3 ms·
> color actually matters and demonstrates a serious commitment to avoiding groupthink This statement is based on the racist assumption that skin color makes yo
by kortilla 6y ago
> color actually matters and demonstrates a serious commitment to avoiding groupthink
This statement is based on the racist assumption that skin color makes you think differently. A middle class Asian person who went to college at Stanford is going to think identically to a white middle class person who went to college. A white person who grew up dirt poor and self taught online is going to be vastly different from either.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> This statement is based on the racist assumption that skin color makes you think differently. Skin color doesn't make you think differently, but it (and, even moreso, racial identity, which is different than skin color) does correlate with things beyond socioeconomic class and personal level of education that do. > A middle class Asian person who went to college at Stanford is going to think identically to a white middle class person who went to college. It's possible, because the range of variation overlaps considerably, but, overall, no, major subcultural and lived-experience differences in the US don't reduce to economic class and whether (or even where) you went to college.
- geofft 6y agoIt sounds like you don't want to work at a company in the latter group, then!
- bradlys 6y ago> A middle class Asian person who went to college at Stanford is going to think identically to a white middle class person who went to college. I thought this was true for a while but I've worked with enough asians (who are also born in USA - some even with their parents being American too) to realize this just isn't true. The white/asian experience has a very different parental/family background. A lot of kids learning some other language from an early age even if their parents weren't born in that country the language is known for. Most white kids don't go through a lot of that stuff. I used to think "Ah, hello, my fellow American!" And then I realized many asians didn't align with the American identity - at least in SV. Many felt like they were very closely tied (or closer) to their parents or grandparents homeland. Super weird - imo...
- geofft 6y agoLet me also add one thing I didn't phrase clearly last night - if it is true (and I, like you, don't believe it's true) that an Asian Stanford grad has the same perspectives and experiences as a white Stanford grad, then that gives all the more validity to making sure you're not unnecessarily discriminating against one or the other group. Your ratio of Asian to white hires should be roughly on par with the fraction of, if nothing else, Asian and white Stanford grads. If it is wildly different, then it's an indicator that something is wrong. Perhaps you are not losing out on perspectives and experiences, per se, but perhaps the biased person running your initial phone screens is causing you to lose out on good candidates who are from a race they don't like, i.e., you're limiting the number of candidates of this perspective and experience that you're willing to interview. That would be a problem worth being aware of! Completely ignoring race means you don't have the data. It doesn't prevent the problem from happening. (See also, "Why is the net wired randomly?", asked Minsky. "I do not want it to have any preconceptions of how to play", Sussman said.*)
- Vinnl 6y ago> This statement is based on the racist assumption that skin color makes you think differently. I think it rather is based on the assumption that you are likely to have been treated differently in your life as a result, and thus have different lived experiences that can influence your work.