7 ms·
Silicon Valley isn't full of fascists
- sawjet 6y agoThis article tries really hard to conflate conservatism with fascism
- kar5pt 6y agoIs there even a difference anymore? The only mainstream "conservative" party in America just acquitted a former politician who lead a mob to riot at the Capital. "Conservatives" are either implicitly supporting fascism or they're so detatched from the major political agents that they're politically insignificant.
- joemazerino 6y agoYes there is.
- jacob2484 6y agoSo you're complicit in the violence and deaths the BLM protests have caused? Yes there is a difference
- kaonashi 6y agoThe violence was 99% the cops beating on people, so not really, no.
- waych 6y agoDid the cops destroy all burn all those building and destroy all those businesses? Not really, no.
- kaonashi 6y agoMoving the goal post from violence to property damage?
- waych 6y agoBurning and looting are violent, just like murder.
- kaonashi 6y agono, they are categorically different
- waych 6y agovi·o·lence /ˈvī(ə)ləns/ noun behavior involving physical force intended to hurt, damage, or kill someone or something.
- kaonashi 6y agoif your definition places injuries to human beings in the same category as damage to things, then your definition is just an excuse to do violence on people
- waych 6y agoDamage to things damages people. This is hard for communists to understand, as they don't believe in private property. You can't have freedom and liberty without the security of private property. Learn some history.
- kaonashi 6y agoPrivate property is by definition a limit on freedom -- it's always a trade-off. Slave societies were always obsessed with protecting their freedoms.
- z9e 6y agoThere is a difference. Fascism is originally defined as national socialism by Mussolini. What Republicans do you see advocating for any such thing? Under actual Fascism, private ownership of businesses was allowed, but the government limited the profits they could make. Point me to where Republicans are trying to limit the amount of profits any company in the US can make. If the comparison is totalitarian tendencies, you have a lot of effort to go through to frame this as a one sided problem as both sides exhibit such time to time. The only thing conservatives and Fascists have in common is they are nationalist at this point, that's it. The constant throwing around of the Fascist label upon the right wing in this country is so disconnected from reality, as someone who loves history it makes me cringe to no end.
- krapp 6y ago"If it doesn't come from the Fascist region of Italy then it's just sparkling white supremacy." Wait until you learn that "Nazi" doesn't always explicitly refer to a member of the German National Socialist party.
- yurielt 6y agoNobody said that it does or has to do in that exact form but at this point some people want to be to loose in order to make a dishonest picture of anyone to the right of Mao
- mhh__ 6y agoI wouldn't associate the american right with fascism in the abstract but I think anyone who believes that Trump himself didn't at very least have some deeply worrying fascist-ic tendencies is kidding themselves: The ethno-nationalism, the distaste for democracy, the love of "powerful" men like Kim and Putin etc - the list is long and the signs were there from day 0. That's not "ooh you're a fascist now let me drink my starbucks"-fascism, but actual, dangerous, fascism that slips through the cracks - the US effectively came within one arbitrary vote in congress of ignoring an election result: If someone less inept than Trump comes along one day and tries I suspect it'll be a slam dunk in the land of the free. Counterargue my friends, facts don't care about your feelings
- _-david-_ 6y agoYou really should step away from the internet and actually talk to a regular conservative.
- esotericimpl 6y agoSuch as who? Ted Cruz? Face it, when conservatives chose fascism over democracy the game was over for them. There’s no going back after supporting insurrectionists.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> a former politician who lead a mob to riot at the Capital. Not a word you wrote is true. Trump was a sitting President, and the riot started before the end of his speech. His tweets for peace were deleted by twitter. (Pelosi refused to pay for Capitol Hill security before the large rally.) The only insurrection was the 8-months of city burning endorsed by the DNC. Why isn't Pelosi on trial yet?
- wilsynet 6y agoBecause she didn’t endorse a riot and neither did she endorse that cities should be burned. It’s utterly breathtaking how much Trump lies. But in your worldview, he’s the victim.
- rayiner 6y agoTrump didn’t endorse a riot either. And at the time of his speech, the pro-Trump protests after the election had been peaceful, to many people’s surprise. (DC had geared up for violence after the election, with plywood covering the windows, and until November 6 nothing happened.) I think Trump should have gotten impeached back in December for continuing to deny the legitimacy of the election after losing his legal challenges. But saying he incited the riot was an extremely tenuous charge.
- krapp 6y agoThe rioters clearly believed that they were doing what Trump wanted and following his desires if not his explicit orders - that impression didn't come from nowhere, it came from months of his encouragement and sympathy with with a deranged conspiracy theory provided by Trump himself. There are clearly implications in Trump's rhetoric that mere peaceful protest would not be enough: “We will never give up. We will never concede. It doesn’t happen. You don’t concede when there’s theft involved. Our country has had enough. We will not take it anymore, and that is what this is all about. And to use a favorite term that all of you people really came up with, we will stop the steal. … “You will have an illegitimate president. That is what you will have, and we can’t let that happen. These are the facts that you won’t hear from the fake news media. It’s all part of the suppression effort. They don’t want to talk about it. They don’t want to talk about it. … “We fight like hell, and if you don’t fight like hell, you’re not going to have a country anymore.” And there is also the content of his now deleted tweet after the fact where he appeared to justify the violence and praise those who committed it[0], and his phone call with House minority leader Kevin McCarthy on the 6th where Trump actually seemed to be smug about it[1]. And yes, in the deleted tweet he told people to "go home with love and peace," but that's hardly a condemnation of their actions. [0]https://media-cdn.factba.se/realdonaldtrump-twitter/1346954970910707712.jpg https://media-cdn.factba.se/realdonaldtrump-twitter/13469549... [1]https://thehill.com/homenews/house/538714-trump-told-mccarthy-that-rioters-more-upset-about-the-election-than-you-are https://thehill.com/homenews/house/538714-trump-told-mccarth... Maybe it doesn't rise to a strict legal definition of incitement, but the narrative being painted in his defense of there being no causal relationship between Trump and the riots, that he simply wanted law and order and peace, is clearly specious.
- Veen 6y agoIt endorses the unfortunate habit of collapsing distinctions on both the left and the right. In truth, although conservatives have occasionally aligned with fascists for pragmatic reasons and because they do share some values, they are not the same. When fascists come to power, conservatives are usually supressed; all conservative political parties were banned in Nazi Germany, for example. Anti-Nazi conservatives were among the victims of the Night of the Long Knives. Friedrich Reck-Malleczewen's Diary of a Man in Despair provides useful insight into how conservatives of the era viewed Nazis. He died in Dachau in 1945. The point people are miss is that Post-18th Century conservatism is a shade of liberalism in the broadest sense (not progressivism though), whereas fascism is resolutely anti-liberal. That said, right-of-center political parties contain lots of people who aren't remotely conservative: radical pro-market capitalists, libertarians, and the occasional fascist. They might all refer to themselves as conservatives, but that doesn't mean they are.
- orf 6y agoConservatives: not fascists, just #1 with fascists
- nicbou 6y agoIn a two horse race
- vanusa 6y agoWhich is perfectly understandable given how hard conservatives have worked to ingratiate themselves with fascists of various stripes, in recent years
- emptyparadise 6y agoWhat I learned so far is that Silicon Valley doesn't actually believe in anything. Ideas get adopted if they're profitable. That's it. There's no morality involved in this machine. It's genuinely wonderful that ideas about inclusivity and diversity are being accepted, but it's because of the understanding that people can do great work regardless of their background or sexual orientation that it happened, and not because of some moral imperative. It's how we can justify and talk up diversity while working on AI tech that can identify homeless people or ex-convicts. It's how we can condemn actions by the Trump administration while criticizing labor activism in Asia by coldly crunching the numbers to demonstrate that you can save money by putting your factory in a country that doesn't allow its people to protest. And you know what, fine. Just keep tossing anyone who doesn't play nice to the wolves. But please just stop pretending there's morality involved. Let's accept it: we're here in pursuit of profit. Any good that we do is just a nice side effect. The sooner we understand that the sooner we can actually do something about it. This applies to the media too, of course. I love the manic obsession with stability and morality combined with a lot of corporate and government money in a lot of US journalists' stories. You get great gems like hit pieces on privacy and encryption painted with a moral coat of paint that are better than anything the alphabet soup agencies could come up with - the Silicon Valley nazis are using Clubhouse, the pedophiles are using Signal, we must let the government monitor communications now! You get stories about reddit users in the stock market that somehow try to paint them as the alt-right while completely sidestepping any discussion of wealth inequality. Love it!
- legerdemain 6y agoFinally, a sane voice! It's time that we realized that many things are simply not political in nature, no matter what social justice demagogues want to tell us. Selling customer data to advertisers is economic, not political. Resisting being forced to classify independent business partners as "employees" is economic, not political. The ethnicity, race, and gender of your applicant pool is economic, not political. Politics has to do with generation-defining issues of our time, like choosing a more rational voting system at the national level and building broad support for a sensible third party that genuinely represents the interests of voters like myself, who are poorly served by the trifling squabbles of the current political "establishment." All this other stuff that certain biased parties want to paint as "political" is just the natural outcome of well-understood deterministic processes of economic self-interest, nothing more and nothing less. No use whining about cold, hard reality!!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- brnt 6y agoBut it is full of useful idiots. Reading up on the role of German industry in the Weimar Republic, or on the how and why of Russian psy ops methods; such knowledge is often avoided in favour of simple one-liners like "limitless freedom of opinion good". Its one of those excellent demonstrations of how one can be both intelligent and yet not at all at the same time. The American political environment actively discourages nuance, which gets into discourse at every level unfortunately.
- fithisux 6y agoWhat is the proportion?
- Barrin92 6y agoSV is overwhelmingly liberal in a general sense (like almost all urban, educated regions), and lacks a lot of gun rights advocates and church goers or standard conservatives, which is what Noah appears to be looking for in the piece. When people talk about fascism in tech they don't talk about a 'bum with a swastika on the arm', but what Jeffrey Herf coined 'Reactionary Modernism'[1]. An extreme belief that technology will replace liberal or democratic values altogether. And there is a substantial, and fairly hidden, adherence to this in tech. And because those people don't storm the capital and probably vote Biden they don't show up in so many surveys. And this is very SV specific. You won't find this in the tech scene of Berlin, Zürich or New York. It's closely tied to the 'Californian Ideology', a sort of new form of futurism that is in many ways similar to its historical predecessor. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactionary_modernism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactionary_modernism
- eli_gottlieb 6y agoSure, but on a certain level, what actually matters for real politics is that "those people" didn't storm the Capitol and probably voted for Biden. Technocracy is bad, but it's simply not the kind of "fascism" up for discussion in American mainstream media right now.
- belval 6y agoI am somewhat perplexed by the headline, who in their right mind would argue that FANG are fascists or even conservative? It borders on the absurd if anything having openly right-wing opinion in tech is a good way to be excluded at work. I wouldn't say that SV leans left either, most actions are virtue signaling to appeal to changing public opinion.
- univalent 6y agoWho said it was?!
- artem247 6y agoBut the NYT article really put an emphasis on that Silicon Valley is far from "classic" US conservatism when it talks about Red vs Blue vs Gray tribes. There is no need to argue that most of tech elite are hardly Trump voters, especially in terms of identity politics. But in terms of economy I think the SV discourse is maybe already much closer to what Scott Alexander had outlined in his Left Libertarianism article. [0] I feel that this ideology which combines unregulated capitalism with social safety net is very far from socialism, progressivism, social democracy etc. What I do not understand - why is it such a shame in not being a leftist for educated middle-class coastal Americans? [0} https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/12/08/a-something-sort-of-like-left-libertarianism-ist-manifesto/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/12/08/a-something-sort-of-li...
- jjk166 6y agoFascism is ultranationalist, collectivist authoritarianism. Silicon Valley is definitely not ultranationalist, and for the most part not particularly collectivist. Certainly no one in silicon valley is calling for corporatist autarky, nor would you find much support for mass militarization of society or paramilitary violence. Technosolutionism is not fascism, libertarianism is not fascism, cancel culture is not fascism, socialism is not fascism, laissez faire capitalism is not fascism, letting fascists express their opinions is not fascism, censoring fascists is not fascism. Of course this is semantics, and when most americans talk about fascism, they are talking about something else which may or may not have some vague resemblance to fascism, but meaningful dialogue is impossible if we can't agree what it is we're discussing.