5 ms·
Realistically all music theory is a joke - an incredibly useful joke if you want to make music, but it's not a theory in any sense of the word: all music theory
by mhh__ 6y ago
Realistically all music theory is a joke - an incredibly useful joke if you want to make music, but it's not a theory in any sense of the word: all music theory is, is a group of notations and conventions for characterising sound and how to get a certain sound.
You could regard the period and origin of a given theory as a set of axioms, e.g. African classical music has almost nothing to do with Bach, but you'd be missing the point.
20th century and Levine's books are a good introduction to applying music theory to do bizarre and twisted things when improvising.
- guerrilla 6y agoAdam Neely has an entertaining video essay ranting about that in some detail: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Kr3quGh7pJA https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Kr3quGh7pJA
- djaychela 6y agoI'd disagree with it being entertaining. I like a lot of his videos, but saying that it equates to white supremacy is an unhelpful and simplistic viewpoint which perpetuates a rather tiring rhetoric of self - loathing against western society. Music theory was simply codified by people using Western classical music as a yardstick, and taking the common ideas expressed in it as the music to analyse using it. Is definitely somewhat out of date, and in need of improvement to encompass not only the music created in other cultures but also textural and sonic expression which makes up interesting music which could otherwise be under - analysed using WCM as the baseline, but equating this to white supremacy is to me incorrect, and missing the point of what's actually needed - an update.
- guerrilla 6y agoDid you watch it? He's not calling music theory itself white supremacist but the current culture that refers to it as "music theory" per se as in "the" music theory opposed to "a" music theory/theory of music. That it is seen as the yard stick and the only thing that taught is the problem, as that's clearly exclusionary, not the existence of the theory which can be no more racist than any other. I see nothing self-loathing about that. It's a useful criticism that might help get music education to broaden its horizons, which it already has started to do it seems.
- coldtea 6y ago>Did you watch it? He's not calling music theory itself white supremacist but the current culture that refers to it as "music theory" per se as in "the" music theory opposed to "a" music theory/theory of music And he is still wrong. Every culture refers to its own music theory (or most any other kind of theory) as THE theory, not "A" theory. That's not because of supermacist tendencies, it's just familiarity and closeness. It's usually not useful, nor are we get any special benefit from, to take into account 2000 other traditions (even our own past ones, or some niche traditions in our midst) when we talk of the kind of music we do 95% of the time. It would be like saying "I am hungry - and this is my personal feeling", "This artist is fire - and I say this speaking on behalf of myself alone", "Macaroni and cheese is the best comfort food, for me that is". A useless and tiresome clarification. Even more so when everybody else (e.g. every other culture) doesn't reciprocate the same, and speaks of its own stuff as THE stuff. So, yeah, this is just a fad, and a very US-centric 2010-20x0 at that. No Italian would give two fucks if they refer to regular western music theory as THE music theory.
- guerrilla 6y agoI think it's pretty blind to teach people that "this is music" rather than "this is how we've done music here and other people over there do it differently." We live in a global civilization now and there's no reason not to reap the benefits or to be exclusionary. Ignoring Indian and Chinese theories today is just sticking your head in the sand and promoting some weird type of conservatism. It'd be like ignoring the non-Western parts of math just because. That's completely irrational. > Even more so when everybody else (e.g. every other culture) doesn't reciprocate the same, and speaks of its own stuff as THE stuff. I've never seen this to be true in Indian music discussion. They know Western music too. I can only assume the same is true in China being that America and Europe export so much.
- coldtea 6y ago>I think it's pretty blind to teach people that "this is music" rather than "this is how we've done music here and other people over there do it differently." We live in a global civilization now and there's no reason not to reap the benefits or to be exclusionary. Maybe start american people actually listening to music outside of the US and UK? (And I'm not referring to latin americans listening to latin music). They're some of the most chauvinistic peoples when it comes to consumption of music, movies, tv series, books, etc. Then we can worry about some jazz player at Berklee or some high schooler at a school band learning western music theory as "this is music" vs learning about the gamelan or classical indian ragas... >I've never seen this to be true in Indian music discussion. They know Western music too. I can only assume the same is true in China being that America and Europe export so much. That's only because they have to play this too, as it has become popular in the 20th century. Historically however there was no mention or need to mention western music theory though.
- codeulike 6y agoIdeas about ratios between note frequencies, overtones of different notes co-inciding, and how those overtones affect the cilia in the inner ear and hence our perception of sound could perhaps be called a theory proper. e.g. Octaves are fairly universal in world music, so there might be a physiological basis for that.
- lukeschlather 6y agoOctaves have a very straightforward mathematical basis. Double the pitch, you get an octave. What is pitch? It is defined in hertz, the number of times the underlying vibration repeats per second. If you have an octave, you take one pitch like 220, then you double it to 440. That is the next octave. It's clear that if you define the "underlying vibration" as a sound that oscillates twice (2hz) then the 440hz sound is also in a way a 220hz sound. Thus the octave is really just a recognition of that mathematical relationship between the two pitches.
- jeofken 6y agoThe 5th too is very simple. It is 1.5x the root. So the the 8th of 440Hz is 880Hz, and the 5th is 660Hz. Western musical theory is amazingly fractional
- benrbray 6y agoActually, most music produced on physical instruments in the west doesn't have such nice ratios. I suggest reading about equal temperament (or watching some Adam Neely videos) if you're interested in learning more about how our tuning system diverges from the Pythagorean ideal.
- jeofken 6y agoNot for us string players :)
- codeulike 6y agoI know that. The interesting bit is why does it sound right?. Probably something to do with overtones and cilia.
- daviddaviddavid 6y agoI would disagree that "it's not a theory in any sense of the word". There is an established sense of the word "theory" in which its meaning is derived from how it contrasts with "practice". Theory vs Practice is a fairly common dichotomy. In music of course, the practice part is just playing. The fact that this sense of the word has less precise boundaries than the notion of theory in math/logic/science doesn't render it totally useless IMO.
- coldtea 6y agoI'm not sure what kind of theory you have in mind, but music theory is very much a theory (let's stick to traditional western music theory for now). Perhaps you compare it with something like Physic's theory. That it is not. But it's more like a mathematical theory, a set of axioms, and an algebra of relationships and properties that derive from them. And of course it's a theory as opposed to the actual practice (applying it to playing an instrument).
- mhh__ 6y ago> But it's more like a mathematical theory, a set of axioms, and an algebra of relationships and properties that derive from them. That's what I take issue with. I vaguely agree with the notion that music theory does have some kind of axiomatic form hidden deep within, but what can you prove? There is no fundamental theorem of Counterpoint, or that 12-tone rows are the work of the devil etc.
- coldtea 6y agoThe axioms are more high level: what is the major/minor form, how one derives the modes, etc. It's not about reductionistically (?) deriving even those from first principles.
- benrbray 6y agoI think you have it backwards. It's nothing like a mathematical theorem, since you can't really prove anything about the subjective human experience of listening to music. Physics on the other hand, though it relies on mathematical models, can't really explain why the universe exists in the particular way that it does. The best we can do is use the scientific method to make very educated guesses at an accurate mathematical model that might help us accurately explain the behavior of some physical system we're interested in. Physics is full of inconsistencies and unexplained phenomena, but we're slowly getting better at making predictions. Music theory is the same way. Music sounds good to humans, and there doesn't really need to be a deeper reason than that for me to listen to a song over and over. Music theorists will study the music that people tend to like / dislike, and do their best to come up with an explanation for why -- often by pulling it apart into its core components, comparing it to other works, analyzing chord structure, voicing, instrumentation, etc.. In the end, just as with physics, composers have slowly built up a reliable foundation of knowledge to help them compose music that will reliably sound "good". But every so often someone comes along with an earworm that can't fully be explained.
- mhh__ 6y agohttps://www.amazon.co.uk/Twentieth-Century-Harmony-Creative-Aspects-Practice/dp/0393095398 https://www.amazon.co.uk/Twentieth-Century-Harmony-Creative-... is the book (can't edit)