7 ms·
The WHO is a useless organization. For political reasons, it will be necessary to engage, but hopefully US authorities will not treat it as an information sourc
by renewiltord 6y ago
The WHO is a useless organization. For political reasons, it will be necessary to engage, but hopefully US authorities will not treat it as an information source.
The US should use its own primary sources in future to evaluate disease spread. China will lie to the WHO and the WHO will protect it.
But to know the truth, we should use our modern equivalents of Key Hole. There is no truth but that which you have examined yourself.
- f430 6y ago> China will lie to the WHO and the WHO will protect it. No idea why you are being downvoted for speaking the truth.
- renewiltord 6y agoThanks. Site guidelines discourage comments like yours but I was definitely rapidly getting downvoted till you said something. Interesting stuff. I don't think anything I said about the WHO is particularly controversial considering the last year and their disinformation campaign. Anyway, bodies like the WHO can't be effective information sources because you get in trouble if a novel contagious disease started in your country. It has to lead to increased money flow to the diseased site at disease onset and decreased money flow to sites likely to risk creating novel disease. That is, market pandemic bonds structured on a regional basis will probably yield a better indicator than the WHO.
- addicted 6y agoYou mean primary sources like the program that had US scientists embedded in Chinese laboratories that Trump dismantled in 2019? Also, you clearly don’t understand what the WHO does and how critical it has been in the reduction and even eradication of disease spread across the world over decades. Further, the WHO, much like most multilateral organizations is dependent on its member states for strength. When the most powerful member state voluntarily and unilaterally chose to disengage over the past half decade, it shouldn’t be surprised that the 2nd most powerful member state is calling the shots.
- renewiltord 6y agoOkay, I'm happy to amend to "The WHO is useless for information on novel disease spread". That's what I intended anyway but clearly did not constrain the sentence correctly. Yeah, I'm sure as a multilateral platform for cooperation on things that everyone wants done they're good. But as an information source for novel epidemics, clearly we should use our spy sats.
- jlmorton 6y agoHow do we use our spy satellites for information about an epidemic? I'm really struggling to understand what you're suggesting here. I'm aware there is a whole cottage industry of conspiracy theorists that point to satellite photos of busy parking lots outside hospitals in Hubei Province as evidence of earlier spread of Covid than has been officially acknowledged. But there's no way to distinguish a busy parking lot caused by a severe influenza outbreak (which existed prior to Covid in Hubei) and a novel pathogen.
- renewiltord 6y agoUsing "spy sats" in a pars pro toto sense. The intelligence apparatus.
- throwawaysea 6y agoHas the WHO really been that critical or are we ascribing successes to them that are really the result of business and technological innovation? At least in the recent decade or two, they seem to consistently be bad at their job and mired in politics. Even before the coronavirus there were issues like their failures in managing the Ebola outbreak (https://time.com/4123858/ebola-crisis-who-response-failure/ https://time.com/4123858/ebola-crisis-who-response-failure/).
- aaomidi 6y agoWHO is like your IT team. You only see their failures.
- 6y ago
- the-dude 6y agoI watched the WHO press briefings in about the first month. If the Western world would have done what the WHO advised at the time, we all more or less would have a COVID stuation like the Chinese have for some time.
- katbyte 6y agoCould you elaborate on what that situation is?
- kergonath 6y agoMask early, serious lockdown as soon as it becomes serious, and don’t end lockdowns before numbers are way low. We masked late, put lockdowns in place late if at all, and ended them way too early, which means that some countries went through several ones. And we’re not through yet. That said, I don’t share the optimism of the parent poster. This would be a heavy burden in terms of freedom and human rights for a result that is far from certain. There have been some resurgences, the extent of which is of course unknown because the truth would be damageable to China. And there is no knowing whether the next variant would start it all over again, in which it would be back to square one.
- aksss 6y agoI’m not sure the federal government has the plenary power to enforce such things in the United States. So it was never an option. Authoritarian governments or single-state nations are better able to mandate behavior. The lockdowns, even as implemented, extracted an enormous toll on small businesses and mental health.
- kergonath 6y ago> I’m not sure the federal government has the plenary power to enforce such things in the United States. I am certain it hasn’t. But the same reasoning applies for state governments. Having public health decisions taken at the county level is sheer madness. > The lockdowns, even as implemented, extracted an enormous toll on small businesses and mental health. This is entirely true, and I hope this will make people and governments take health issues and depression more seriously. Now, we don’t have an alternative earth to experiment, but whether one strict lockdown for 6 months followed by progressive reopening is better or worse for people and the economy compared to a succession of waves and partial lockdowns with no end in sight should certainly be discussed. This is even more skewed in countries that do not have a proper safety net and where people have the choice between going to work ill or not having a job.
- methodsignature 6y agoSure, if data from US would be enough to understand and fight disease. Otherwise, you need to create some sort of world health organization to share meaningful data and investigate inside all country participant without the appearance of [or actual] invasion of sovereignty. Thus, we have the WHO. You wanna replace it, it's gonna take a decade to get to another agreement if one even is made. Then it will have its own set of issues. During a pandemic, seems better to me to work with and hold accountable the one we have... kinda like the WH is doing today.
- renewiltord 6y agoWe don't need it for this. Intelligence organizations know that biological threats like this are intelligence problems. They just didn't think them likely or that the sick guy would be our enemy. However, now we know the adversary is truly an adversary. China will suppress information on pandemics started within its borders. The game has changed. You don't listen to China about whether China is sick. You listen to Keyhole and your guys on the ground.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ZoomerCretin 6y ago>China will lie to the WHO and the WHO will protect it. Do you have any reason to believe that this is true?
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoRemember that time a high up WHO representative was asked about COVID in Taiwan and he faked the video call freezing and disconnected? Then remember when they got him back he was again asked about Taiwan and said they had already discussed China? I remember thinking that the WHO wasn’t what it seemed. Just one small example of course.
- sumedh 6y agoNot sure why you are getting downvoted for telling a fact.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoI know why. See my username. I think in some years when we have better options and more transparency we’re going to reflect on this “person with the most votes gets speech” thing.
- mamon 6y agoHow about [1]? Corrupt organizaiton's loyalties typically lie with those who sponsor it. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/china-pledges-additional-30-million-funding-for-world-health-organization/2020/04/23/24f9b680-8539-11ea-81a3-9690c9881111_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/china-pled...
- edmundsauto 6y agoThis is a particularly generic bit of evidence, based on cynicism with a bit of directional truth about incentives. Do you have anything that draws this connection more directly?
- kergonath 6y agoThere is no winning with you... Of course it cannot be too powerful, because then nationalists would scream bloody murder and refuse to have anything to do with it. The WHO is a forum to coordinate strategy and exchange information. Obviously, this requires a minimum of good faith, which seems to be difficult for some countries (yes, particularly dictatorships). But even then, it is better to have them within, collaborating on their terms, than to leave them outside, in which case it would be even harder to get any information out of them. So yes, China will lie, which will make life worse for epidemiologists and governments across the globe, but not as worse as it could be with China being entirely uncooperative. It is not the world police, and it won’t come anywhere and do anything against the local government’s wishes. Otherwise the screams world be even louder, and justifiably so.
- renewiltord 6y agoI don't think anyone wants the WHO to be powerful. They want the WHO to be honest. And they aren't. But that isn't the WHO's fault or anyone working there. It's a property of what the WHO is.
- kergonath 6y ago> They want the WHO to be honest. And they aren't They are working with what they have, which comes from governments and governmental health agencies. If they don’t have information, they say ‘we don’t know’, even though everyone knows that the most likely scenario involves emergence in China. If one wants them to be able to coerce information out of China, then by definition it would need to be more powerful.
- salawat 6y agoIf they are "working with what they have", then they should not speak from a position of authority. Authority is derived from something being something that everyone has. In the past, achieving that goal practically guaranteed authenticity to within a comfortable enough quanta for everyone to work with. With more advanced remote sensing equipment, the decreased cost to publish, reach one can attain for relatively little cost nowadays, that is no longer a luxury we can all afford to continue to entertain. We must all see with our own eyes. In the case that is frustrated or made impossible, it should not a surprise that the world acts as badly as it does. This is why the collective lie is the most powerful weapon fielded by modern civilization, and why there is such a jockeying for control of what the definition of allowable evidence is. Perception management is a weapon of mass destruction, and should be called out for what it is.
- toiletfuneral 6y agoright dude, china needs to be truthful just like the US has been /s
- ssss11 6y agoThe WHO needs to be credible and trustworthy as an impartial source of truth otherwise it is not required. Unfortunately this particular topic is heavily politically-loaded and CCP’s track record of handling the virus leads the common person to believe the WHO won’t receive the full information. In this case the WHO’s hands seem tied. How are they supposed to fix that? (Genuine question, I would like the WHO to be able to fulfill its role well and serve the global public good)