6 ms·
It's going to be hard to tie financial responsibility to individual officers in a way that doesn't ultimately come back to tax dollars anyway. Most likely if y
by toast0 6y ago
It's going to be hard to tie financial responsibility to individual officers in a way that doesn't ultimately come back to tax dollars anyway.
Most likely if you hold officers financially responsible as a rule, they'll take out errors and omissions policies. Salaries may be raised to pay for premiums, but either way it's tax payer money. The insured pool would probably be police officers from a wider area, but still tax payer money. So if you ended up getting a claim paid by insurance, it's just coming from a wider pool of tax payers.
If you only allowed people to be a police officer if they were wealthy enough to pay a judgement, that would be pretty gross.
- fgonzag 6y agoIf you force officers to carry malpractice insurance, the city only pays the base premium for a spotless record to the officers (collectively negotiated by the union most likely), anything extra is supposed to come out of their pockets. The insurance would probably disqualify gross negligence too, so police officers as a whole would have to be a lot more careful. It is far from an ideal solution but it should help start getting the ball rolling towards a more professional and transparent police force.
- tqi 6y agoI think the problem with this proposal is the us vs them mentality of police departments. I would expect that cops will continue to close ranks around the bad cops, and use these insurance claims as a tool against those that don't.
- iaw 6y agoThis is the most free-market approach to resolving police brutality that I've seen so far. With no ideal solutions sometimes the pragmatic ones are the best.
- TomSwirly 6y agoWhy is "free market" a good idea in this case? What's wrong with simply _enforcing the law_ on police officers?
- iaw 6y agoThe problem is who enforces the law for the enforcers? With actual financial incentives on the line (their insurance premiums and their jobs) we may see natural behavior change without having to build out a new enforcement apparatus that could be subject to the same abuse as the current one.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoI like it. Even if unions decide to start covering costs bad officers will get expensive quick. Free market will force out bad officers. We need to stop punting the cost of this to faceless entities like the state and allow the officers themselves to be sued and the free market will do the rest.
- roywiggins 6y agoThere's probably a pretty large constituency willing to give money to bad cops' crowdfunding campaigns. Free market works both ways- lots of people would be happy to subsidize this sort of behavior as long as they can be convinced the cops are being "canceled" by "antifa" or whatever.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoNearly all of the "bad cops" stories in the media, like nearly all stories in the media whatsoever, are toxoplasma: https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/17/the-toxoplasma-of-rage/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/17/the-toxoplasma-of-rage... If there is no case to be made in defending a cop, nobody wants to make it. But then it isn't a story, because it's only a story if it's a controversy. That creates the impression that many people are defending all of these bad cops in the clear cases, when they're really only defending them in the controversial cases.
- mr_toad 6y ago> If there is no case to be made in defending a cop, nobody wants to make it. Seems like the unions will defend an officer regardless of what they did.
- lmm 6y agoOf course they will, that's their job, just like a defense lawyer will defend anyone regardless of what they did.
- pseudalopex 6y ago
- maxerickson 6y agoThe base premium would be the cost of covering the typical available hire, not the cost of covering someone with several years of low cost behavior. Compare to credit reporting where everyone starts with a decent provisional score and then the cost of borrowing goes down if you demonstrate the correct risk/reward behavior.
- giantg2 6y agoThis is basically my thoughts too. I think the only real catching point is that the courts don't care about rights nor are police willing to really investigate claims against another officer. I have some very recent/on-going experience with this. There was a trooper who knowingly held a false charge against us, leading to restrictions in our freedoms and small costs. I contacted a civil rights attorney who told me the courts don't care unless we sustained significant costs/damages. Recovering costs would be great, but we would mostly like to see protections put into place so this doesn't happen to others (and maybe get this bad trooper removed). I filed one successful complaint against him. Then he took further actions and I filed another complaint. That complaint was closed without any investigation or justification - they didn't even tell me they were closing it.
- snomad 6y agoOr, they just do a better job of covering up for each other, choose to enforce the law less frequently, arrive to reported crimes slower, etc...
- alsetmusic 6y agoPolice unions have so much power that they’d force cities to cover them completely.
- ineptech 6y ago> If you force officers to carry malpractice insurance... With all respect, this sounds like an awful idea. Doctors have malpractice insurance because their field is an outlier in many ways. In almost every other profession, people who mess up get fired, not fined, and it works pretty well. Given that that is largely not the case with police officers, it seems like we should try what works everywhere else before we try the one-off exception we've carved out for medicine.
- ineptech 6y agoDownvoters, what am I missing? I'm not saying cops shouldn't be held accountable, I'm saying malpractice is a convoluted way to go about it. The default method (getting fired when you screw up) isn't really done effectively today; while it might be hard to implement, developing some equivalent to malpractice for cops, and making it stick, sounds an order of magnitude harder.
- Person5478 6y agoThere's a certain class of people who believe the free market can solve all problems, and for these people, the way you inject said free market is by using insurance. The thing is, you're right about it being convoluted and hard. But when you believe the free market cures all ills, you reach for the hammer even if what you're looking at is a screw. Similar to the adage "everything's a dildo as long as you have the will", the other truism is "everything's a nail if your hammer is being enough". We really just need to fire bad cops, but that solution isn't tenable due to police unions. The real solution has nothing to do with the cops themselves and everything to do with busting the police unions.
- tehwebguy 6y agoYou are talking about a solution that might work[0]. But the issue is not that this solution has not been tried, rather no solutions are being tried because the police simply refuse to allow any potential solutions. Most workers in the US are not protected by unions, the police are a stark exception to this. Their union contracts not only protect them as workers, they ensure protections that people absolutely would not believe, such as mandatory cooling off periods before police can be interviewed when charged with misconduct. Even if the rules were nearly even for police and non-police the issue remains that most enforcement would have to come from their peers (other police or DAs, even other enforcement officers at state and federal agencies will see themselves on the same team). They don’t want to subject one of their own to the criminal justice system because they know how cruel and damaging it is. [0] It actually won’t work though: - Taxpayers with police forces that actually avoid incidents that would pay out will still have to pay the insurance tax - Incidents of gross civil rights violations (such as intentionally arresting or killing someone when it was not warranted) are so injurious that nobody will insure the police forces that actually need it - In the interim we may see one of the worst possible outcomes: a police understanding that violations are simply a dollars and cents issue
- morty_s 6y agoIt’s clear police and their supporting systems don’t want to change. Dumb question—what about introducing a competing agency or agencies? How bad of an idea is a “for profit police force?”
- daniellarusso 6y agoDoctors have malpractice insurance. Could there not be something similar for other professionals that can end a person’s life while ‘on the clock’?
- vmception 6y agoYou have to make the consequences of non-compliance greater than the coverup. Make a lien on the pension which forces the old guard to feel uncomfortable and request department changes. Make this occur for the slightest infractions of any individual officer. Make the municipality have to disclose very significant policing stats when they want to issue a bond, and then quarterly. They currently have a complete disclosure exemption from the SEC. Turn on these consequences every time a police report doesn't match the video. Or whenever one just lies whether there is video or not. Make the partners accomplices when they don't report, and that alone being a trigger for the wide range of sanctions against the entire municipality. There are a lot of ways to make them turn on themselves, while keeping their primarily stated concern of being able to make split second decisions and get home safely at the end of the day. This would be much better than requiring all this fanfare for a small subset of egregious transgressions.
- Judgmentality 6y ago> It's going to be hard to tie financial responsibility to individual officers in a way that doesn't ultimately come back to tax dollars anyway. Why not just deduct all lawsuits and other costs from the collective pension fund for police departments? This seems like a trivial problem to solve (I mean assuming the goal were to solve it, and not increase police power while minimizing accountability). Once the police have to start paying for their own fuckups, I think they will quickly turn on each other. And in the event they decide to double down and hide it collectively, they risk losing the pension fund for the entire police department (obviously depends on the court settlement). At least they'll have skin in the game for their corruption.
- Thiez 6y agoSo good cops who have never done anything wrong and never looked the other way or covered up for their coworkers would lose their pension? Communal punishment is considered a war crime under the Geneva Conventions. While those clearly do not apply in the situation you propose, it may be an interesting datapoint for considering its fairness.
- Judgmentality 6y ago> So good cops who have never done anything wrong and never looked the other way or covered up for their coworkers would lose their pension? 100%, not even a second thought. We need reform, not excuses. Why do cops even get a pension in the first place? It should be a reward, not an entitlement. And it should only be rewarded if the entire department does its job, not an individual officer. They serve the community, and if the community is not served they should not be set for life. To be clear here, the bar is "don't break the law." This isn't some extraordinary standard we're expecting them to adhere to. In fact, we're only trying to hold them to the same standards they hold everybody else to.
- Thiez 6y ago> In fact, we're only trying to hold them to the same standards they hold everybody else to. Then convict them. You can't? Fix that. Why this convoluted scheme that punishes unrelated people? You say you want the same standards to apply to the police but on the other hand you accept that they can never be punished directly and their colleages must be fined instead. That's crazy inconsistent, those are not at all the standards that normal people are held to.
- garyfirestorm 6y ago> It's going to be hard to tie financial responsibility to individual officers in a way that doesn't ultimately come back to tax dollars anyway. Replace individual officer with individual common citizen. Knowingly doing something wrong results in <insert anything> for egg Knowingly driving a car into a building won’t be slap on the wrist and the tax payer will pay for it. It probably means you’ll be in jail, bankrupt etc. why shouldn’t same standard be applied?
- opo 6y ago>...It's going to be hard to tie financial responsibility to individual officers in a way that doesn't ultimately come back to tax dollars anyway. No one is going to sell you a liability policy to protect you from committing crimes. When police officers commit blatant misconduct the officers involved should at least be fired and criminal charges should be applied to them if applicable. This is how it works for every other job, not sure why police should be different.