4 ms·
I generally love Stack Overflow, and have been active on it for ages, but there are a huge number of mods who see it as their life mission to close as many ques
by kstrauser 6y ago
I generally love Stack Overflow, and have been active on it for ages, but there are a huge number of mods who see it as their life mission to close as many questions as possible. See also: Wikipedia deletionists.
- Twixes 6y agoJust… why?
- weujruerwuwe 6y agoPairing of an ego fed by making "contributions" to the community with an inability to contribute in a way that adds to the knowledge base.
- indeedmug 6y agoIt seems like it's wrong that removing contributions would count as a contribution.
- coldtea 6y agoPerhaps a good gamification would be to freeze their accounts if they close too much?
- Qwertious 6y agoThat means that if spammers spam enough questions for the mods to shut down, the mods' accounts will be frozen and spammers will be able to spam unchallenged. Also, that requires fine-tuning of the "too much".
- coldtea 6y agoWe're talking about legit, but bad questions. I'd expect actual spam questions to be closed automatically, similar to spam email.
- numpad0 6y agoDid you just describe the systemic dilemma of social media where: - value is judged by how controversial something is, but; - users who “crossed the line” are “not tolerated” and banned?
- opportune 6y agoI feel like Wikipedia is different because it actively harms the platform when people put up non-notable content, since it reduces the signal to noise and turns the platform into a way to launder legitimacy/importance. For example your local dentist should probably not have a wikipedia article, and you don't want there to be an arms race of every local dentist trying to get a wikipedia article so that they seem important. The other issue is that many novice contributors write with an improper voice and don't cite their sources - which again lowers the quality of the platform. Stack Overflow is different, as long as a question is on-topic and not a very close repeat I think there is no great reason to close it.
- im3w1l 6y ago> you don't want there to be an arms race of every local dentist trying to get a wikipedia article so that they seem important. I wouldn't mind at all actually. Or maybe I just miss the issue?
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoIt would clutter disambiguation pages, would contribute little of value to Wikipedia, and might lead to a wave of advertising spam.
- jrochkind1 6y agoWhat do you think the attraction is? I guess it's one of the easiest things you can do as a mod, so if you want to do a lot of mod things... to the extent SO gives you "points" for it, it might even be engineered (on purpose?)
- rangibaby 6y agoThere’s a kind of person who just likes having power over others
- anaerobicover 6y agoCorrection, there are no points given for voting to close. Points are only for positive votes on questions and answers (and also, up to a certain number, for edits that are approved by other users).
- enriquto 6y ago> but there are a huge number of mods who see it as their life mission to close as many questions as possible You can see this as a good thing, it helps you identify the most interesting questions: those that are closed!