4 ms·
NYT is the same rag that published as "news" and helped expel a girl from college, because when she was 15, after passing her driving exam, she was caught on vi
by coldtea 6y ago
NYT is the same rag that published as "news" and helped expel a girl from college, because when she was 15, after passing her driving exam, she was caught on video bragging "I can drive, n..." (addressed to no-one, meant as a boast).
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/26/us/mimi-groves-jimmy-galligan-racial-slurs.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/26/us/mimi-groves-jimmy-gall...
To me that's 1000 times more offensive and hideous than using the n-word by yourself, and the scum of the earth that wrote and posted that article (and those that expelled the girl), should be ousted from society.
- high_derivative 6y agoAgreed and I think what consumers should do is vote with their wallets and attention: - Cancel NYT subscriptions - Subscribe to independent journalists and writers on Substack or via other means - Flag NYT articles
- leesalminen 6y agoI subscribed to Glenn Greenwald the day he left The Intercept. I don’t really read his writings nor do I necessarily agree with what he say to say all the time. But, I really like the idea of supporting individual journalists with $. Hopefully others can see Glenn’s success in this model and try it out themselves.
- mattdotc 6y agoYou're supporting someone whose writings you don't read after he left in a big hissy fit because his editors tried to edit him. Got it. A lot of folks might soon be discovering why editors are actually important. There's value in having another party check your work, challenge your assumptions, and question your claims. This process is not blanket censorship, but Glenn would have you think so.
- leesalminen 6y agoI think the public should be challenging assumptions and questioning claims. Advocating for an “editor” aka “gatekeeper” is a form of elitism in that it assumes an editor will be “better” at challenging assumptions than the public at large. While you may find many instances where that is true, it’s not good for public discourse to be boxed into a frame of discourse decided by the ivory tower types. My current financial support for Glenn has nothing to do with him. It has to do with the funding model of journalism. He’s just the first one I came across to try it, so I’m supportive.
- monocasa 6y agoHe had a contractual agreement that editors couldn't edit for content at The Intercept, a news outfit he literally founded in order to not have content based editorial oversight. Describing that as a "hissy fit" is disingenuous.
- adamjb 6y agoShe had already withdrawn (not expelled) long before that fairly sympathetic article was posted. I am very confused why you think it proves anything.
- coldtea 6y agoYou're confused? I'm triply confused. Confused why you think the article was "news" worth printing, or sympathetic. Confused with the use of the term "withdrawn" (like the euphemism of someone"quiting for "personal reasons" when they are in fact pressured to resign). I'm also confused about what you think my comment was supposed to "prove" or not. It was meant as a case in point of the kind of bad, pearl-clutching-style sensenationalist stories increasingly peddled by the NYT.
- adamjb 6y agoYou said that the NYT "helped expel a girl from college". The article did no such thing, euphemism aside, for the simple reason that time travel is impossible. I am begging you to read the article or at least the date of publication because it is clear you haven't. >Confused why you think the article was "news" worth printing The article is about a girl having her life upended by an internet mob with interviews with the principal players. (Again, to be abundantly clear, this article is post hoc.) Is that not newsworthy? You certainly think the event is worth bringing up months later which points to it being at least a little noteworthy. > or sympathetic They quote the girl, painting her as having just made an innocent mistake. "At the time, I didn’t understand the severity of the word, or the history and context behind it because I was so young". “It honestly disgusts me that those words would come out of my mouth”. Hell the main thrust of the article is a racial revenge narrative where she's the arbitrary victim of a mixed-race kid living in a racist town trying to settle the score with whatever he can.
- brown9-2 6y agoThe very article you linked to contradicts your telling of the events here. She voluntarily withdrew from her high school and the college rescinded her acceptance months before the article was published.
- 6y ago
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoMedia seems to be increasingly part of the enforcement arm of the monoculture. For those that are in the “club” there’s cover, for those that find themselves on the other side there’s smear.
- flavius29663 6y agoI can't get over that either. The girl was not some redneck racist, she was an active BLM protester, but they still framed her hometown as "Leesburg, Va., a town named for an ancestor of the Confederate general Robert E. Lee and whose school system had fought an order to desegregate for more than a decade after the Supreme Court’s landmark ruling." like it has anything to do with the girl.
- mst 6y agoThe damage to her was done by the asshole classmate, though. The NYT just wrote it up after the fact. Said write up was awful and the extent to which it made the asshole seem like a hero made me want to stab things, but it's worth blaming the NYT for all the things they did get wrong here and not the one thing they didn't :)
- da_big_ghey 6y agoThere are some people who just need to get roughed up a few times before they get a clue. A couple guys should just knock some sense into that guy for ruining this girl's life. This seems to no longer be the norm, though, so I guess people need some better way to exact retribution.
- manfredo 6y agoNo, violence is never the answer here.
- the_only_law 6y agoIronic that the people outraged by a mob destroying someone wish for their own mob justice. As soon as the balance of power changes it will be unsafe for a whole different demographic.
- da_big_ghey 6y agoDon't take my rash words as a representation of others; they are not. The above was a resentful comment I made the mistake of posting, and I wouldn't endorse violence either irl.
- brown9-2 6y agoThe timeline you present here is all wrong. The article itself says that her college acceptance was rescinded, meaning it came before this article. The article was published in December 2020 and these events happened in June 2020: > The consequences were swift. Over the next two days, Ms. Groves was removed from the university’s cheer team. She then withdrew from the school under pressure from admissions officials, who told her they had received hundreds of emails and phone calls from outraged alumni, students and the public. The mere act of reporting - documenting an event that happened for its readers - does not make the author “scum of the earth”. You find it offensive and hideous that the journalist did things that they did not in fact do, while yourself presenting a false accounting of the facts.
- coldtea 6y ago>The article was published in December 2020 and these events happened in June 2020: I see. I haven't read the article itself (it was/is behind a paywall), but a report on it, that read like the article publicized this story ahead of the events. Still, from the snippets I read posted here, what's with the "slave auctions" and the BS innuendo about her city?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- brown9-2 6y agoPerhaps consider how trustworthy that “report” was that it got such simple facts wrong.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]