2 ms·
These points are weak - there are other weaknesses of BitCoin, but these aren't really them. Almost every issue he raises attacks BitCoin as a medium of exchang
by peteretep 15y ago
These points are weak - there are other weaknesses of BitCoin, but these aren't really them. Almost every issue he raises attacks BitCoin as a medium of exchange (which it doesn't need to be) rather than as a medium for storing value. Taking them one at a time:
> Severe Problem Number 1: Seeding Initial Wealth
He doesn't really explain why this 'problem' is a bad thing. There is a limited supply, and there needs to be a distribution system. While this one may not be perfect, it doesn't cause any systemic weakness in the system. Early adopters will do well, yes.
But the degree to which people mine or buy bitcoins now is the degree to which they think they'll be valuable in the future - bitcoins already have a price. People who have mined them will sell them to you. Nothing stops you purchasing bitcoins now if you believe the price will go up. This is how markets work. Hearing someone complain about it is like hearing someone complain that people who buy assets cheaply on the stockmarket will make a significant return.
> Severe Problem Number 2: Built in Deflation
A bad thing if you're trying to replace a country's currency system with it, and excellent thing if you see them as a store of value. This is the same as people complaining that any other asset deflates over time.
> Severe Problem Number 3: Lack of Convertibility
This is the closest point he has to being right. Lack of convertibility is a current problem, but economics should solve that. All you need in order to convert your bitcoins is a person who is willing to trade. To have an efficient market, you need an exchange. Here's the crux: bitcoins have a value as long as someone is willing to buy them off you.
His key point here seems to be that 'no one is completely invested in the long-term success of the system' - yes. This is also true of your MSFT shares. No-one is guaranteeing that they will be worth anything in the long run.
> Severe Problem Number 4: When Something Goes Wrong, It Will Die
Perhaps. I went for dinner with some Fx quants last night. One of them brought up this point, and then they all laughed and said "And that's when you invest heavily in it". All assets change their prices based on bad news - most recover again and people who doubled-down at that point make money.
- cube13 15y agoRe: Deflation >A bad thing if you're trying to replace a country's currency system with it, and excellent thing if you see them as a store of value. This is the same as people complaining that any other asset deflates over time. Currencies aren't investments. They have little to no inherent worth. They're the medium used to make investments, and the medium that investments pay out to the investors. If you're approaching Bitcoins as an investment asset, you're missing the entire point of creating a new currency. Assets, on the other hand, have inherent worth. Gold is used for jewelery and in electronics. Fine art's worth is it's existence itself. BTC does not have any worth past the confidence in the other currencies used to exchange for them. The fundamental problem with deflationary currencies is that there is no risk in keeping it around, which removes a lot of the incentives for investing. People are encouraged to not use BTC because they will appreciate more doing nothing than actively going out and investing it. Instead, they'll hoard it until the point where it becomes too expensive for people to buy. At that point, there will be a run on the exchanges, which will kill the entire worth of the economy around it.