4 ms·
> Negative. Territory is things, not people. It is also a human instinct to treat people as things. Thus, we appear to be creating a society that can override
by Apocryphon 6y ago
> Negative. Territory is things, not people.
It is also a human instinct to treat people as things. Thus, we appear to be creating a society that can override baser instincts. Anti-propertarians would thus be claiming to transcend those instincts in the name of greater justice, in the same nature as you are claiming to transcend this instincts to abolish taxation.
> You’ve neglected to consider laws that prohibit without specifying consequences for violation.
Those laws are clearly in the minority.
> Now you’re understanding why a “social contract” can’t be used to justify violating someone’s rights.
Correct, and it means that your problem is with the whole of the social contract, and taxation is but a fraction of what it entails.
> You’re arguing against it with me right here.
I argue because I choose to, not because it actually reveals anything about my actual opinions or convictions.
> roads predate the government that expropriated them from the commons.
Much like private property.
> I shouldn’t need permission from bureaucrats to use the roads.
Then you are stealing from the actual parties who built those roads and maintain them.
> You’re losing the plot.
Tu quoque.
> Bureaucrats taxing and spending necessarily means that I’m competing, with bureaucrats, for goods, while the bureaucrats are using my own money to compete with me.
Yes, yes, the issue of private competition with public services does exist. All of which can be explored without denying the fundamental principle of taxation, as aforementioned ad nauseam.
> So you agree that I do not have the right of exit.
Yes, but you believe in it for the wrong reasons.
> [citation needed]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_taxless_countries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_taxless_countries
> No, it is not.
Sure it is. Do you claim to be able to protect it if a foreign power assaults it? Can you take on an entire criminal cartel?
> Rent is not a unilateral transaction, neither is it extortion.
Rent is unilaterally determined by the rentier, who establishes a coercive rent regime due to monopoly ownership over the property in question. Thus, it is extortion because the other party is inherently at a disadvantage.
> You think the government is an alternative to might makes right? Interesting.
Even most minarchists who want only a night-watchman state will agree upon the necessity of court systems and law enforcement to enforce contracts. You are free to advance an alternative, if you'd like.
> Unowned property becomes owned through homesteading, owned property changes hands through voluntary transfer.
Homesteading is established through force, and voluntary transfer exist along relations that are backed by the violent force that is society.
> Force is a primary means of retaining property when someone attempts to take it from the owner.
Because in a Hobbesian state of nature all property is up for grabs, property is inherently in need of protection, and thus force is always on the table.
> I’ve made a solid case that does not rely on Proudhon
It certainly doesn't, but your case lives in the same moral universe as Proudhon's does, and has about as much relation to reality as his.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoProperty/territoriality is not an instinct to treat people as things. Your desire to override my baser instincts is misplaced. Concentrate on overriding your own base instincts, then you will be less inclined to expropriate from people and redistribute the wealth of others according to your subjective preferences. I’m glad you’ve conceded that coercion is not a necessary component of laws. It is true that private property also predates the government. I’m glad you’ve conceded your earlier point about the right of exit. You’ve yet to establish the necessity of taxation. Rent is not unilaterally determined by the rentier. Its negotiated between the rentier and the renter. How do you describe a government in a way that the government isn’t an instance of “might makes right”? Homesteading is not established by force. Voluntary exchange cuts across relations that are violently enforced by society. Hobbes was mistaken about a state of nature. Your fixation on Proudhon is detracting from your efforts to reply to my arguments. Finally, property doesn’t require the state because property can exist in the absence of a state. The fact that states can expropriate people is the basis for this entire argument. Essentially you’re saying if I didn’t have a state expropriating me, I’d have a state expropriating me. Well, who is expropriating the state? Why not?
- Apocryphon 6y ago> Concentrate on overriding your own base instincts, then you will be less inclined to expropriate from people and redistribute the wealth of others according to your subjective preferences. Who says those are my actual instincts? For all you know, I completely agree with your positions on taxation and am merely testing how well you advance our mutual beliefs. For all intents and purposes, neither of us exist beyond this conversation. One must transcend the baser instinct of assuming one's opponent's personality in order to debate with pure logic. > I’m glad you’ve conceded that coercion is not a necessary component of laws. For all intents and purposes, they constitute a vast majority of laws. > It is true that private property also predates the government. Source? > I’m glad you’ve conceded your earlier point about the right of exit. How did I concede? > You’ve yet to establish the necessity of taxation. You've yet to advance an alternative mode of government that exists without it. > Rent is not unilaterally determined by the rentier. Its negotiated between the rentier and the renter. In the same way that a monopolistic market still creates contracts despite power and information asymmetry, sure. > How do you describe a government in a way that the government isn’t an instance of “might makes right”? Social contract and free association, which is how governments are founded. > Homesteading is not established by force. Tell it to the Lakota. > Voluntary exchange cuts across relations that are violently enforced by society. Voluntary exchange is still founded on the principles of violent enforcement in the case when exchangers break contracts. > Hobbes was mistaken about a state of nature. And who wasn't? > Your fixation on Proudhon is detracting from your efforts to reply to my arguments. It's because your arguments are by similar to his. > Essentially you’re saying if I didn’t have a state expropriating me, I’d have a state expropriating me. And that's the crux of it. Anytime there is more than a single person, you have a state. It's states all the way down. > Well, who is expropriating the state? Why not? There's always a bigger state. And usually, the state itself.