3 ms·
I think Betteridge’s law of headlines is relevant here; If these videos were being removed by social media, we’d be hearing about the removals. Instead, we have
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
I think Betteridge’s law of headlines is relevant here; If these videos were being removed by social media, we’d be hearing about the removals. Instead, we have journalists asking “Are cops playing music to use copyright law to have the videos removed?” We then watch the non-removed videos.
I’m not thrilled about this, but I’m not entirely convinced that police officers are trying to get videos taken down by playing tinny, low-volume songs in the background of someone else’s videos.
Does anyone have an example of a video that was taken down because police were playing music in the background?
I’ve been seeing these videos over and over in the past 24 hours on various streaming platforms. It seems that if they were being taken down, we’d be hearing stories about the takedowns, not stories about them listening to music.
- jawns 6y agoCan you propose some other legitimate purpose for their actions? I don't regularly see police officers playing music on their cell phones during the course of their official duties, nor do I see any reason why they should. Edit: To response to your edited comment, I don't think the problem with this conduct hinges on whether YouTube or other video-streaming services actually do flag them as copyright infringement and filter them. The problem is that the officers are attempting to trigger the sites' filtering algorithms. Whether or not they're successful, it's still a problem.
- klyrs 6y agoI can see another purpose for their actions. If they're playing music, then bodycam or external recordings will not capture what is being said by cops and those that they're interacting with. I didn't say it's a legitimate purpose, mind...
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoSeems like they’re trying to send a signal that they’re not interested in engaging in any more conversation. Feels like a de-escalation tactic. Whether you like them or not, these cops have people obsessively following them around, filming them, and trying to engage them for social media clout. I suspect if the filters had more of a legitimate purpose, we’d be hearing about it in these articles.
- jawns 6y agoIt feels like a de-escalation tactic? This is pretty classic passive-aggressive behavior. And aggressive behavior, whether in the form of overt aggression or passive-aggressive tactics, does not contribute to de-escalation. Recording police in public as they perform their official duties is a constitutionally protected activity, upheld by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, whose jurisdiction covers California. The police are trying to deter and prevent people from exercising that right. The mature way to send a signal that they're not interested in engaging in conversation is to say, "I'm sorry, I'm not interested in engaging in any more conversation. I've got to attend to the duties of my job. It was nice talking with you." I do acknowledge that police officers often face special scrutiny from the press and from the public. But that is because they are public servants with the ability to impinge upon people's life and liberty. And the more the public records LEO interactions, the more bad apples they seem to uncover.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoIn the video (which hadn’t been taken down, contrary to the headlines) the officer does what you suggest: He calmly states that he can’t continue to engage the person recording in the same conversation over and over again. This doesn’t appear to be a simple case of the police ignoring someone’s first question. The person recording the police appears to be following them around, recording them, badgering them with accusations and taunts, and posting the videos for social media clout.
- tpmx 6y agoBetteridge’s law of headlines ìs probably not true: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9232419 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9232419 (The way you invoked this is kinda reaching.)
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoI brought it up to highlight the contradiction, not because it’s literally a law: They are reporting speculation. If this was happening, they’d be reporting on the takedowns rather than the speculation. Instead, the video is still up and available on social media.
- tpmx 6y agoThat's a better way to put it, IMO.
- anaerobicover 6y agoDon't exclude the middle: they could be trying to get them filtered, and failing at doing so. I can easily see a coworker having a "brilliant" idea about copyright mumbo jumbo and a bunch of people buying into it. People try things that don't work all the time.