6 ms·
Just what is the conclusion of this market insanity? Some of these stocks clearly have no value. I had a friend of a friend who at a whim bought a million or so
by endisneigh 6y ago
Just what is the conclusion of this market insanity? Some of these stocks clearly have no value. I had a friend of a friend who at a whim bought a million or so of some penny stock that went up 10X in a matter of days and cashed out.
Is this the future of retail trading? An expensive game of chicken? I think many people, including myself to extent, believe there is always some NX stock around the corner. The FOMO is intensifying I guess. When you have stock like $SNDL almost double in literally a day it seems rational to spend your time trying to find the next one than to do the tried and true method.
- Swizec 6y ago> Is this the future of retail trading? An expensive game of chicken? Isn’t this how stock markets work? Actual company performance is just a relatively minor signal for the chicken.
- endisneigh 6y agoSure, but you would think reality would have more of an impact than simply speculation. To an extent the stock market is a game of chicken since prices are ultimately derived from expectations, but what happens when the expectations are no longer attached to reality? Buying a weed stock for example can be speculating on Biden's likelihood of legalizing it and the subsequent boom, but there are stock that literally have no products, a single employee and the entirety of the volatility is based on random internet musings. Pump and dump is nothing new, of course, but the internet's ability to cascade this surely will have some implications for better or worse.
- prewett 6y agoOh, reality will have an impact, sooner or later. What happens when expectations are no longer attached to reality is "irrational exuberance", aka "a bubble". We're in the mania phase of the stock cycle. It's starting to feel like 2001 again: pet supplies ON THE INTERNET!!! Big money, big prizes, big expensive Superbowl ad! Partly the problem is that we're at the tail end of the business cycle, partly the Fed has been keeping interest rates low so anyone that needs yield (pensions, etc.) has to move out of bonds into stocks, and partly retail traders have been stuck at home spending their vacation money on the Robinhood casino. And stocks are up 30% on the year and 80% from the local minimum in March, so now everyone that is short on money says "I should play the market". Give it a year or so.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> Isn’t this how stock markets work? Actual company performance is just a relatively minor signal for the chicken. In my experience, actual company performance is a very huge signal. You just need to zoom out and look at longer timeframes. The stocks with the highest prices and gains over the long term are those with the highest profit and growth potential.
- mhh__ 6y agoLike Tesla? Wouldn't Tesla have to have a monopoly on the entire automotive industry to realise their P/E? And as for profit they don't make any at the moment, IIRC
- dEnigma 6y agoTesla just reported its first full-year profit last month, so that's no longer true.
- leoedin 6y agoTesla is probably overvalued, but it's also not as simple as Tesla == cars. They're also one of the leading players in grid level battery storage (a market that will be huge soon). I don't think any other auto manufacturer is involved in that.
- mhh__ 6y agoTesla still has to sell something like 21x more cars to match Toyota for example who they dwarf in market cap. Tesla are putting their eggs into cars which are extremely hard, and batteries which will be a commodity long before Tesla can extract enough value.
- valuearb 6y agoProbably? They grew only 22% last year and trade at over 25 times SALES.
- bsanr2 6y agoIIUC Tesla's value comes in part from failed bets against it. Investors looking to make a buck off its imminent failure were instead forced to pay out, in greater proportion, hedges made on those short bets, when it survived. The same thing happened with GME, just on a shorter time scale and with the completely out-of-context event of retail traders being shut out of the buy side of market trades for several days. We do not know what would have happened had GME continued to be freely traded on a day it had reached over $500 a share premarket.
- kortilla 6y ago> Is this the future of retail trading? Nope, this has happened many times throughout history. It doesn’t really persist for many reasons, one of the primary being how many people get burned on the dump phase of the pump and dump. The people that bought GME at $300 are not likely to return for more sick gains.
- 2bitencryption 6y ago> The people that bought GME at $300 are not likely to return for more sick gains. Unfortunately that sounds a lot like saying "The people who lose all their money at the casino are not likely to return to the casino," which... well...
- Bakary 6y agoIt doesn't just sound a lot like it. It is literally gambling.
- aikinai 6y agoSerious question, where do you draw the line between investing and gambling? The original case for GME was built on solid fundamentals and I’d say not really gambling even though you were going up against hedge funds trying to short it into bankruptcy. Buying in at $300 is almost certainly gambling. But where’s the line? Anything over book value? Anything over some PE ratio? If so, you basically can’t invest in anything these days.
- bsanr2 6y agoUncertainty based on incomplete data. With an investment, you have most of the data about a given venture as it stands at the moment in front of you; only the future is uncertain. With a gamble, you have profoundly incomplete information about the venture in its present state. This is often a feature for the "house", who can use this information asymmetry to manipulate odds. $300 wasn't gambling if you were throwing in based on an understanding of gamma and short squeezes and GME's standing on the week of the 25th. That information was complete and supported the thesis, "If I buy at $300/share I should be able to sell at a profit in the near future." (And,this turned out to be correct; selling before trading opened would have netted an up yo 65% return.) It was, however, ultimately a gamble, because of incomplete information about the solvency of retail brokerages (and the ability of "the house" to manipulate odds by increasing collateral requirements without explanation). Unfortunately, this revelation marks the entire financial market as essentially a casino.
- cj 6y agoFor every 1 retail investor you hear talking about how they made a million dollars on lucky trade, there are 10 people who lost just as much without publicizing it, and there are 1000 people who made a lot of money simply buying and holding "boring" index funds for long periods of time.
- ericmcer 6y agoI always think of this whenever a friend says they are trying day trading. A couple weeks later I will wonder how it went and realize it must have gone bad, because they would tell me if it went well lol.
- filoleg 6y ago>there are 10 people who lost just as much without publicizing it Ironically enough, that's why I like the spirit of WSB, because people readily post insane losses and celebrate them just as much as they celebrate wins (tagged under "loss porn" iirc). Discovering it years ago was what, imo, gave me a solid mindset when it comes to losses incurred by trading. I don't think that seeing only crazy wins without any crazy losses would have set me on the right track or allowed me to keep my mindset healthy. The fact that people there treat crazy losses just as normal and worthy of positive attention as crazy wins is imo the biggest gem and differentiator in the whole thing.
- lm28469 6y ago> Just what is the conclusion of this market insanity? That this is all a game. Stocks are completely decorrelated from value production and are mostly purely speculative vessels. We're in a weird limbo state that will probably crash hard sooner than later.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoHow are they decorrelated? The most valuable stocks are still those of companies that earn very large amounts of profit, or have lots of potential to grow.
- munk-a 6y agoIn theory stocks for valuable companies are valuable since you own a part of something valuable - however for that value to be liquidated without a trade to another party the company itself needs to be acquired. It turns out that valuable acquisitions happen pretty often in the tech space due to how undervalued the network effect is by the stock market but - when a normal company is acquired it is after having shed the majority of its value. Exiting the market in the final sense really only happens with failure - instead it's closer to an act of better against the failure of the company in question - believing it will remain solvent for a long period of time. That, at least, goes for dividendless stocks - for dividend stocks the math changes a bit and more valuable companies are valued since there is an expectation that they will continue to pay current - or higher - dividends for a long time with individuals still able to leave the market by pawning off their shares. But, at EOD - it's essentially the same math but with a bit of extra fudging in one category.
- xwdv 6y agoWrong. This market can stay irrational longer than most of us will be alive. Let that sink in, this is the new normal. You can either sit on the sidelines waiting for things to become "rational" and then invest feeling safe making rational 4% gains a year, or you can get in now and make real money. One thing is clear, when things rationalize and become "normal", many people who were investing now are still going to be sitting on their irrationally made gains while you dust off your cash and prepare to jump in.
- chiph 6y agoOne of the reasons r/wallstreetbets got created was they felt that the buy & hold strategy wasn't going to work for them (hurt from the crash of 2008, were being taken advantage of, general disillusionment, etc.), so they'd rather bet big and hope for a winner. The culture there celebrates winners, but they also admire the people who go down in flames. Personally, I am getting "dot-com" vibes from the market, back when lots of people lost money day-trading on companies with no value. I'm selling right now, not buying.
- f00zz 6y ago> "dot-com" vibes from the market Same, but with negative real interests rates all over the world I don't know where else I can park my savings. I've been buying low-volatility stocks in boring sectors (utilities, etc) that pay good dividends.
- kridsdale1 6y agoLand.
- chiph 6y agoThat depends on your timeframe, acceptance of risk, liquidity needs, and the other usual suspects. I will reevaluate my decision in about 6 months, so I'm happy to keep it in cash for now (earning bupkis, but very low risk and easily used to buy in again).
- dragonwriter 6y ago> When you have stock like $SNDL almost double in literally a day it seems rational to spend your time trying to find the next one than to do the tried and true method. Sure, it seems rational if you overestimate your likelihood of picking the right one in advance. Kind of like the lottery.