5 ms·
I know everyone is looking for a loophole to prosecute these officers But let’s not rush to make listening to music on the job illegal. That wasn’t the intent
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
I know everyone is looking for a loophole to prosecute these officers
But let’s not rush to make listening to music on the job illegal. That wasn’t the intent of copyright laws that prohibit public performance.
- SilasX 6y agoAgreed, but I think it's at least a defensible case if you activate the music specifically and only when you know you're being recorded for a mass audience.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoSo the officers just claim they always listen to music? Or that they were simply trying to send a message that they were done with the conversation with someone who is following them around on the job? Which seems to be the case here, honestly. Or that they didn’t know that a random person with a phone had a massive YouTube following combined with intent to post this video online? I know everyone wants to stick it to these cops, but let’s be realistic. Normally HN is very against weaponizing copyright law, but the second it feels useful for their purposes we’re flooded with comments from people who want to misuse copyright law as a weapon.
- bmicraft 6y agoMaybe they should turn it down a bit while on the job? There is no reason the music should to be heard outside their car.
- mc32 6y agoHmmm, I’d like to see this applied to many a teenager eager to have me listen to their choice of music for free from afar.
- monocasa 6y agoI hold police to a higher professional standard than I do lackadaisical teenagers.
- mc32 6y agoBoth are playing music loudly and projecting it openly. Either it’s allowed for all or allowed for none. I’m good with either decision as long as it’s consistent.
- rootusrootus 6y agoMy employer expects me to keep my music quiet (preferably confined to my ears only) when I am at the office. At home I can play it loud enough that the neighbors can hear it, and that's okay. I'm fine with professional officers being held to different standards when they are on duty.
- mc32 6y agoWhat about a job site? Can they play loudly if the company or the foreman or forewoman allows it? Is it unprofessional if they play it loudly?
- monocasa 6y agoA jobsite has different and looser standards of professional conduct than what the police should be generally held to, yes.
- mc32 6y agoI don’t think the cruiser is subject to your elevated standards. This is a classic case of double standards. We want one set of standards god people we agree with and another set of standards for people we disagree with. To avoid this, we institute a standard across the board for everyone, like them or dislike them.
- sjg007 6y agoIt's probably against policy to listen to music while on the beat and definitely when interacting with the public.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoOn the contrary, I wouldn’t be surprised if this was a de-escalation tactic for dealing with stalkers. If you watch the video (which is available in the previous article and all over social media, contrary to the narrative) it’s clear that the person is trying to get a rise out of the police officers by following them around and badgering them for content on his social media channels. He even went so far as to watermark the video with his social media handles. It’s clear that the officers are tired of dealing with him and being followed around while trying to do their jobs.
- monkmartinez 6y agoI totally agree with you. There are lots of people that do this to EMS as well. Fortunately, I have HIPPA to get these people away from scenes. Unfortunately, there are a ton of people that have nothing better to do than film/jibe/harangue police and fire/EMS in the course of their duties. We know a lot of them on a first name basis including bday, medical history and how many times we have given them narcan... as we often find them with needles in their arms overdosed.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> Fortunately, I have HIPPA to get these people away from scenes. HIPAA, and you don't. (I'm sure the claim works on people, though.) https://www.ems1.com/ems-products/cameras-video/articles/photojournalist-5-tips-for-managing-the-media-on-ems-scenes-nG0R3Q59XlzaPZZu/ https://www.ems1.com/ems-products/cameras-video/articles/pho... > Your basic HIPAA obligation when it comes to the press is very simple. Don't divulge any patient medical information to a journalist. Don’t discuss patient specifics within hearing or recording distance, at least not in great detail. Don’t write notes where they can be read. If you have a clipboard with medical information, turn it over so it can’t be seen in a photograph. > Your HIPAA obligation does not, however, require you to stop me or others from taking images at the scene. Can you keep them at a somewhat reasonable distance? Yes. Out of the scene entirely? Generally no, barring a hazmat incident or something where you'd need to be getting out too.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> So the officers just claim they always listen to music? > Or that they were simply trying to send a message that they were done with the conversation with someone who is following them around on the job? Which seems to be the case here, honestly. > Or that they didn’t know that a random person with a phone had a massive YouTube following combined with intent to post this video online? They can claim those things, sure. But liability (especially civil liability, which is need only be established by preponderance of the evidence, not beyond a reasonable doubt like criminal liability) doesn't go away just because you can present a narrative which is possibly true which would provide an innocent explanation. Moreover, if a department pays the cost of litigating a couple cases where officers actions in this regard are challenged, they'll have a strong incentive to adopt policies which prevent the dispute from occurring.
- tonyg 6y ago> Normally HN is very against weaponizing copyright law I mean, a good chunk of the people here are GPL fans, and if that's not a weaponization of copyright law, I don't know what is.
- gowld 6y agoThe police are being obnoxious but they are exploiting the streaming platforms and the rightsholders. That's where the problem is. It doesn't making any sense to ask the rightsholders to pressure the police to stop using a tactic that only works because the rightholders want it to work.
- RIMR 6y agoI think it's more important to focus on is the rationality of enforcing copyright law against music captured in the background of a video. Fair use should be much more broad. So long as the video isn't produced for profit, the producer isn't unfairly benefitting off the presence of the music in the video, and the quality of the audio doesn't compete with that of a commercial recording, I don't see the issue.
- 1MoreThing 6y agoThese rules were created specifically because so many people were profiting off the ad revenue of music in videos. There's not a simple way to determine if the audio just happens to be in the background or if the content producer is benefiting from the inclusion of music they don't have rights to.
- gowld 6y agoIt's trivial: demonetize the video, or extract the standard license fee from the ad revenue. YouTube already knows how to do this.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoYeah, because I know that when I am trying to speak clearly to another human being in an emotionally heightened situation, I always do it while listening to my favorite jams.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThe person doing the recording operates multiple Instagram accounts where he tries to provoke reactions from cops who are trying to do their job. He sells anti-police merchandise through these accounts. It’s not correct to suggest that this was a routine interaction with police. Despite the headline, the videos are still up on his social media accounts.
- phjesusthatguy3 6y agooh stop
- woah 6y agoAre you serious? You’re telling me you think police officers should go around blasting tunes on a boom box? Seems like a serious lack of professionalism. What a straw man
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoNo, I did not say that at all. The videos in question are still online. They haven’t been removed. It’s clear that the person filming is following police around, trying to provoke a reaction for his Instagram accounts where he sells anti-cop merchandise.
- dahart 6y ago> let’s not rush to make listening to music on the job illegal. I’m wondering if it already is illegal for police officers who wear body cams, even when their routine video is not public record. They are recordings intended for other people, and they also can become public record when use of force is involved, as I understand it.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoAs far as I can tell, these recordings are from an uninvolved 3rd party who has several social media accounts dedicated to recording the police, from which he sells merchandise. This isn’t a case of victims being drowned out of rightful conversations during arrests. This is a 3rd party trying to insert themselves into police duties and provoke a response while recording. His Instagram accounts for these videos promote his anti-cop merchandise. It appears the videos haven’t actually been taken down. I’m sure he’s loving the attention, though.
- narrator 6y agoWatch the cops just pay the ASCAP fee. That's the fee the music industry makes bar owners pay if they want to play music in their bar.