4 ms·
A few points: - What if the file had been labeled "Britney Spears Nudes.rar?" What about "Ubuntu 12.04 Saucy Serpent.iso?" Does the fact that it was labeled as
by pyre 15y ago
A few points:
- What if the file had been labeled "Britney Spears Nudes.rar?" What about "Ubuntu 12.04 Saucy Serpent.iso?" Does the fact that it was labeled as a work that was not authorized for p2p distribution (by a completely different copyright holder, mind you) change things that significantly?
- If it can be proven that the copyright holders are distributing their works on p2p networks under different names in order to ensnare people into the "do I pay $3k to make this go away or $$$$ to defend myself in court" question, then that should constitute some sort of fraud.
- Applying this logic to other areas also fails the "does this make sense" test. Should you go to jail for downloading child pornography if someone sends you a link to download "Cute Kitten Photos.rar?"
- A person has no idea that they are violating the copyright of copyright holder X when they download the file. They can only verify the file contents once the file is downloaded. Sure they may have intended to commit copyright infringement against copyright holder Y, but so longer as this is not the same person as copyright holder X, I don't see how copyright holder X should have any standing to 'punish' this user on behalf of copyright holder Y.
- ChuckMcM 15y ago"A person has no idea that they are violating the copyright of copyright holder X when they download the file." And this is my whole point. Everyone knows the correct way to get copyrighted content from the internet. You use iTunes, or Amazon's MP3 service, or NetFlix, or Hulu, or any number of services. Everyone also knows that when you get a legal copy of a copyrighted work there will be a 'payment' or a 'subscription' involved. Naive people (I choose not to use the pejorative 'stupid' in this case) should know that any downloading of a copyrighted work which doesn't involve a subscription, or a fee, is nearly always illegal. This sort of action might train them with this fact. Can you share information which is CC licensed or out of copyright or public domain? Absolutely. And I don't believe Titan Media or anyone else would be successful in pursuing someone by 'tricking' them with a filename that would otherwise be legitimate. They could certainly try to sue you but any lawyer could move for a dismissal based on the clients beleif that the material was what it said it was, and deleted it immediately when they discovered it was not. There is no way to prove any sort of intent to violate copyright that way. Look of the case of Tracy Lords and her underage pornos where the buyer wasn't liable for child porn because she had represented to the production company and the production company had represented to the customer that everyone in the production was of legal age. So if this educates a few thousand people that trying to get free copies of copyrighted stuff over the Internet is illegal and to stop trying (that would the educating the naive part) then its a good thing.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- bxr 15y ago>Everyone knows the correct way to get copyrighted content from the internet. You use iTunes, or Amazon's MP3 service, or NetFlix, or Hulu, or any number of services. Everyone also knows that when you get a legal copy of a copyrighted work there will be a 'payment' or a 'subscription' involved. No. No they don't know. And no, no there isn't payment for every legal copy. You mention Hulu. Lets look at that real quick. What if someone sets up a website that mimics hulu's free video system, with a different brand but just as legit looking and with pirated material, hell, lets say they even run ads. No one would know if the website was legit or not, especially not if there were no news articles about it. Furthermore, look at youtube. The version of video X uploaded by hulu has no copyright violation, the version uploaded by hulo does violate copyright. Congresspeople upload clips from CSPAN. Are they breaking copyright? Did they get authorization from CSPAN for every single clip? Really? How do I know that? Don't act like that the user knows. I still find myself explaining to the less technologically inclined that getting songs with whatever p2p software they're using is illegal. Don't even pretend that you can put the burden on the user to determine what websites are kosher.
- pyre 15y ago>> A person has no idea that they are violating the copyright of copyright >> holder X when they download the file." > > And this is my whole point. No, it is not your whole point. They are being sued based on the contents of the file when the file with masquerading as something completely different. The fact that they intended to violate copyright in the first place is irrelevant. In this case, the files were masquerading as copyrighted works that this plaintiff does not hold the copyright for. It would be up to the copyright holder to attempt to sue these people, not someone completely different just because it will 'teach people a lesson.' This kind of 'teach people a lesson' bullshit is no different than when the DoJ was trying to say that violating MySpace's Term of Service was tantamount to Computer Hacking/Fraud because there were no other laws to punish that lady that caused the student to commit suicide. The idea that someone should be punished for something they didn't intend to do, even though their original intent was bad in the first place is an abuse of the legal system, IMO. It's probably easier to boil it down to this: The user is being sued for 'violating the copyright of copyright holder X' not for some nebulous 'violating copyright but it doesn't matter what copyright' infraction or else I could sue you for violating someone else's copyright. Therefore the question should really be, "is it reasonable to have expected the user to know that they would have violated the copyright of copyright holder X when they downloaded/uploaded that file?" You're trying to phrase the question as, "is it reasonable to have expected the user to know that they were violating any copyright when they downloaded/uploaded the file?"