3 ms·
Guaranteed minimum income on a regular basis.
by arcticbull 6y ago
Guaranteed minimum income on a regular basis.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThat's welfare and benefits as they exist in Europe (at least in some countries). So when American speak of convoluted UBI systems do they in fact just mean having an European level of welfare state?
- thebean11 6y agoYes, it certainly wouldn't be "less" of a welfare state than the European countries you're referencing, that's pretty obvious. I don't think proponents of it are claiming otherwise. I'm not sure what you mean by convoluted though. To me it seems much less convoluted to the existing patchwork welfare we have in this country.
- Ekaros 6y agoWelfare in many cases is hugely bureaucratic. It is there, but it means things like filling forms and sending your bank statements every 3 months to be reviewed. Not to mention the unemployment benefits you must claim first which can take weeks to process with no payments. That is if you decide to take short job. I would see it to be much simpler just to take some basic level of current benefits and last resort benefits and just giving it to everyone. And then claiming it back in some way like higher income tax.
- benibela 6y agoIt is far too bureaucratic In Germany I can't get welfare, because I have too many savings. After graduating from university, I also could not get unemployment benefits because I had not earned enough when working as student. Last time my work contract / research grant was about to expire, they said I would not get unemployment benefits, because I need to have a valid government id and my id card was expired. My still valid passport would not count. Although the grant was renewed, so I did not need unemployment benefits. Now the grant is expiring again, and probably won't be renewed soon, so I applied again. I forgot I need to apply 3 months before expiration, so I only did it 1 month before. Now they want a copy of my work contract (which I do not have, because I seem to have lost the contract) as well as a attestation from my employer how long I have worked there (which I also do not have. The university said they will write one, but have not yet). Not sure what is going to happen now