5 ms·
Inflation is a red herring metric for assessing a UBI. Pretty much all the major schools of economic thought agree that under the current financial market regul
by roenxi 6y ago
Inflation is a red herring metric for assessing a UBI. Pretty much all the major schools of economic thought agree that under the current financial market regulation inflation is an overall policy position by government separate from any one specific policy. If UBI pushes inflation up, changes elsewhere can push it down. And UBI is a policy to be implemented in context, the big idea is to gain efficiencies by cutting back on now-redundant welfare nets.
So the actual negative effect of a UBI, in theory, would be declines in real goods and services as resources are directed from economically productive to economically unproductive people. Devilishly difficult to measure.
- anm89 6y agoSay whatever you want but don't play the trick of just asserting there is consensus behind your opinion. There is extremely little consensus regarding inflation right now and because we are in uncharted territory monetarily and in terms of debt levels both public and private, and the consequences(and data) of that can take years to show up(frequently slowly and then all at once) almost everything is speculation, not data driven. So no, there is not broad consensus that we can just pull some levers and send inflation wherever we want, not even close.
- MrFantastic 6y agoUBI would lead to dramatic inflation in rents in desirable areas. There is only a finite amount of premium real estate. UBI would just jack up rents by the amount of payment in San Jose or Boulder because the people that want to live there mostly have jobs so their extra UBI would just go to making their commute better. UBI might help people move from West Virginia to Indianapolis but it won't help people in Bakersfield move to San Jose.
- kart23 6y agoTaxes would take away the UBI for people that can afford desirable areas. Rents probably wouldn't go up in the manner you describe.
- wernercd 6y ago> probably Government funded things go up in price. Prime example: eductation and child care. Government funded problems that lead to government funded solutions.
- username90 6y agoThe point of UBI is that it isn't government funding, the government have no control how it is spent, people get to decide themselves how to spend it. People wont choose to spend it all on housing just like they currently don't choose to spend all of their disposable income on housing.
- wernercd 6y agoisn't government funding? it's literally redistrubtion of wealth by the government. I never said they had control of what's spent... just that government help leads to higher prices. And it's easily provable that where government puts money, prices go up. Supply and demand - more money available? prices go up.
- ctdonath 6y agoUBI is literally government funding. The point of it is to provide all with means to buy staple goods/services, and as with all government funded goods/services the price will go up.
- blackbrokkoli 6y agoYeah, if you do it uncontrolled and with the prime motivation of a few people getting rich in the process. My university in Europe literally costs me a hundred bucks a year, and child care is a similar story (although my country has some problems with providing enough capacity).
- wernercd 6y agoand you also pay a MASSIVE amount more in taxes and your education is more controlled with shortfalls and limitations. https://www.heritage.org/education/commentary/free-college-would-be-disaster-just-ask-europe https://www.heritage.org/education/commentary/free-college-w... https://www.aei.org/articles/what-european-countries-sacrifice-for-free-college/ https://www.aei.org/articles/what-european-countries-sacrifi... "capacity" amazing how forced markets can't create capacity? its also why healthcare is rationed in places like Europe and Canada. Free? Sure if you don't mind waiting months or years...
- rayhendricks 6y agoThere is only a near-infinite amount housing in the desirable west coast cities that could be built. Make enough high rise towers like Chicago or NY and the price will go down. But people’s (voters) tax sheltered investments (homes) would also go down in value.
- jariel 6y agoThe notion that we can just arbitrarily control inflation in the context of UBI-like spending is not responsible, it's simply not true.
- throwawaysea 6y agoCan you share any relevant evidence regarding inflation being a policy position?