which it isn't). We're in the peak hour right now. This is Starlink. There's no magical favoring of North America (well, except we have a non-operational "train" of new launches overhead). https://imgur.com/a/h94WRsQ https://imgur.com/a/h94WRsQ The only thing you can really do is pick your inclination wisely.