6 ms·
Its such a statement about the free rider problem that python can have only 2 people working fulltime on it. Python is one of the most popular languages in the
by josephg 6y ago
Its such a statement about the free rider problem that python can have only 2 people working fulltime on it. Python is one of the most popular languages in the world - there's got to be trillions of dollars worth of companies depending on it. Small improvements to the language would result in millions of dollars of productivity gains in aggregate globally.
And yet ... collectively we can only find enough money to pay two full time salaries?! Seriously?
- edwardwatson 6y agoPython is as popular as it is because it's free, not because it's good. If companies had to contribute, many would pick something else.
- tasubotadas 6y agoSo... why don't you pay?
- bzb6 6y agoSomeone else should!
- feanaro 6y agoWhy do you assume he isn't paying? The payment should obviously be proportional, though. You can't expect a single individual to finance what a gigantic multibillion corporation could.
- tasubotadas 6y agoJust because some random individual came up with some arbitratry agenda of whom should finance what, doesn't mean that it makes sense. There are so many better (and worse) things to finance than Python Foundation.
- feanaro 6y agoIt's not very arbitrary. The reasoning (in one of the upstream posts) is that Python is one of the world's most used programming languages. It definitely makes sense for large multi-billion corporations which are the users of this language to help finance it. Your point would make more sense if the claim was that a significant portion of the corporation's profits should go towards financing Python. Then I would agree that "there are so many better things to finance than Python". But if we're discussing a salary or two in the context of corporations that employ hundreds of thousands of people, then your argument makes much less sense in the current context. There are very few things that would have better marginal utility then paying for the (effectively) third full-time Python developer.
- josephg 6y agoI say this as someone who's spent decades of my life donating time to opensource projects. - But the model where big companies have their technology stacks underpinned by charity is ridiculous. Obviously ridiculous, if python only has 2 full-time-equivalent staff. This problem isn't solved by little old me pulling out my check book. My bank and my insurance company don't need charity from me in order to fund the technology they've built their businesses on. They need to learn to pony up and start funding the "free" software they use. Paying myself would only help kick the can down the road - and encourage and enable this sort of corporate mooching to keep happening. In 60 years most of the volunteer maintainers of the software we depend on every day will be dead. Some time between now and then we need solution to this problem of opensource sustainability. Delaying buys us nothing.
- sokoloff 6y agoIf python continues to be this popular, there will be more maintainers who join the project. Surely you’ve seen volunteers join existing projects out of their own interest and need now. The decades that you contributed (thank you, BTW): were those all on projects you started, or did you also join some existing efforts? I don’t see any reason to think that will stop in 10, 20, or 60 years.
- josephg 6y ago> If python continues to be this popular, there will be more maintainers who join the project. Will there? I feel like most of the opensource attention flows gradually up stack / toward trendy things on github and away from infrastructure older than github. When heartbleed happened a few years ago it was revealed that OpenSSL was maintained by basically one guy. The same is true of the linux timezone database. Apparently python is mostly 2 people. I'd put money on this being is a theme for lots of tools we take for granted. How many people work on bash? Or busybox, grub, libpthread or libicu? I bet the number is tiny.
- sokoloff 6y agoCpython had 5 pull requests opened yesterday. 6 the day before that (from 10 total distinct contributors). That doesn’t seem like a project starving for contributors. If everyone with commit access up and quit, there’d be turmoil for several weeks and something reasonable would emerge. People want to work on popular, useful things. Python is both of those.
- Barrin92 6y agobecause software that is provided for free cannot capture the positive externalities it creates and thus is under-supplied, it's just very straight-forward economics. Yet it's become such a widespread sentiment to expect software for free that charging for something like Python would probably be seen as obscene and kill the language through loss of reputation alone.
- _tom_ 6y agoAnd large improvements to the language could result in millions of dollars of productivity losses! :-) I'm not a big fan of "Now this language has gotten popular, let's add all the features to it that made our other language so unpopular."
- huffmsa 6y agoIt taking 10 years to transition from 2 to 3 wasn't necessarily a bad thing. Definitely concerns that more hands could make another Angular, which had 2 incompatible branches, with one going from v2 to v11 in 5 years.
- josephg 6y ago> It taking 10 years to transition from 2 to 3 wasn't necessarily a bad thing. The python3 interpreter could have been largely (or completely) source-compatible with python2 code. They could have done it rust2018 style - where source code files can opt in to a newer parser, and in return get access to the new features. Then the whole python3 drama would have been avoided. MacOS still ships with a python 2.7 interpreter because of all that nonsense. But if they only had 2 full-time people working on it, no wonder they didn't have the man power to do the transition any other way. Disappointing.
- my123 6y agoWhich puts a: > WARNING: Python 2.7 is not recommended. > This version is included in macOS for compatibility with legacy software. > Future versions of macOS will not include Python 2.7. > Instead, it is recommended that you transition to using 'python3' from within Terminal. banner on launch nowadays...
- josephg 6y agoRight; none of this should be necessary. I don’t need an old version of my C compiler in order to compile old C files. Rust made breaking changes to their language and yet a modern rust compiler will happily compile the older 2015 rust syntax. Python could have gone down the same road; but I suppose all of python’s corporate users chose to fight python compatibility changes locally rather than donate time / money fixing python itself.
- andi999 6y agoI am seriously wondering: is it actually possible for stock listed companies to donate? I mean aren't they legally obliged not to spend more than necessary (towards their stockholders obliged). Also what does the IRS say on that?
- foota 6y agoNo. This is a misinterpretation of the responsibility. Companies have great latitude in what they do, as long as they're forthright.
- OJFord 6y agoThey have a duty to try to operate efficiently, but that doesn't make corporate social responsibility, a bad hire, or wasting something nobody liked in the canteen illegal.
- andi999 6y agoWell, bad hire, bad food can always be justified (avoiding hindsight fallacy). But giving away money for nothing received (meaning of donation) is something different (at least to me)
- keeganpoppen 6y agocompanies donate money to stuff all the time what are you on about?
- andi999 6y agoSo I read up a little. To tax deduct the nonprofit must have registered as 501(c)(3). Is this the case here?
- sokoloff 6y agoI can pay you to put my company name on your business website or a physical banner at a trade show and account for this as a business expense (deduct it) without you being a non-profit. I have broad latitude to make business expenditures in a manner that I believe is profit-seeking or optimizing for my business. People do this with Google and Facebook all the time. We call them ads. Not every ad campaign has a positive RoI.
- kortilla 6y ago> And yet ... collectively we can only find enough money to pay two full time salaries?! Seriously? But what’s the problem here? Is python struggling as a language? If there were clear calls for help companies could find it a lot easier to justify donating money or dev time.
- passtheglass 6y agoTo me that is more like evidence of a well-engineered codebase.
- II2II 6y agoIs that actually a bad thing? Much of the popularity of Python is based upon third party libraries that have been contributed by both individuals and organizations. These are still contributions, and there are many cases where the contributors are paid. Should Python receive more funding and pay more people to work on the language? Probably, yet it is doubtful that having a large team working on the core language will improve the health of the language.
- coldtea 6y ago>Its such a statement about the free rider problem that python can have only 2 people working fulltime on it It's also a big statement about how non realistic were the ideas that FOSS will thrive on volunteers working together. Back in the day where the "Cathredral and the Bazaar" was published, VALinux got its IPO, and FOSS was the latest hype, people really believed that this will work without corporate sponsorship, just by volunteers doing the work. Then again, they also believed in many eyes available through the magic of FOSS making bugs shallow (Torvalds), and you get 20+ years of some obvious bug in something as critical as OpenSSL.