7 ms·
>He appears to agree with Murray that some class differences reduce to heredity. So? When did that became illegal? Or news?
by coldtea 6y ago
>He appears to agree with Murray that some class differences reduce to heredity.
So? When did that became illegal? Or news?
- UncleMeat 6y agoIt isn't illegal. But Murray's work is both bad science and has been used to justify all sorts of policy and social systems that harm certain groups (black people in particular). If somebody shows up at a party talking about this great book they read called "The Bell Curve" it is a reasonable bayesian prior to be leery of them.
- vinger 6y agoSometimes we fear and fight reality. If the Bell Curve has information / facts that upsets your worldview don't be so fearfull. Embrace new ideas and change your worldview. You can run but you can't hide from the truth.
- tadfisher 6y agoIt's never the facts people have contentions with, it's the conclusions. Facts can support conclusions, but it is far too easy to manipulate facts (see: lies of omission) to present misleading conclusions. So while I agree with your sentiment, I completely disagree that one should embrace challenging conclusions because they are challenging.
- UncleMeat 6y agoThis sort of thing is so frustrating. Scientists aren't afraid of Murray's work. It is just poor science. The defense that people who resist a piece of writing are simply too frightened of what is inside is a cheat. It assumes that the work is worthwhile in the first place. Murray's ideas aren't "new". Not even a little. And they aren't "truth".
- vinger 6y agoThese ideas are not completely new. Can you backup they aren't "truth" or they don't offer a peek into a reality that maybe taboo? Personal opinions are great do you have more to comtribute?
- UncleMeat 6y ago> Can you backup they aren't "truth" or they don't offer a peek into a reality that maybe taboo? Your local university can do it if you really care. A ton of material has been written about Murray's work. Taboo? Humanity has been using science to break the backs of minorities for centuries. People aren't hiding the corner quivering and afraid to touch Murray's work.
- vinger 6y agoYou called it not "truth". Have you been to your local university to research this? Did someone give you an opinion you are repeating? What informs your strong opinion?
- UncleMeat 6y ago> Have you been to your local university to research this? I attended grad school with people who studied sociology and history, who were able to synthesize the state of the fields for me. I'm married to a professor and good friends with other professors who study topics in this space. None of them have good things to say about Murray's work.
- rjsw 6y agoI thought that the research that Murray interpreted had been done by other people. Coming at this from the left, I feel it might be better to suggest alternative interpretations of those results than to just avoid any discussion on the whole area. Another thing that correlates really strongly with black people in the US is their ancestors having lived in slavery. Those ancestors were restricted in their freedom to pick a partner compared with the white population of the US at the time. This could result in genetic differences between the two groups.
- UncleMeat 6y ago> Coming at this from the left, I feel it might be better to suggest alternative interpretations of those results than to just avoid any discussion on the whole area. A lot of people have done this. The Bell Curve is full of problems, both in the sourced research being completely false (for example, straight up lies about populations being tested) as well as Murray's conclusions drawn from research. Papers and books have been published. What else do you want from the community?
- ardy42 6y ago>> He appears to agree with Murray that some class differences reduce to heredity. > So? When did that became illegal? Or news? What does illegality have to do with anything in this context? I mean holding an idea can be both legal and abhorrent/wrong at the same time. And isn't bringing up legality here kind of a Motte & Bailey fallacy? (I'm genuinely asking, I only learned about that the other day.) People condemn Murray's ideas because they're distasteful and wrong, but it's certainly far easier to defend their legality.
- vinger 6y agoAbhorrent facts are still truthful. If you feel it's distasteful and wrong that men can be attracted to other men how far should the world go to defend your worldview
- ardy42 6y ago"Wrong" can mean both factually untrue and immoral. I was using it with both senses.
- manfredo 6y ago> I mean holding an idea can be both legal and abhorrent/wrong at the same time. Then rephrase the above question: since when did that become abhorrent or wrong? We know that IQ is hereditary. This is a simple statistical fact: there is positive correlation between the IQ of children and their parents. And if cognitive ability translates into higher incomes, this would mean income is hereditary I think what people find abhorrent are the perceived implication rather than the message itself. I'm going to hazard the guess that you're perceiving the implication that saying class differences are hereditary is implying that inequality isn't a problem, or some social groups won't ever have high incomes, or something else. In reality saying these differences are hereditary is saying nothing about that. Saying IQ is hereditary isn't saying some people will never be smart. Obesity is hereditary, too. That doesn't mean the children of obese parents can never be a healthy weight. Nobody's body cheats thermodynamics. Likewise people's IQ can be improved by exercising mental tasks.
- 6y ago