4 ms·
Using criminal law to deal with it seems like a fairly over-the-top, dramatic step to take. It's not necessarily unreasonable for a company to want each person
by _delirium 15y ago
Using criminal law to deal with it seems like a fairly over-the-top, dramatic step to take. It's not necessarily unreasonable for a company to want each person to have a separate subscription, and they can even mandate it in their terms of service, and take action to terminate the accounts of people violating it. But criminal prosecutions for sharing accounts?
- markwweaver 15y agoThe article does say that it is mostly to combat people harvesting and selling large number of accounts/passwords which seems reasonable to me. It is scary that they could go after people sharing with a friend with up to a year in jail though.
- generalk 15y ago> The article does say that it is mostly to combat people > harvesting and selling large number of accounts/passwords > which seems reasonable to me. It seems reasonable that there be a law against that? Reasonable: Netflix TOS allows them to terminate your account if you're found in violation. Unreasonable: TN law allows criminal charges to be brought against you, potentially incurring fines and jail time and almost definitely incurring legal fees.
- graywh 15y agoReasonable?: Netflix will terminate the stolen account you're "borrowing" and you never get penalized. chopsueyar makes a good point: how will they even prosecute the real criminals?
- jrockway 15y agoWe really need help from the Republicans here. They passed laws so that any time someone wants to do something useful with taxpayer money (build infrastructure, provide government services), the first step becomes a 10-year-long "alternatives analysis" stage. We need the same thing for new laws. As an example, before this law can take effect, we need to decide exactly how much it will cost to investigate, prosecute, and imprison violators. And, we need to decide where that money is going to become from? Should we legalize child rape to free up those investigators to go after Netflix ToS violations? If yes, then make it a law. If no, then let Netflix worry about its own profits.
- chopsueyar 15y agoUnfortunately, there is nothing preventing the law from being applied in your 'scary' scenario. Additionally, if I share my password with my wife, and her sister 'borrows' it from my wife, and she gives it to three friends, and they each give it to three friends, who is responsible under this law? How do you prove it? Also, it is just really poor business to solve a problem using legislation which could easily be solved using software. This law may even be in conflict with the licensing agreements between Netflix and the studios. If Netflix and a studio had worked out an arrangement where up to 4 simultaneous users can stream from a single account, who is the Tennessee legislature to declare otherwise. This could be an interstate commerce issue, too.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- cabalamat 15y ago> Using criminal law to deal with it seems like a fairly over-the-top, dramatic step to take. Indeed. A company is perfectly entitled to want each member of a family to buy their services, what they are not (morally) entitled to is to use coercion (in the form of laws backed by threats of violence) to get people to do so. A company is morally entitled only to that revenue that people would willingly give it in the absence of force or fraud.