3 ms·
It’s also strange that HN is so eager to weaponize copyright for their own agenda. It’s strange that so many people are arguing for using copyright law against
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
It’s also strange that HN is so eager to weaponize copyright for their own agenda.
It’s strange that so many people are arguing for using copyright law against the cop, instead of realizing that it’s absurd that we have to think about having videos taken down for background music.
That said, I’m not even convinced that background music can get the videos taken down, since we’ve all been watching these videos on social media platforms for the past few days.
- rriepe 6y agoWhat purpose would realizing the absurdity serve, again? It might be absurd that someone is shooting bullets at you but you should shoot back if that's the case.
- floor2 6y agoYour analogy is perfect... for showing why this is wrong. The "shooting back" solution just ends up with a bunch of people injured (likely including random bystanders). The better solution is to get the shooting to stop entirely. We don't need to find a new interpretation of copyright law to attack the cop, we need to remove the dysfunctional copyright system that started this. Or in your metaphor, I want no-one to get shot rather than wanting to shoot back.
- rriepe 6y agoYou're conflating outcomes and solutions. You've offered no solution.
- ceejayoz 6y agoIt's less "copyright law is good" than "copyright law is already being used against us so it might as well be turned around on them a bit".
- mindslight 6y ago... which is a terrible approach, because it validates the cudgel while not actually addressing the dynamic of unaccountable power.
- exporectomy 6y agoWhat are they fighting for if they don't stand up for any principles and are willing to do the same bad things their enemies do? Even if they win, they've become a new baddy.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoWho is “them” though? The police officer in this video (which hasn’t been taken down anywhere, as far as I can tell) isn’t the record label.