3 ms·
Line of sight is a bit of a pain. So is needing sky in all directions to 10-20 degrees of elevation. Satellite is great for A) where it's not worth putting up
by mlyle 6y ago
Line of sight is a bit of a pain. So is needing sky in all directions to 10-20 degrees of elevation.
Satellite is great for A) where it's not worth putting up towers to reach just a few residents, and B) filling in where there's little holes in tower coverage. (This is what I tried to say in the comment you're replying to).
> The other problems haven't really been an issue for Starlink, even for being in the early phases, it's really just the density issue that bites it.
Capital costs are high per simultaneous user served in an area. Densification is hard. Spectral efficiency is the key figure of merit (how many bits you get to users per limited bit of radio spectrum). That is, the things I mention *are* the reasons for the "density issue".
- Retric 6y agoSpectrum is different with satellites as it’s using directional antenna. In theory you can have nearly arbitrary satellite density depending on efficiency. The only effective limit is the user density you’re aiming to support.
- mlyle 6y agoFixed wireless uses directional antennas, too. Towers can have sector antennae, and you can have multiple towers servicing an area, too. (Indeed, small LEO satellites' ability to spot beam is limited, but sectors on fixed wireless can provide a -lot- of densification).
- Retric 6y agoDirectional antennas on the ground are a much higher risk from obstructions. Multipath propagation is essential for large wireless networks without building giant towers everywhere.
- mlyle 6y ago> Directional antennas on the ground are a much higher risk from obstructions. Giant towers / hillsides for the central point; small towers or rooftops for the other end. Between two hills over my suburb, you can see 80%+ of houses. If your point is that this doesn't work well for dense cities: you're right, but it breaks down at a higher population density than satellite does. Relying upon multipath and diffraction can work to get moderate quality LTE service everywhere, but in general this is not what WISPs are doing, because it doesn't work. (And in any case, MIMO + multipath are friends, too, which provides its own densification, and sector antennae are effective, too).
- Retric 6y agoThis is why WISPs are so location specific. With the right geography, population density, etc it can work but we don’t have these companies going nationwide.
- mlyle 6y agoWe don't have these companies going nationwide because it's one of those things that's inherently a small to medium business. It doesn't work places with high population density. It doesn't work places with very low population density. It requires compliance with local codes and a relatively high amount of real estate work per subscriber. They don't benefit from legal frameworks intended to make things better for cellular carriers. Satellite is great for very low to low population density, and fill-in coverage in medium population densities. Fixed wireless is good for low to medium population density in most geographies, and fill-in coverage in high population densities. Wired internet access is good for places with medium to high population density. Cellular can provide fill-in coverage for medium to high population densities.
- Retric 6y agoSatellite population density is a little different as individual Starlink satellites cover a ~580 mile radius circle. Illinois is only 232 people per square mile and near the Great Lakes so as far as the satellites are concerned, and excluding the core urban areas with high speed internet, the area has a fairly low population density. The Northeast megalopolis is a larger issue, but again it’s next to the ocean which makes a huge difference. Further including launch costs it’s ~2 million a satellite. Depending on lifespan break even could be below 1,000 customers per satellite which could support a very dense network. Especially if they charge more for aircraft and boat internet access. PS: Current Satellites are 20GBPs, so if they average ~1000 people per satellite that’s 20 MBps bandwidth per customer. Traditional home internet can be 10x oversubscribed, but assuming they lose a lot of that to low population areas 1-2x ~= 20-40MBPs in high density areas during peak usage periods.
- 6y ago
- zamadatix 6y agoStarlink currently cuts off minimum elevation at 40 degrees, with lower shells they'd eventually like to drop that to 25 degrees. Not sure where you're pulling these 10-20 degree numbers from but allowing it to go that low would actually create more problems than it would solve. > That is, the things I mention are the reasons for the "density issue". The things you mentioned were path loss, no need for beam stearing, possibility of wired backhaul, and density. I'm just saying the only one of those that actually matters is density, the others are really non problems as the equipment already exists, is reasonably priced, and works fine.
- mlyle 6y ago> Not sure where you're pulling these 10-20 degree numbers from Starlink uptime where I am-- SF Bay Area-- with a 35 degree elevation cutoff is 80%. 25 degree elevation cutoff is 98-99%. To get 99.5% you need to get down to 15 degrees presently. Yes, this will improve, but for an area to share their bandwidth over multiple satellites, there'll need to be multiple satellites in the cone that that area can talk to. > The things you mentioned were path loss, Less path loss for a given power == more bits/Hz == more people served from one transceiver with a certain amount of bandwidth. AKA density > no need for beam stearing OK. That's a terminal cost issue, and isn't density. Though it's closely related to allowing the towers to have narrower coverage (e.g. sector antennae) and thus improves density. > possibility of wired backhaul Ground station uplink bandwidth is often limiting for Starlink. Allowing more bandwidth to the transceiver == density. > density Allowing densification by putting up more towers where needed == density. > , is reasonably priced, Right now, Starlink terminal BOM costs are likely around $2k. This can be expected to improve in the future, but electrically steered phased arrays with tons of phases are still a somewhat exotic technology. C.f. high end fixed wireless CPE selling for $200 at qty 1 retail (they, also, can be expected to improve in cost and bandwidth in the future).
- zamadatix 6y agoYou're speculating as fact an awful lot here and it's making it difficult to talk about what actually is. For instance the elevation cutoff isn't arbitrary i.e. it's not "whatever number would make it work reliably at my house". It doesn't matter if a satellite is available at 15 degrees you will not have service until one is available at a higher angle. I assume you're looking at something like (or following similar logic to) https://sebsebmc.github.io/starlink-coverage/index.html https://sebsebmc.github.io/starlink-coverage/index.html and well... there's a reason that page has 2 options in the drop down - the current limit of functionality and the proposed future limit of functionality. Also I think it goes without saying if it's not fully launched where you live then where you live is a poor choice to even try to reverse engineer numbers in the first place. I will give a list of facts about Starlink as it currently stands, not my personal speculation or speculation from others rather knowledge from currently working with operational Starlink and many fixed wireless providers in a large enterprise network: - Path loss is not a driving factor in the density problem (more details on why in another section but it boils down to the bandwidth losses by this are not what's causing the density squeeze). The path loss is also very different than the path loss to a terrestrial tower as there is a lot more at play than distance (atmospheric density, atmospheric composition, frequency, frequency interaction with molecules in the atmosphere, power limits for interference being different for ground<->horizontal vs ground<->up) so you can't just think "more distance therefore path loss is a bigger problem than it is for fixed wireless" either. - The cost for the service is $499 + $99 * month for a real world expected rate of 100 Mbps/20 Mbps @ 1 TB/month soft cap w/o throttling. This pricing beats >95% of fixed wireless offerings, Verizon's 5G demo cities probably being the exception. Pricing is not a problem even if there is fancy tech involved on the user terminal. - Ground station bandwidth hasn't been a problem for Starlink, let alone an oft problem as you confidently claim. They also continue to be turned up at the same rate as new satellites go active so no need to speculate their either. - It's quite easy to add both more towers and satellites but neither is actually a realistic solution to their respective spectral density problem as for towers density comes to the point the cost savings of using towers for the last mile in the first place go out the window and for satellites the spectral density problem is on the ground. Remember it's not going to be a fully shared collision domain like Wi-Fi where you just spread the same frequency to everyone attached in a sector. - Both can be expected to improve drastically in the future. Starlink is barely deployed enough to function at all at the best geographical locations, many of the assigned frequencies aren't in use, satellite<->satellite still hasn't been deployed, the lower shell hasn't even been started, only a handful of ground stations are up. Similarly 5G (or the latest 4G) is still early in deployment in the US, good & cheap 5G hardware is just really becoming available at scale, network deployments are really kicking into gear.