3 ms·
I think it's worthwhile perhaps asking some random musicians what they think music "theory" consists of. They will probably be the first to agree that it's not
by analog31 6y ago
I think it's worthwhile perhaps asking some random musicians what they think music "theory" consists of. They will probably be the first to agree that it's not the same as "theory" in the sciences or "theory" in the humanities.
I'm a jazz musician, and have learned very little theory myself beyond basic notation, scales, and chords. I can hold my own on the bandstand.
But without exception, the musicians who are capable of composing and arranging new material of any quality have all studied theory. I think it expands your creative vocabulary in ways that I can't really explain.
- meowkit 6y agoIn my opinion, it expands your creative vocabulary via analysis and synthesis. If you can analyze a riff or a progression, take it apart and identify its melodic, harmonic, rhythmic, and tonal components, then you can use the combos you like to synthesis new stuff later with improv and audia-tion. Theory just gives you a catalog and process for naming things. I think many musicians learn a lot of this implicitly through their ears, never learning the names and patterns. It works, but its probably slower.
- analog31 6y agoIt's certainly been slower for me. Thanks to being a bassist, I was able to function in ensembles long before learning to improvise melodic solos. Today, soloing is a major part of my playing, but I struggle with difficult, modern changes. It amazes me that Chick Corea had limited formal education, given his wizardry at both composition and improvisation. Nobody could thread a melodic line through complex changes, with such grace.