25 ms·
We don't have these companies going nationwide because it's one of those things that's inherently a small to medium business. It doesn't work places with high
by mlyle 6y ago
We don't have these companies going nationwide because it's one of those things that's inherently a small to medium business. It doesn't work places with high population density. It doesn't work places with very low population density. It requires compliance with local codes and a relatively high amount of real estate work per subscriber. They don't benefit from legal frameworks intended to make things better for cellular carriers.
Satellite is great for very low to low population density, and fill-in coverage in medium population densities.
Fixed wireless is good for low to medium population density in most geographies, and fill-in coverage in high population densities.
Wired internet access is good for places with medium to high population density.
Cellular can provide fill-in coverage for medium to high population densities.
- Retric 6y agoSatellite population density is a little different as individual Starlink satellites cover a ~580 mile radius circle. Illinois is only 232 people per square mile and near the Great Lakes so as far as the satellites are concerned, and excluding the core urban areas with high speed internet, the area has a fairly low population density. The Northeast megalopolis is a larger issue, but again it’s next to the ocean which makes a huge difference. Further including launch costs it’s ~2 million a satellite. Depending on lifespan break even could be below 1,000 customers per satellite which could support a very dense network. Especially if they charge more for aircraft and boat internet access. PS: Current Satellites are 20GBPs, so if they average ~1000 people per satellite that’s 20 MBps bandwidth per customer. Traditional home internet can be 10x oversubscribed, but assuming they lose a lot of that to low population areas 1-2x ~= 20-40MBPs in high density areas during peak usage periods.
- mlyle 6y agoMy town and the town next to it have 25,000 households. If you want to provide 50 mbit/sec to 20% of households, while oversubscribing by 50x, ... you've basically used up 20-40% of a simultaneous-overhead-satellite. At any time, you can expect there will be dozens of towns of my size in the footprint. (And, well, most of the time, the entire SF Bay Area, and the Monterey metropolitan area). Starlink can sell tons of subscriptions, but they can't address suburban connectivity issues. An alternative analysis, looking at the FCC RDOF areas where funds were awarded to Starlink (completely unserved by broadband-- very low density areas) areas says that Starlink can address around 50% of these households -- not counting any capacity sold to nearby users in cities or towns -- and provide 15mbps peak hour usage-- which is expected to be typical peak hour usage in a few years. https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/10208168836021/FBA_LEO_RDOF_Assessment_Final_Report_20210208.pdf https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/10208168836021/FBA_LEO_RDOF_Ass... P.S. I see your edit and that now you're making an economic argument. I totally think Starlink can be profitable. I don't think Starlink can address anything but the least dense areas and occasional fill-in in other areas, but these are still very large potential markets. As to supporting a very dense network... there are reasonable limits on how many satellites we can expect to have overhead. P.P.S. gbps not GBps. Currently thought to be 10gbps, but also it's thought they will not have much issue reaching to 20gbps.
- Retric 6y agoEarth only has 196,900,000 square miles. A 580 square mile circle is 580^2 * 3.14 so a little over 1 million square miles. At a minimum that 12,000 satellite network means ~60 are within range at the same time. At 42,000 your at ~210 overhead at the same time. While nobody can see every part of the sky, across tens of thousands of people plenty will get at least a slice near the horizon. So, you can include satellites out over the ocean and exclude people with access to high speed internet already. Overall a 42,000 satellite network could connect something like 1/2 the “1.3 million people in California without access to a wired connection capable of 25 Mbps download speeds.” As I doubt 1/2 those households are going to want to pay 100$/month for internet the 42,000 satellite network should cover California just fine. PS: Of note their ground receiver can only point to a slice of the sky, but I suspect plenty of people near the ocean will focus on that slice of the sky for better bandwidth.
- Retric 6y agoIt should be clear from context but: * A 580 square mile A 580 mile radius
- mlyle 6y ago> At a minimum that 12,000 satellite network means ~60 are within range at the same time. It doesn't work like that, unfortunately. It's not uniform and satellites in highly inclined orbits spend more time around the poles. 580 miles radius is also far too much. This may -barely- work for the outer shells, but the link budget and rates get worse there, and of course, these outer shell satellites need to be shared over an area enclosing more population. Of course, link budget, data rates, and spectral efficiency also get worse as the satellites are lower in the sky, too. Of course, receiving from an arbitrary subset of 60 transmitters occupying the same frequency band with an electrically steered phase array gets pretty hard when there's a big difference in the received power levels between the transmitters, too.
- Retric 6y agoSure, it’s also worth nothing that satellites over the ocean may not have a direct connection to a ground station or eventually be relaying long distance connections. That said, a ground station on the coast connecting to a satellite over the ocean has a huge impact on density calculations as so many people live along coastlines. Especially so when looking at Hawaii and other islands. However, this is all rough order of magnitude calculations. Starlink’s consolation is optimized for it’s potential customers rather than simply aiming for uniform global coverage. https://i1.wp.com/starnationsnews.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/starlink-satellite-constellation-orbital-map-hg-1.jpeg?resize=600%2C280&ssl=1 https://i1.wp.com/starnationsnews.com/wp-content/uploads/202...