6 ms·
> Here's the current ethnic makeup of the PAC: > Three Latinas > Three white women > Two African Americans > One Asian American > One Pacific Islander > A
by throwaway894345 6y ago
> Here's the current ethnic makeup of the PAC:
> Three Latinas
> Three white women
> Two African Americans
> One Asian American
> One Pacific Islander
> All current members of the PAC are women. Brenzel would have been the only man, and he happens to be white.
How do you even parody this?
> About 33% of SFUSD students are Asian, 28% are Latino, 15% are white and 6% are African American. The school board argued that adding a white male would tip the balance in the PAC. Whites would then become the "dominating race."
What if we didn't encourage a world in which people identified with and advocated for their own race? I.e., you have some extra white people (or whatever race) on the board but it's not really a problem because they aren't lobbying for "white interests" (whatever that means). In what world is segregating everyone to their own racial lane going to deliver more equitable outcomes for individuals? Surely this is only going to enforce antiquated, racist ideas that race is a useful predictor for anything at an individual level (i.e., "I know everything I need to know about a person from their race"). Surely this is the very essence of racism? Do these people really not understand that they're being far more racist than their broader society? Or are they aware of their racism but using terms like "anti-racism" and "equity" deceitfully?
EDIT: Looks like TFA was flagged off of the front page, which is really too bad because this seems like a very important topic and very relevant to much of this forum (considering how frequently we deal with racial employment policies in tech or the broader BLM threads over the summer or general SF/SV happenings).
- brink 6y ago> What if we didn't encourage a world in which people identified with and advocated for their own race? Agreed. How on earth did the "Each race only looks out for their own kind" mentality get labeled as progressive?
- rsj_hn 6y agoBecause "Progressive" is about dismantling the incumbent policies and replacing them with your own policies. The advantages of this is that if you are a political leader, it's something you can hang your hat on to grab a leadership position rather than waiting for the incumbent to retire. But the price of this constant rejection of what your grandparents did is that if you yourself achieve the goal, then your own policies get dismantled by your crusading grandchildren. Take for example anti-trust, which sought to destroy the power of big trusts in the Teddy Roosevelt era -- and was itself destroyed by the progressive Watergate Democrats in the 70s, about 60 years later. All these anti-trust rules were considered old fashioned, obsolete, and policies of a discredited generation. They were called bigoted and not with the times. Or the social hygiene movement (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_hygiene_movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_hygiene_movement), another great crusading Progressive cause, that sought to make illegal prostitution, alcohol, public nudity, and other attacks on morals. Few remember that the Women's Temperance movement and the Women's Suffrage movement were part of the same movement, and the progressives of those days really wanted to build a virtuous society, in much the same way that the current crop of progressives is obsessed with virtue, or the 60s crop was also inordinately focused on being virtuous, except for them being virtuous required dismantling the laws of the previous virtue movement. All the moral purity laws from the social hygiene movement were dismantled by other progressives in the 60s-70s. Or the union rights movement which was triumphant during the FDRs period, but was systematically destroyed primarily by Democrats in the 1970s-1990s (Clinton putting the last nail in the coffin). Unions were viewed as bigoted, old fashioned, and not with the times. Similarly the civil rights movement of the 60s is being systematically dismantled by the culture warriors of the present era, who view color-blind policies as the legacies of a discredited generation, of bigotry, and not being with the times. The good news is that if our current pro-racism movement triumphs and the nation re-segregates, there is a good chance that grandchildren of the current generation will themselves dismantle that system as being old-fashioned and not-with-the-times. In either case, Progressivism needs to be viewed as an act of rebellion first, and the policies are whatever they need to be in order to rally the most people to the moral revolution.
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoThank you for taking the time to write out such a thought provoking comment. All too often movements will rewrite their history to show that their current beliefs have always been their beliefs. This part very interesting: >The good news is that if our current pro-racism movement triumphs and the nation re-segregates, there is a good chance that grandchildren of the current generation will themselves dismantle that system as being old-fashioned and not-with-the-times. Combine this with the ongoing "Great Sort" where people are more and more moving into areas that best conform to their value systems, it's possible that the country will break apart into smaller pieces before there's an opportunity for a future generation to reject the current obsession with identity labels. It's interesting to see how quickly a large share of the population has adopted the primacy of label collecting when for most of my life the phrase "I'm a person, not a label" was common, especially in progressive circles.
- erik_seaberg 6y ago> people are more and more moving into areas that best conform to their value systems, it's possible that the country will break apart into smaller pieces This used to be a role filled by states, when federal policies were kept limited in scope.
- cat199 6y ago> obsessed with virtue To point out making this claim, while also noting that what people consider 'virtue' changes, is implicitly treating relativist ethics as valid; Leaving this assumption unchallenged is a key part in enabling counter-productive 'inclusion' when it occurs; Similarly, it allows one group to define it's ideology as 'virtue' simply by being 'new' or 'modern' without needing to define 'why' it is virtue... (to note: This is not at all the same as, and I'm absolutely not saying that 'inclusion' is implictly counter-productive)
- BitwiseFool 6y agoI sense that for Progressives the pursuit of Equity means that "looking out for your own kind" is not racist for any group that is disadvantaged, underserved, or systematically oppressed.
- lm28469 6y agoIf you split groups based on enough variables every single one of us is part of a disadvantaged group. A fight which isn't directed in the right direction is a waste of time and resource. > "looking out for your own kind" is not racist If "your own kind" is based on """race""" [0], it is, no matter who's doing it. Words have meaning, either they apply to everyone or they don't apply at all. [0] aka ethnicity, skin color, &c. because "races" don't exist anywhere on earth other than in the US
- BitwiseFool 6y agoI no longer subscribe to the "words matter" philosophy, considering how fast and loose people on the left treat language in arguments. Remember when ICE was running "concentration camps"? > because "races" don't exist anywhere on earth other than in the US Race doesn't exist, except when it does for BIPOC or when talking about the concept of Blackness or whiteness. You're probably thinking, those aren't races those are ethnicities! But what does it matter? These are terms used to separate people into groups and even if you switch the words the concept remains. If you're saying I'm using Race/Ethnicity incorrectly just know that on every form I have ever filled out about demographics race was a choice from "African, Asian, Caucasian, etc." and Ethnicity was only two options, "Hispanic/Latino or Non Hispanic/Latino".
- lm28469 6y ago> how fast and loose people on the left treat language in arguments. Not even one sentence in and we already in a "left vs right" argument... Newspeak isn't a leftist thing, it's a "people who know the power of words" thing > Remember when ICE was running "concentration camps"? It's just as despicable when it's coming from one or the other, and that why you shouldn't side with either > But on every form I have ever filled out race was a choice from "African, Asian, Caucasian, etc." And this is exactly why we should reappropriate words and their meaning, and not fall into the trap of complete deconstruction of language(s)
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoI don't think it's that "Each race only looks out for their own kind" - but I think there's a lot of people that feel excluded and want someone of their own kind on boards to make sure that they aren't continually excluded. I won't comment on what's fair (who am I but a drop?). But I think that's the viewpoint.
- floor2 6y agoYes, that's the viewpoint. That viewpoint is also incredibly racist. A phrase like "want someone of their own kind" is something I expect to hear from a KKK member. My "own kind" includes people of all races, religions, genders, and ethnicities. If you separate people based on their race, don't trust people based on their race, etc, you're a racist.
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoPoor analogy. What you would hear from the KKK is that the school board would be 100% white Christian males, and they don't want anyone who isn't one of them. There is a difference between wanting representation and wanting to exclude all other representation. There is a difference between men thinking no women deserve a seat on the board, and women demanding equal seats on the board. Again - I won't comment on what is fair. But I will draw a line between the difference.
- lm28469 6y agoimho we somehow got tricked into fighting each-other instead of fighting the system(s) which created inequalities. It's the same thing with "white male privileges", when you start fighting literal "white males" in general and not "the system which is biased against females/people of color" you already lost, no matter how much energy you put in the fight. I'd even say the more energy you put in the fight the more you'll lose, both politically and humanly People at the bottom of the ladder are equally fucked no matter if they're white, black, &c. while the people at the top are thriving like never before and doing everything they can to stay in charge. There is an insane amount of hate in a lot of people these days, hate generated by decades, if not centuries, of abusive systems, it should be redirected toward meaningful goals instead of these meaningless token achievements. Reading and learning about modern progressivism feels like a parody of previous civil right movements. People have all the reasons to be upset, some people more than other, that being said the fight should be vertical, right now it is mostly horizontal. We have to think in term of classes, not races, otherwise we're heading towards self destruction
- foofoo4u 6y ago> What if we didn't encourage a world in which people identified with and advocated for their own race? It saddens me to see the woke ideology taking hold across the United States. It is indeed fundamentally racist and brings us back to our most tribalistic behaviors. It's the kind of thinking we learned a long time ago to put in the past. But now it's making a resurgence. And it's spreading. But articles like [this](https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/09/world/europe/france-threat-american-universities.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/09/world/europe/france-threa...) and the most upvoted comments within it give me hope that the west hasn't become entirely mad. It seems the French have observed the discourse of modern American events and see how decisive and destructive the ideology is. I'll quote the top comment within this particular article. > Yes, importing the American political correctness/woke/cancel culture will destroy France. How do I know this? Because it is already destroying the US. It fuels social division, and it distracts from the real problems, which tend to be economic and environmental. Much of the recent scholarship coming from the US, obsessed about race and gender, is completely useless and extremely ideological. It is no wonder that many of the most important books of global interest from recent years, such as Picketty's Capital in the 21st Century, do not come from the US. US universities are not free environments of vigorous intellectual debate anymore, and the faculty lives under constant fear of uttering the wrong word or phrase, and of being canceled because of their ideas. If a child of mine decided to study social sciences or a humanities field, the US would the last place I would send them to. I'm glad France is standing up against this nonsense. It gives me hope.
- ng12 6y ago> Because it is already destroying the US. It fuels social division, and it distracts from the real problems, which tend to be economic and environmental I think about this a lot. I don't think it's a coincidence that most of the countries lauded for their economic equity or environmental leadership are also largely homogenous societies. I don't know what the answer is for a fundamentally multicultural country like the US but obsessing about race and "representation" surely isn't it.
- throwaway894345 6y ago
- majormajor 6y ago> What if we didn't encourage a world in which people identified with and advocated for their own race? I think you're flipping cause and effect here. We can see plenty of examples in the history of the US of people, when left otherwise unencumbered, either ignored the needs of others at best or put their own race first at worst. The idea of segregation isn't being introduced here, existing segregation and related behaviors are being responded to. They aren't saying "this man is unable to perform this role due to his race" in a racist-against-this-person way, they're putting additional structural checks in place as a preventative measure. So here people are trying to make that structurally more difficult. Which is arguably a more realistic and rational choice than simply saying "things will be fine if we get better people."
- throwaway894345 6y agoI understand what you're saying, and to be clear I'm not suggesting that woke progressives invented segregation. But the racial lanes that divided us historically have been progressively weakened--indeed, "racial progress" is largely synonymous with desegregation. So the idea that we can make racism/segregation "structurally more difficult" by reinforcing racial lanes is completely paradoxical. Can we not agree that categorizing people by their race is going to reinforce their racial identity at the expense of a broader collective human/national identity? And can we not agree that reinforcing racial identities and weakening the collective identity is going to create competition among and animosity between the different racial groups? And can we not agree that it is this racial animosity that births all of the evils of racism? If we can agree here, then surely this does the opposite of making segregation/racism "structurally more difficult"? > Which is arguably a more realistic and rational choice than simply saying "things will be fine if we get better people." Desegregation isn't "things will be fine if we get better people"; it's the active dissolving of racial lanes ("dismantling racist structures" might be a good phrase if it weren't coopted to mean the exact opposite). And it has been the only thing that has worked so far, so why should we think that it's a worse choice than segregation?
- griffinheart 6y agoI don't disagree with a lot of your above reply, but this part in particular picked my interest, mostly because I don't understand how its not racist. > They aren't saying "this man is unable to perform this role due to his race" in a racist-against-this-person way, they're putting additional structural checks in place as a preventative measure. Its not about the intention of the emitter, its about the receiving end of it. It seems that if we flip this so that the receiving end is part of a minority we would all think this is utterly racist independent of the intention, how is it not? edit: typo
- suzzer99 6y agoIt's San Francisco, and big city school boards have always been utterly terrible. Hyper-liberal cities and universities have been doing ridiculous loopy stuff since basically forever. My uncle used to always complain about some ridiculous thing universities or San Francisco was doing, in the pre-internet 80s, when you had to read about it in American Spectator or someone's newsletter. I don't get how people think stuff like this is some existential threat - when we have much bigger very real problems in this country, like 30% of the population thinks the election was rigged, and armed militias are flexing their muscle taking over statehouses. It's a very weird form of focusing on the molehill and ignoring the mountain imo. Like walk me through how this kind of nonsense is this ever going to spread to Johnson County, KS - as opposed to being contained in hyper-liberal enclaves. I can walk you through a lot of scenarios as to how the stuff I mentioned above is a real existential threat to our democracy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ghiculescu 6y agoThe problem is that the people in SF are doing things that many people find divisive and dumb. But the same people are seen as in control of media, universities, tech etc - things that impact everyone. If you’re in Johnson City, KS, this happening in your country feels like it impacts you even if it’s in a hyper liberal enclave.
- suzzer99 6y agoHow does the SF school board have anything to do with the media? This seems like really digging hard for something to be mad about.
- ghiculescu 6y agoIt doesn’t, directly. But if you’re far away from SF and all you see is this headline, it reads as “the ruling class did some dumb woke stuff again”. How can you respect them? How can you be confident the wokeness won’t spread?
- silicon2401 6y agoI agree entirely. Lots of people calling out racism are themselves acting fundamentally racist in the sense of racially prejudiced and discriminatory. I won't be surprised if I wake up one day and we have race-specific water fountains again.
- undefined1 6y agosegregation is already being practiced in schools. here's an example: https://www.bwscampus.com/our-community/commitment-to-diversity/inclusive-excellence/dialogue-community-building-sessions https://www.bwscampus.com/our-community/commitment-to-divers...
- foofoo4u 6y ago> I won't be surprised if I wake up one day and we have race-specific water fountains again. We already have: Race-specific clubs on Universities.[1]; Race-specific departments on Universities.[2]; Race-specific video playlists on YouTube. [3]; Race-specific filters for map apps. [4]; Race-specific brands [5]; Race-specific merchandise [6]; Race-specific professional feeds [7]; Race-specific video channels [8.1][8.2]; Race-specific graduations [9]; I could go on endlessly with this list. You see the trend. America is socially segregating itself. So the concern you raise with race-specific water fountains is valid. Though that form of segregation, specifically, may not return, but other forms will. [1] https://www.linkedin.com/company/bbsasfsu/about/ https://www.linkedin.com/company/bbsasfsu/about/ [2] https://equity.sfsu.edu/blackunitycenter https://equity.sfsu.edu/blackunitycenter [3] https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLbpi6ZahtOH5pZK-VXFwjwCzuwaMgIR0g https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLbpi6ZahtOH5pZK-VXFwj... [4] https://blog.google/outreach-initiatives/small-business/black-history-month-2021/ https://blog.google/outreach-initiatives/small-business/blac... [5] https://www.target.com/c/black-owned-or-founded-brands-at-target/-/N-q8v16 https://www.target.com/c/black-owned-or-founded-brands-at-ta... [6] https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2021/01/apple-celebrates-black-history-month/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2021/01/apple-celebrates-blac... [7] https://www.linkedin.com/news/daily-rundown/special-edition/ https://www.linkedin.com/news/daily-rundown/special-edition/ [8.1] https://www.netflix.com/browse/genre/81299227?so=su https://www.netflix.com/browse/genre/81299227?so=su [8.2] https://www.hulu.com/black-stories https://www.hulu.com/black-stories [9] https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/red-alert-politics/more-than-75-colleges-host-blacks-only-graduation-ceremonies https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/red-alert-politics/more-t...
- golemiprague 6y agoJust looking at the list and the grouping, it is such a warped worldview, Latin define people who speak a group of languages but only if they are south to the US in the American continent. White is a skin colour but includes all the range up to brown, as long as they don't live south to the US (or is it? If you are Italian from Italy you are white but if you are Italian from Argentina you are Latino? Or do you have to be slightly mixed with native to become Latino?). African American includes only black people, but not other Africans from north Africa who are not black. Asian includes all east Asians but not sub continental or middle Eastern. It is just a crazy mix of codes to group people by a combination of characteristics which they themselves not only see but the Americans are very sure about them. It is just nuts.
- leetcrew 6y agosometimes the process of making a decision is just as important as whatever decision ultimately gets made. sometimes a tough decision has to get made and the tradeoff is that your ingroup takes a hit. the impact is the same either way, but it doesn't feel as bad if someone from your group was at least involved in the process. people already segment themselves into many different in/out-groups. institutions sometimes take this to a ridiculous level, but we have to account for this somehow.