4 ms·
> At a minimum that 12,000 satellite network means ~60 are within range at the same time. It doesn't work like that, unfortunately. It's not uniform and satel
by mlyle 6y ago
> At a minimum that 12,000 satellite network means ~60 are within range at the same time.
It doesn't work like that, unfortunately. It's not uniform and satellites in highly inclined orbits spend more time around the poles.
580 miles radius is also far too much. This may -barely- work for the outer shells, but the link budget and rates get worse there, and of course, these outer shell satellites need to be shared over an area enclosing more population.
Of course, link budget, data rates, and spectral efficiency also get worse as the satellites are lower in the sky, too.
Of course, receiving from an arbitrary subset of 60 transmitters occupying the same frequency band with an electrically steered phase array gets pretty hard when there's a big difference in the received power levels between the transmitters, too.
- Retric 6y agoSure, it’s also worth nothing that satellites over the ocean may not have a direct connection to a ground station or eventually be relaying long distance connections. That said, a ground station on the coast connecting to a satellite over the ocean has a huge impact on density calculations as so many people live along coastlines. Especially so when looking at Hawaii and other islands. However, this is all rough order of magnitude calculations. Starlink’s consolation is optimized for it’s potential customers rather than simply aiming for uniform global coverage. https://i1.wp.com/starnationsnews.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/starlink-satellite-constellation-orbital-map-hg-1.jpeg?resize=600%2C280&ssl=1 https://i1.wp.com/starnationsnews.com/wp-content/uploads/202...
- mlyle 6y agoSeriously, go read the analysis I linked. I was pleased to see it aligned well with my back of the envelope numbers, and it seems to say that Starlink has a bit of a potential challenge in reaching the underserved populations that it's receiving FCC subsidy to address... They've got a fairly decent model of number of satellites overhead vs. number of subscribers in that area (and assume no one outside of the subsidy customers will buy, which is pessimistic).
- Retric 6y agoI did, but I will more directly address where they are being overly pessimistic. For example, they are likely to prioritizing US coverage which could reach desired goals before completing the global network. Allocate 12,000 satellites equally spaced across 72 planes to approximate the Starlink fleet That’s a reasonable criticism for 2028, but not their actual goal. Assuming a 70% broadband uptake rate of assigned locations Clearly not the goal at 12k total satellites otherwise they would not be aiming for a larger network. 500-km coverage radius Doesn’t seem to be accurate based on other sources, but I would accept an actual source such as a current user. For RDOF locations, we have uplifted these estimates of peak usage to establish a minimum capacity required of 3.6 Mbps per subscriber That’s not how users behave, normally people use zero, ~maximum, or stream a specific amount of bandwidth. Which responds to the maximum available bandwidth. Anyway, they control the rate and geographic location of new users and can therefore maintain minimum bandwidth standards by slowing adoption based both their current network and user behavior.
- mlyle 6y ago> For example, they are likely to prioritizing US coverage This is difficult, because the earth spins under the orbital planes. > Assuming a 70% broadband uptake rate of assigned locations Clearly not the goal at 12k total satellites otherwise they would not be aiming for a larger network. This is the locations that Starlink has bid and received FCC subsidy for to provide connectivity for / receive subsidy for that are completely unserved by broadband. > 500-km coverage radius Doesn’t seem to be accurate based on other sources, but I would accept an actual source such as a current user. It's somewhat pessimistic, going all the way down to the elevation limit. tangent(55 degrees) * 550 kilometers = 785.481404 kilometers At the same time, it's not likely you'll often want to be talking to a satellite at the elevation limit, as it'll be 6-7 dB+ further down even before taking into account the phased array will offer less gain. > For RDOF locations, we have uplifted these estimates of peak usage to establish a minimum capacity required of 3.6 Mbps per subscriber That’s not how users behave, normally people use zero, ~maximum, or stream a specific amount of bandwidth. Which responds to the maximum available bandwidth. Forecast average peak hour demand was what was used to size these numbers, which is reasonable. Assuming stochastic demand with the same average makes this worse rather than better. > Anyway, they control the rate and geographic location of new users and can therefore maintain minimum bandwidth standards by slowing adoption based both their current network and user behavior. Starlink has committed to provide service to these users as a term for receiving these FCC subsidies.