4 ms·
US P2P lawsuits show signs of 'pirate honeypots'
- wccrawford 15y agoIf these honeypotters really did relabel the files, wouldn't that make them guilty of trademark infringement?
- pyre 15y agoYou would have to prove that there were 'honeypotters' out there and not just some random person that decided to relabel the files (which the lawyers then found and sued over).
- larrik 15y agoSeems at best this is entrapment (assuming there is indeed a civil equivalent), and at worst this is outright fraud and extortion. I honestly can't see why they would actually file a suit on these. Sending the initial letters makes sense, but actually sending it to court is insane.
- tptacek 15y agoThis wouldn't be entrapment even if law enforcement personnel conducted the string.
- mikecane 15y agoNYPD leaves a wallet on the ground. Someone picks it up with the intent to find the owner and return it, but the NYPD swoops in as soon as it's in hand and charges the person with theft. This has actually taken place in NYC. Law enforcement does do entrapment.
- tptacek 15y agoThis is incoherent on two different levels. First, I didn't argue that law enforcement didn't entrap people. They clearly do. I argued that passively advertising infringing content on eDonkey isn't entrapment. Second, no matter what these apocryphal NYC cops did, picking up a wallet on the street isn't a crime. The argument over "entrapment" never enters into the picture. You would need a very poor criminal defense lawyer indeed to deploy the affirmative defense of entrapment over such a trivially refuted charge. You will not be convicted of theft simply for picking up a wallet.
- mikecane 15y agoApocryphal? You couldn't be bothered to Google? Just one item: http://gothamist.com/2006/07/21/lucky_bag_opera.php http://gothamist.com/2006/07/21/lucky_bag_opera.php >>>I argued that passively advertising infringing content on eDonkey isn't entrapment. Oh sure it is! If the file had been properly labeled, the person would not have engaged in the illegal act. Just looking for illegal files is not yet a crime. Most everyone who's used Google or any other search engine would be in jail. People browsing YouTube for clips would be in jail.
- tptacek 15y agoThis isn't responsive to either of my comments, and I'm not sure you read the original story either, since the defendant in this case did more than simply search for an infringing file; moreover, I'm not sure you've researched how entrapment works, since you'll find police interventions far more intrusive than "listing a file on eDonkey" have survived entrapment claims.
- mikecane 15y agoIf you can't see how it's responsive, we need go no further with this.
- anigbrowl 15y agoApocryphal? You couldn't be bothered to Google? It's good manners for the person who makes a claim to support it. Incidentally, the charges were dropped in that NY case, suggesting a lack of legal understanding among the subway cops: http://www.thevillager.com/villager_178/luckybagstingcharges.html http://www.thevillager.com/villager_178/luckybagstingcharges... As for your argument, that makes no sense. 'Just looking' implies doing a search but not downloading any of the files. Taking the woman's story at face value, how could she have opened the file and discovered it to be porn if she had not downloaded it first? If the file had been properly labeled, the person would not have engaged in the illegal act. On the other hand, if the label had been accurate then the downloader would have just been infringing the copyright of a Ryuichi Sakamoto album rather than a porn movie. The bait-and-switch tactic alleged here looks extremely questionable (it appears to violate something called the 'clean hands' rule, though that may not matter if the plaintiff is only seeking statutory damages). But you've got to admit that 'I was trying to infringe a different work' is a pretty pathetic excuse, not much better than saying you took a wallet which you believed to be full of cash but threw it away in disappointment when it turned out not to contain any. You seem to be arguing from the belief that anything downloadable should be presumed to be in the public domain by default. Let's say the mislabeled file had in fact been a Ryuichi Sakamoto album, which is what the woman says she was looking for, and which is in fact copyrighted. At what point do you think her exploration would have crossed the line into infringement, if ever?
- ChuckMcM 15y ago"A new scheme we uncover today allows anyone to setup a honeypot and make hundreds of thousands of dollars from naive file-sharers." If this was the result then it would be a Good Thing. Whether you agree with the laws or not, file sharing stuff you don't have a right to have a copy of is, in fact, illegal. And if these troll type lawyers create enough noise in the space and scare off (or educate) all of the naive file sharers then it will make the interwebs a better place. You drive faster on than the speed limit on the freeway you know what's at risk and if you get a ticket you know why you got it. I'm very much in favor of making sure that people know when they are on the wrong side of the current law and where the line is. Then I can talk to them about whether or not they will join me in bringing sanity to where the line is :-)
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- yason 15y ago"Whether you agree with the laws or not, file sharing stuff you don't have a right to have a copy of is, in fact, illegal." But, in fact, you can and often do have that right. Under the practice of fair use making personal copies is legal in most parts of the world, including countries where bits are heavily considered an intellectual(ly challenged) property. I can legally make a copy of an album from my friend and I can legally own that copy. The MAFIAA would like you to think that any kind of file sharing is illegal but non-commercial peer-to-peer file sharing is a hugely debatable issue. If it's okay to use the sneakernet to pop at your friend's to make a copy but not okay over the internet, what's the difference besides a technicality? The MAFIAA do have some sort of track record in winning a number of copyright lawsuits but it seems to me that mostly it's because they have shitloads of money to fight with and, conversely, individual citizens don't.
- wmf 15y agoAFAIK a "personal" copy is usually interpreted to mean a copy used by the same person.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- chc 15y agoIf this did go to court, what could they get out of it? It seems like it would be incredibly difficult to show even a vague possibility of intent or damage, so the lawsuits would be an unsustainable money drain.
- ChuckFrank 15y agoIt's obvious that there is much more going on here than simply trying to build an innocuous honey pot. The key part of this scam is to get people to settle out of court for the fine because of the social embarrassment that might come from publicly disclosing that someone has downloaded !!Gasp!! GAY PORN !!Shudder!!, even if they meant to download this instead http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=btyhpyJTyXg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=btyhpyJTyXg . Additionally, while the title of the file was not listed, I doubt it was "Happy Days in the Barracks" instead it was probably something like "Dastardly Dongs", all with the intentions of raising the level of neighborly cringe factor. So, while this story may be masquerading as a poorly set honeypot, it is also the story of exploiting the latent homophobia that still exists throughout America. Here's my suggestion, instead honeypot Martha Stewart's "Home for the Holiday" under "Porn Bloopers" and see how people respond to the extortionist threat of court time. I doubt it will work out nearly as well.