2 ms·
The legal arguments are quite straightforward. Did Google copy Oracle's APIs? Yes, they did. Could they have chosen another form of expression of the ideas in t
by bitwize 6y ago
The legal arguments are quite straightforward. Did Google copy Oracle's APIs? Yes, they did. Could they have chosen another form of expression of the ideas in those APIs and arrived at the same technical result? Yes, they could. Was Oracle harmed by this copying? Yes they were. Therefore, Google violated copyright.
A finding not in favor of Oracle would call into question whether U.S. copyright law has any force at all. While software nerds may well be okay with this, people in literally every other field of creative endeavor -- art, music, literature, media -- may lose their shirts. And the hardest hit won't be Lady Gaga or other millionaires, it'll be the small time players.
There is no morally sensible universe in which the Supreme Court does not find for Oracle.
- LocalH 6y agoCopyright is so far away from the original ideals, that I honestly say "fuck em". If 28 years is not enough to make your money from your creative works, then too bad.